General Forums => The O' Club => Topic started by: AKKuya on December 27, 2025, 05:32:01 PM
Title: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: AKKuya on December 27, 2025, 05:32:01 PM
Sacrifices. I don't mean human sacrifices.
Utopia can be created. The problem is the utter resistance by those consumed with wealth and power. Those addictions are so powerful, that trying to break them would be a mountainous challenge.
The first hurdle is to break he bonds of supply and demand. That is the foundation of our financial civilization. Those chains are so heavy and thick, that snapping then would be impossible to many. That's where the first sacrifice comes into play. Billionaires and millionaires would have to agree for the removal of personal wealth. Wall Street and corporations would have to agree on no more profit and the elimination of stocks. Banks would have to close up shop. Money has to become obsolete.
How does anything get done?
The next sacrifice is the individual governments funded by the taxes and tariffs. A new system must be placed in that vacuum. Intellectuals become the new governing bodies based on their specific educational backgrounds and life experiences. That process will require much deliberation of specific criteria. Starting with towns and cities, the new organizational structure would grow into larger administrative regions until a global body has emerged. A great challenge to be undertaken.
How does individuals function?
This sacrifice is the easiest. Everyone has a job. The best part is anyone can choose to be a lowly worker or work up the ladder. Everyone has a place to live, clothes to wear, food in their belly, access to full medical treatment, and access to higher learning. Redundancy in a specific job is fully part of the system since money has no place. A restaurant has a full staff at all hours of operation. Maintenance has all the skilled employees to cover all areas of operation. There should be no shortages in manpower.
What about those who refuse to work?
The most delicate sacrifice of all. They will have to be taken to special designated areas. These areas are kept at primitive levels. Basic shelter, clothing and food with basic medical care provided by volunteer staff. They are not prisons but facilities to spur individuals into wanting a better way of life within the human civilization. A scared straight type of setting.
There are more issues and challenges to overcome. These are the basic examples to get the idea across. An individual can work as a janitor and still live life in luxury or get a higher education and still live a life in luxury. The way white collar and blue collar should exist in equalness.
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: RUSH1 on December 27, 2025, 05:49:23 PM
Utopia can be created. The problem is the utter resistance by those consumed with wealth and power. Those addictions are so powerful, that trying to break them would be a mountainous challenge.
The first hurdle is to break he bonds of supply and demand. That is the foundation of our financial civilization. Those chains are so heavy and thick, that snapping then would be impossible to many. That's where the first sacrifice comes into play. Billionaires and millionaires would have to agree for the removal of personal wealth. Wall Street and corporations would have to agree on no more profit and the elimination of stocks. Banks would have to close up shop. Money has to become obsolete.
How does anything get done?
The next sacrifice is the individual governments funded by the taxes and tariffs. A new system must be placed in that vacuum. Intellectuals become the new governing bodies based on their specific educational backgrounds and life experiences. That process will require much deliberation of specific criteria. Starting with towns and cities, the new organizational structure would grow into larger administrative regions until a global body has emerged. A great challenge to be undertaken.
How does individuals function?
This sacrifice is the easiest. Everyone has a job. The best part is anyone can choose to be a lowly worker or work up the ladder. Everyone has a place to live, clothes to wear, food in their belly, access to full medical treatment, and access to higher learning. Redundancy in a specific job is fully part of the system since money has no place. A restaurant has a full staff at all hours of operation. Maintenance has all the skilled employees to cover all areas of operation. There should be no shortages in manpower.
What about those who refuse to work?
The most delicate sacrifice of all. They will have to be taken to special designated areas. These areas are kept at primitive levels. Basic shelter, clothing and food with basic medical care provided by volunteer staff. They are not prisons but facilities to spur individuals into wanting a better way of life within the human civilization. A scared straight type of setting.
There are more issues and challenges to overcome. These are the basic examples to get the idea across. An individual can work as a janitor and still live life in luxury or get a higher education and still live a life in luxury. The way white collar and blue collar should exist in equalness.
The scariest part of this post was, "Intellectuals become the new governing bodies based on their specific educational backgrounds and life experiences."
