I've just been looking at my remaining AH1-era skins and I did reskin all the small parts from scratch. There really isn't any other way to make those parts look good. However I wouldn't do all that work now for a buggy, low poly shape that might have a lifetime of a year or two at best before its replaced.
I'd object to anyone filling slots with these sort of cut and paste skins on an AH2 model. However I can't see the problem doing it with an old AH1 shape like this unless HTC just don't want to set a precedent for allowing it.
Exactly. Except, if that is really HTCs problem with it (which I think is an understandable, reasonable and defensible position to take) then why not come out and say that? I would prefer that to Skuzzy publically impugning my judgement and ability as a skinner.
It was exactly one of the reasons I was so open about what I was doing. I wanted anyone and everyone to voice any objections they had before I spent a lot of time on it. Instead, I received positive comments and encouragement to continue. So I did end up wasting my time on them.
I even had a discussion with Skuzzy privately about my concerns for showing proper credit to the original skinners. Again, it was an opportunity to tell me not to continue with this; that these skins would not be accepted.