I posted this because I recently bought IL2 (Getting smarter now, wait a year for all the fixes, patches) and I agree its a fine sim. It should be considering it was 3 years in the developing...however, it certainly won't replace AH for online simming for me.
I'm one of those that Hitech's markets reaches too, a nice mix between gameplay concessions, and realism. The big thing for me is direct 6 views, on a computer screen, where one has no peripherial vision, or ability to loosen the harness, lean forward, and crank your neck around to get alittle better rear view, I feel its absolutely necessary to have at least *some* 6 view. I also feel that those that dislike direct 6 views *need* them and the subsequent "element of surprise" in order to get kills. not having a direct six view, you end up with everyone flying high, looking for unaware lower pilots. Thats just me though.
If it doesn't have a 6 view, I don't fly it online.
Incidently, I can't get my views to "snap view" in IL2, anyone know why?