I'm with Pongo on this.. there are those that no matter how well I set up the shot.. no joy.
Best example that comes to mind is Hblair.. He'd chopped through two of my squaddies at low alt in a tense furball.. looked like it was a three v one.. the one was Hblair.
I was about d20 out.. low dots vis; and I'm listening to the fight ON RW as I come barreling in. As I get closer, the numbers aginst Hblair get even worse for him.. now it's five v 1. Hblair is in a 109; in the weeds. Three guys are tight on him working for a shot.. 2 in front of him. Hblair gets one; instantly reverses his turn.. the three over shoot, he get one of them. He reverses his turn again.. a roll-away, and as I get on him I take a shot.. it goes wide. He's reversed direction again.. gone low. He tags another and reverses his direction again. No manuver is smooth.. the direction his nose is pointed is NOT where he's going.
I see the cross control moves he's using now.. impossible to land a tracking shot.
I pull up and over the fight; literally get above him and roll inverted to see which way he goes.. two more guys are making tracking shot passes at him. Both miss. One augers.
Now; truly amazed I update SA.. still 4 of us on him.. and he's gotten at least 4 of us while I watched. All of them via superb evasives and gunnery, all from the bottom of the E envelope in a plane not noted fer turn-fighting in the weeds.
This is an agressive and exceptionaly alert pilot.. he knows when he's in my gun envelope and he knows how to fox a tracking shot with a sideslip.. not excessive; just enuff to force the shot wide, and he retains enuff 'e' to capitalise on the overshoot.
I drop down for my second pass.. and squirt a shot at where he's going, Pull up briskly; roll inverted and come back to where he went the last time.. anticipating the roll-away reverse.
There he is.. crossing up; setting himself up for my overshoot. I'd say about 50 yards off his left side and crossing fast.. and I have one snapshot opportunity at very close range. If i miss; I'm meat.. he's perfectly positioned for my overshoot. I can see interseting details.. the canopy frame.. the flaps.. the control surfaces defected.. all frozen in a frame of time; square in my gunsights. One shot opportunity.. 'miss it and yah die Hang'... I squeeze...
THATS what Pongo is talking about.. pilots that have their plane so well dialed in.. have their SA so well locked, know how to use defensive/offensive manuvers and know exactly when and how to switch from defense to offense that you MUST get in close.. unreasonably close, 'blow the shot and yah die close' to get him. He forces the situation, no matter how badly outnumbered he may be, into a 'come on in here, hugahunk, and I'll kill yah' situation.. you either get him on that pass or he gets you. You think you are in a comfortable 2 or 3 v one.. and suddenly find yourself in a 'kill or be killed knife fight' in a heartbeat.
Pongo.. I agree. Some of us can fly offense.. some are pretty good shots. But it's the guys that can switch from defense to offense in a spit second in time and can force an apparently easy shot wide
then capitalize on the overshoot that are the real killers in this sim. I defintly need to work on my defense.. and Hblair is an excelent teacher.

Salute Hblair. !
Hang