Went the muscle car route in the 70's. FUN! Great appeal to the eye, but only good in a 1/4 mile...bring a muscle car up to 140 mph, or try negotiating a 20 mph curve at 60, and they suck (Most suck, there are a few, like Corvettes, that do okay).
I prefer the best of both worlds, quick acceleration, great cornering, excellent handling at top end:

Priced good (under $40,000), good 0-60 time (5.9 seconds) good top speed (155) good HP (225 hp, 214lbs. torque)and not a bad 1/4 mile time (13.9 seconds)