Guys, guys, guys...
Sigh... here are the rules.
If a Republican is in office, and the market goes up, its not a good indicator of the economy. The inverse is also true; if the market goes down, it is, indeed, a good indicator of the economy.
If a Democrat is in office, and the market goes up, its a fantastic indicator of the economy. The inverse is also true, but with a twist; if the market goes down, not only is it not an indicator of the economy, but its the previous Republican office holder's fault.
I blame my parents.