Sounds familiar. Wake up, folks, or your kids/grandkids are going to have endure the socialist experiment described above, as many throughout history already have.
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: Eagler on December 27, 2025, 06:39:41 PM
Huxley's Brave New World had the answer...
SOMA :banana: :banana: :banana:
Eagler
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: JimmyD3 on December 27, 2025, 06:45:40 PM
Humans are incapable of creating a utopia, human nature gets in the way. :)
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: CAV on December 27, 2025, 06:49:56 PM
Sounds like some kind of communist B.S. to me...
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: RUSH1 on December 27, 2025, 06:56:04 PM
Humans are incapable of creating a utopia, human nature gets in the way. :)
People looking to government for meaning becomes a problem, too. Ever noticed how many who are drawn to socialism are not religious, and how socialist/communist governments push or even demand secularism?
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: RUSH1 on December 27, 2025, 07:15:08 PM
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: AKIron on December 28, 2025, 08:18:51 AM
Define Utopia.
Start with the most basic unit. Is that a person? A family? A village? What does it take to make that unit content? If your "system" cannot achieve contentment for your most basic unit any extrapolation will also be discontent.
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: rabbidrabbit on December 28, 2025, 09:55:17 AM
Utopia can be created. The problem is the utter resistance by those consumed with wealth and power. Those addictions are so powerful, that trying to break them would be a mountainous challenge.
The first hurdle is to break he bonds of supply and demand. That is the foundation of our financial civilization. Those chains are so heavy and thick, that snapping then would be impossible to many. That's where the first sacrifice comes into play. Billionaires and millionaires would have to agree for the removal of personal wealth. Wall Street and corporations would have to agree on no more profit and the elimination of stocks. Banks would have to close up shop. Money has to become obsolete.
How does anything get done?
The next sacrifice is the individual governments funded by the taxes and tariffs. A new system must be placed in that vacuum. Intellectuals become the new governing bodies based on their specific educational backgrounds and life experiences. That process will require much deliberation of specific criteria. Starting with towns and cities, the new organizational structure would grow into larger administrative regions until a global body has emerged. A great challenge to be undertaken.
How does individuals function?
This sacrifice is the easiest. Everyone has a job. The best part is anyone can choose to be a lowly worker or work up the ladder. Everyone has a place to live, clothes to wear, food in their belly, access to full medical treatment, and access to higher learning. Redundancy in a specific job is fully part of the system since money has no place. A restaurant has a full staff at all hours of operation. Maintenance has all the skilled employees to cover all areas of operation. There should be no shortages in manpower.
What about those who refuse to work?
The most delicate sacrifice of all. They will have to be taken to special designated areas. These areas are kept at primitive levels. Basic shelter, clothing and food with basic medical care provided by volunteer staff. They are not prisons but facilities to spur individuals into wanting a better way of life within the human civilization. A scared straight type of setting.
There are more issues and challenges to overcome. These are the basic examples to get the idea across. An individual can work as a janitor and still live life in luxury or get a higher education and still live a life in luxury. The way white collar and blue collar should exist in equalness.
(https://i.imgflip.com/5aoxwd.png)
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: Captain Virgil Hilts on December 28, 2025, 11:50:01 AM
Utopia is the fantasy of the small mind, devoid of purpose.
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: rabbidrabbit on December 28, 2025, 01:04:19 PM
Utopia is the fantasy of the small mind, devoid of purpose.
It's impossible at scale. People become infatuated with fantasies but the reality of human nature makes the concepts a fools venture used to build and consolidate power by authoritarians.
So unless you are going to find a way to inflict a Pluribus type society hive mind, there is a zero percent chance the system survives the string pullers orchestrating it the same way every communist/ socialist experiment has so far.
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: AKKuya on December 28, 2025, 04:54:45 PM
When science and technology are advanced to a point where energy production becomes clean and unlimited, the future society will be radically different than today and in the past. When energy can be converted into matter, then unlimited resources become available.
