Originally posted by Otto
You are now six times more likely to be mugged in London than New York. Why? Because as common law appreciated, not only does an armed individual have the ability to protect himself or herself but criminals are less likely to attack them. They help keep the peace. A study found American burglars fear armed home-owners more than the police. As a result burglaries are much rarer and only 13% occur when people are at home, in contrast to 53% in England.
Otto, I agree with your statement - in part. In the mid 1990s I was working in London, and also spent a great deal of time in New York. Yes, I actually felt safer in New York, and have expressed this to many people I know. But I do not agree that it's because people are allowed to walk around with guns in New York. (Is NY a conceal/carry state?) The real reason is policing. Britain is cutting back on policing to save money. Tony Blair's government has got itself into a pickle because the existing tax structure cannot support its spending plans, and they don't want to raise income tax. So they implement "stealth taxes" and cutbacks - and policing is one. My village used to have a police station - not any more. The council claims we can't even afford a traffic warden - so the village is blighted with illegal parking. Our jails are full, so Lord avacadoHead Derry Irvine has been urging judges not to send burglars to jail. And corporal punishment was abolished in schools in 1986 - followed by a collapse in discipline and a steep rise in juvenile crime - car break-ins, joy riding etc.
Compare that with New York - many more (33%) police officers deployed on the streets of NYC under the Giuliani-Bratton partnership. You'd see them everywhere - street corners, down the subways, on the trains, always in pairs... Many a time coming up from the W 86th St. subway stop (1 & 9 line) I would see police with a suspect in handcuffs. The NY police took a very tough line - even guys urinating in the street would get carted off.
Sure, the NY police are armed, but so are many London police these days. And of the many, many people I met in New York, not one single one owned a gun. I gues I was amongst a bunch of typical elitist limo liberals - LOL.
New York may be safer (up to about 107th Street) than London, but I don't agree that it's because of arming the citizens. The key is policing, and a tough stance on quality of life and other relatively minor crimes. The theory is that this will deter people from moving on to more major crimes, and the results would seem to bear out this theory.
Sandman! It's the reaction that counts!

My attention seeking has been well sated in this thread - muhahahaha.
