On that same fateful day, Oyster flight of the 555th TFS engaged 4 MiG-21s and killed 3 of them. However, its flight leader, Major Robert Lodge, was shot down and became MIA while trying to kill the 4th MiG

"Steve" Ritchie and Chuck DeBellevue killed one of the MiG-21s and went on to become 2 of the 3 USAF aces. It is interesting to note that the USAF scored the majority of its F-4 kills with the AIM-7 Sparrow, which the Navy claimed was too difficult to use. Of course the Navy had developed improved versions of the AIM-9 Sidewinder that were almost as good as the modern versions and made Duke Cunningham's 3-kill day much more feasible. If the MiG-19s had not shown up to shoot down Major Lodge, it would have been his 2nd kill for the day and 4th kill overall using Sparrows. I always think of both Showtime and Oyster whenever the day May 10 is in the spotlight.
Go here for the story of Major Lodge's WSO, Roger Locher, and how he set records during his escape and evasion:
http://www.afa.org/magazine/valor/0392valor.htmlGo here for an exceptional bio on Ritchie including a fairly good description of May 10 from Oyster flight's perspective:
http://www.centennialjournal.com/Mar02/SteveRitchieTheLastAce.htmThat is the first time I have ever read anything about why Robert Lodge didn't eject

He stayed with the aircraft to protect classified information that could be tortured out of him.