Just an example for illustration, that was the real error in the thought processes of Thanos in the MCU. The writers had no idea of what they were talking about.
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: Rocco on December 29, 2025, 03:29:00 PM
Sounds like you're talking about a Federation type of post-scarcity society. While I love Star Trek and its optimist future, I always struggled with what motivated everyone to work. I think that's where that type of utopia kinda falls apart for me. I can get the no money economy. When there is an abundance of everything, money would become obsolete. I also get the main character's motivations, cause flying around space in a starship would be wicked cool. But if all our needs and wants are met, why would anyone do the hard, gross, dangerous, or uninteresting jobs like sanitation, mining, filing, scrubbing plasma conduits. Everyone would follow their passion, which is awesome and I wish that happened more often now. But where now when you can't follow your passion ppl have to take the unwanted jobs to build a life, in a Federation society they would just do nothing because they can. Then these terrible but necessary jobs wouldn't get done and society crumbles.
TNG touched on it a few times in regards to androids and creating a slave race of sentient machines, and established that these unwanted jobs still exist (see The Measure of a Man, great episode), but never really explained why ppl do them. To better mankind doesn't work for me without a fundamental shift in human nature. I think realistically the only way we could get there is if all of those unwanted jobs were somehow automated. But then I still see humanity ending up less like Star Trek and more like Wall-E. Maybe some kind of hybrid of the two, as there will always be ambitious ppl that want to make their mark and lazy ppl that just want to hang out on the holodeck all day.
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: AKKuya on December 29, 2025, 04:44:19 PM
The Greek, Norse, Egyptian, and other mythological civilizations may possibly be Type 3 civilizations that exist on different dimensional planes. Their advanced technology would be magical to us walking apes. :devil
They could possess the scientific means through technology to convert energy into matter. Unlimited resources would be able to build a perfect society.
Olympus, Atlantis, the Underworld, Asgard, AAru, Avalon, Aztlan, Shangri-La, and others like them have one thing in common. They all have regular citizens inhabiting them. Some could be human and others could be non-human.
Hypothetically, they could be considered utopias. We can only theorize through academia and walking ape logic. If they did exist, then they would be good examples to learn from. Possibly. Skeptic in me always border on wait and see approach. Over time, they could be not good for us.
Rocco mentioned the United Federation of Planets (UFP). That's a good reference due to fictionalized warp drive and matter/food replicators. The replicators are theoretically existing matter being rearranged into new constructs. That technology creates the possibility of the beginnings of a utopian life.
The UFP still uses currency along with the other spacefaring species except for the Borg and he Q Continuum. The UFP still has social, educational, religious, governmental, and military issues. This is the drama created by writers for episodic television to hook viewers.
There is many YouTube content on Star Trek.
The closest form of Utopia that existed. It was with early man during the hunter/gatherer days. No paychecks, no rent/mortgage, no insurance, no utility bills, no grocery bills, and no taxes. They were masters of their destiny.
This walking ape is very jealous.
Title: Re: What Would It Take To Create Utopia?
Post by: DmonSlyr on December 29, 2025, 08:10:59 PM
Utopia is being able to work for value in society while being able to keep most or all of what you earn, living in a society that respects one's worth and values someone's contributions. A society that punishes gangs and bad doers. A society that keeps its streets clean and promotes strength, intelligence, and all level of skills. This creates a prosperous society able to bulld a utopia by working for value to help others. There are still many areas in America that live like this if you can find them.
Utopias for most would create a society similar to Saudi Arabia. There is no need to work, there is no need to educate, there is no need strive for excellence because you dont need to. The leaders hand you money every month to live on and thats it.
A society that doesnt appreciate a person's value and strives to Increase it through worth, always becomes sub par and lacks creative intelligence to drive prosperity in their nation. A society where all people are represented with the same value regardless of contribution and value, never develops in a strong sociery. Weve seen so many examples throughout history.
Working for value and worth, being able to retire, living on a plot of land or condo box anywhere you want and traveling to other lands, while also able to afford all the fun things other smart people were able to create to build their self worth so they can do the same thing. Now that is Utopia.