ZENMS got tired of black-outs, so he said:
Create a "Relaxed Realism" version, as AW had, and let the hardcore pilot wannabe's live for FR as usual. This will get many new clients, and give the ones who are not yet skilled a place to fly, where they can do more than become points for someone else.
I can see your reasoning, but not sure I would go along with it.
You actually address 3 things:
(a) rookies are fodder for vets - this is going to be true for any multiplayer game. My submariner buddy used to whup me in Nintendo games when I'd visit him between cruises, because he'd been playing below the ocean for months on end. An AH vet that's been playing for months shouldn't possess the same skill as a guy on his 2-week free trial period, and shouldn't find himself ham-strung by simple-to-learn airplanes. If a guy can master a game in 2 weeks, then what's the incentive to subscribe? A game should have a built-in learning curve to it; it should have room in it for player growth. Otherwise it will go stale.
(b) learning curve - AH has a good library of vehicles from which to choose. Its easy to get a Spitfire, FM2, and N1K2 into a fight and maybe even get a kill on your first flight. Learning the game commands takes a bit longer, but that's going to be true for a RR arena as well. Just because RR might take away stalls and g-force blackouts doesn't mean the basic menu system would be simpler. Besides, Spitfire, FM2, and N1K2s are the most stall-friendly planes in the group and are easy to fly. Plus, there's the anti-stall option that can be selected, plus the auto-launch from the runway and the "combat trim" feature to further reduce pilot skill requirements.
(c) hardcore vs softcore pilots - I think you'll find the hardcore guys will be flying the more challenging planes, the planes that take an intuitive skill and experience to master, such as the P-47, the 109 and 190, F4U, P-51B, P-38, C.205, Ki-61, and such. The softcore guys will fly the user-friendly planes such as the Spitfire IX, N1K2, LA-7, and P-51D. If you find your Spitfire IX getting smacked down by a clown-tailed Ki-61, then you know you just got bested by a vet.