The ability of this community to debate any subject into inanity is legendary. Suggestions piled on ideas piled on foundation of the bodies and minds of PLAYERS. HiTech, you got to decide what to do, not the community. People here will continue to choose what they are doing right NOW and you can see how that works.
The bottom line is this.
1. THE GAME KEEPS SHRINKING. Anyone who believes otherwise has their head firmly tucked into the sand.
2. The game keeps shrinking because it becomes less fun than reruns on TV. That is the competition in this age set and a low bar.
3. ENY makes people log off because it shrinks the pool of players for WHATEVER REASON. You can attack the messenger or see what is.
4. ENY is a condition of AH, when ENY or anything else is too onerous people will watch TV.
5. HTC what are you going to do? It is ok that the answer is more of the same but keep in mind it gave us the game of today.
6. This is a suggestion, do what you want. If you do what you want till the place is empty, that is your prerogative.
7. Marking out the planes you can't fly put a bandaid on a spurting artery. It didn't solve the problem.
You gotta be smarter than the debate. You will always find someone to represent the tiny number of users doing something. You have to decide what will make this game grow. There will be lots of people standing by the grave of AH if it tanks saying, "If they only did what I had in my head" but few of them have ever been game designers or ever will be. Believe it or not but its has been obvious where things are headed for YEARS. You live and die by your choices. If you want things to be different you have to make different choices. Look at the trail of choices leading to here and do something different that what has always been.
I will respectfully suggest that the graphics upgrade didn't do it to the extent that is needed by itself. AH3 is not close to regaining the former glory of 800 people in an arena.
I'll humbly suggest that this game needs working change, not more debate. The debate in this community leads right here.
Thanks!