I just want to add that I have had no problems with my Cougar since I got it in April. The only problems that I have had deal with windows reassigning controller id's at whim and pissin me off. But, that is not a Cougar issue, I think it is more of a CH/Windows issue (I use CH Pro Pedals).
Was it worth the money? To me, yeah, it was. I can't see myself getting another stick anytime in the near future (several years I would guess). I was fortunate enough to have a friend give me a set of pedals so I didn't have to shell out more $$$ for them.
Anyways, I am satisfied with the Cougar, much mroe than I ever was with the Saitek stuff. I can't comment on the CH stuff since I have never owned any CH stuff since the original Flightstick (you know, the 2 button with throttle slider on it). I have a feeling I would still have it if I didn't break it a couple times.