Nah, my bet is he is sitting in some Egyptian or Israeli cellar right now.
Problem is, US intel needs some information really fast, and while there are better interrogation methods than torture if you have enough time, if you need answers fast... Well, lets just say you dont have the time to break him down with sleep depravation or sensory depravation combined with drugs. And right now there are alot of questions that needs fast answers.
The US will have its back free anyway "what do you mean...WE didnt torture him", since there wont be any US agents doing the actual work on him...besides, the Egyptians or Israelis are better at that.