I have been a Warbirds guys for 4 years and I have been playing Aces High for a week now.
Here are my thoughts
Good...1. Planes fall apart when I shoot them (I really like the 1:1 bullet modelling and damage they do.
2. Good choice of planes as of 1.09 nice to see some early war stuff coming in.
3. FM's "feel" good for the few planes I have flown (most time in the corsair, rolls very well)
4. Combat trim nice for flying to the fight, and I can turn it off for landing and dogfighting.
5. Graphics are good and I like the tracers, strange the first couple sorties but very cool now.
6. 450 people in the arena when I come on at night woohoo!

7. Pilot getting hurt very cool, had no idea it was there until I started blacking out.
8. Maning guns on ships
9. Flying with the old squadies again...even lazs
Not so good...1. AH voice I like it but, according to my squadmates my voices is very low. I tried changing setting in AH and in windows to no avail, once I can get this sorted out it will be in my good column.
2. auto 6 call, don't like it at all, it takes surprise pounces away.
3. I get a few too many warps when cons are about d1 away.
4. no right-click 6 call
indifferent1. ground vehicles and bombers, I don't use ground vehicles and I haven't tried bombers yet.
ConclusionI am staying.