Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: mERv on April 03, 2026, 06:44:30 AM

Title: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: mERv on April 03, 2026, 06:44:30 AM
It has and will always be one of the more balanced maps in the MA. It is very hard not to find a fight with the GV transfer bases, manageable distance between green and red bases, and accessibility to both strike and resup strats. If a country wants to tackle the map quickly it requires a strong 12 hour run of calculated offensive pushes, strategic defense, and a little luck from both enemy countries.

CraterMA will always be a personal favorites. What are you opinions on the current map?

P.S. GET RID OF EASY MODE STRAT RESUP. It compromises a working strat system that has been in place a long time that works. No strat under any situation below 6 players resupping should ever be able to bring up a strat in less than 15 minutes. CraterMA is a great example of how you dont need easy mode strat resup to make a map work.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: The Fugitive on April 03, 2026, 09:00:23 AM
I consider it one of the worst maps we have. Due to the numbers we have these days it is too spread out , leaving far to many areas for players to "sneak in". This game....I always thought, was all about combat. There are too many ways to avoid it on this map. Hitting supply depots is right at the top of this list as well. I miss the old version of this map. Most players back then ended up in the crater for some tankin fun. Now its barren, might as well just fill it in.

As for the supplies, I hate that anyone does hit the strats, but Im relieved that the resupply isnt horrible. If I only have an hour or so to play I dont want to waste that time running sups to the strats. You want our bases, come and get them. This hitting the strats to nerf a teams ability to defend isnt "combat", its avoiding combat. And should a team drop dar, NOBODY resups, they just log off, again all the attacking team did was avoid combat.

I thought I heard they were going to revamp crater map to bring it in line with the other maps supply wise   :devil   
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: JimmyD3 on April 03, 2026, 09:04:15 AM
I consider it one of the worst maps we have. Due to the numbers we have these days it is too spread out , leaving far to many areas for players to "sneak in". This game....I always thought, was all about combat. There are too many ways to avoid it on this map. Hitting supply depots is right at the top of this list as well. I miss the old version of this map. Most players back then ended up in the crater for some tankin fun. Now its barren, might as well just fill it in.

As for the supplies, I hate that anyone does hit the strats, but Im relieved that the resupply isnt horrible. If I only have an hour or so to play I dont want to waste that time running sups to the strats. You want our bases, come and get them. This hitting the strats to nerf a teams ability to defend isnt "combat", its avoiding combat. And should a team drop dar, NOBODY resups, they just log off, again all the attacking team did was avoid combat.

+1
I thought I heard they were going to revamp crater map to bring it in line with the other maps supply wise   :devil
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Devil 505 on April 03, 2026, 09:27:24 AM
I consider it one of the worst maps we have. Due to the numbers we have these days it is too spread out , leaving far to many areas for players to "sneak in". This game....I always thought, was all about combat. There are too many ways to avoid it on this map. Hitting supply depots is right at the top of this list as well. I miss the old version of this map. Most players back then ended up in the crater for some tankin fun. Now its barren, might as well just fill it in.

As for the supplies, I hate that anyone does hit the strats, but Im relieved that the resupply isnt horrible. If I only have an hour or so to play I dont want to waste that time running sups to the strats. You want our bases, come and get them. This hitting the strats to nerf a teams ability to defend isnt "combat", its avoiding combat. And should a team drop dar, NOBODY resups, they just log off, again all the attacking team did was avoid combat.

I thought I heard they were going to revamp crater map to bring it in line with the other maps supply wise   :devil   

Exactly. Crater is one of the worst maps we have. Also the super large airfields create huge amounts of lag. Those need to be replaced on any revamp.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: JimmyD3 on April 03, 2026, 11:18:04 AM
For me, I like Craterma. That having been said, I think there could be some changes made to it that would make it better.

1. Add Battle Ships. add a minimum 2 BB's to each country, imo a BB at every port.
2. With the BB's added, increase the Shore Batt. at all shore line bases.
3. Add Flak bases at all strats, enable GV's.
4. Re-do Tank Town. (Replace existing TT tile with new tile, when it becomes available.)
5. Replace All Mega bases, with Large Bases and add an adjacent Flak base.
6. Keep all existing base locations as they are.

I would like to commend Greebo for what I think is one the best Maps that came out early on with AH3. In AH2 this map was one of the best for Great GV Battles in the original TT.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: DmonSlyr on April 04, 2026, 11:05:06 AM
One of my least favorites. Its too large. Makes small dars where people dont know where the battle is during off hours. No action for fighters in tank town. All tanks in tank town means less battles on the rest of the huge map. All 3 teams cannot interact from a fighter perspective.

Building #s starts in the off hours and that starts with maps where people can easily find larger battles and partake in them rather than looking all over a map and figuring if they want to roll for 2 190Ds at 16k, a B17 at 20k, or a massive hoard on both sides where their team isn't defending at all. Its the larger maps like BowlMA, Oceania, and Crater than IMO, have held the #s back when we get stuck with them all weekend.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 05, 2026, 03:35:51 AM
While I was developing CraterMA (on and off for a few years) AH had a much bigger player base than it does now and the design reflected that. At the time it was a medium sized map, some were way bigger. I'd originally intended to have airbases in the crater too but at some point HTC stated they didn't want "fighter town" style layouts in MA maps any more as it meant the rest of the arena became unpopulated, so I deleted them. Once it was released many GVers liked having a tank town largely free of aerial interference anyway.

Nowadays I agree the map is too big for the player numbers we have online but there is nothing I could do about it, even if I was inclined to. This is because when AH III was released HTC made CraterMA the default terrain that comes as part of the base game download and took over development of it themselves. Any changes made to it would have to be done by HT and would also need a new game version and download to be created, so its unlikely to ever happen.





Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: mERv on April 06, 2026, 01:00:54 AM
While I was developing CraterMA (on and off for a few years) AH had a much bigger player base than it does now and the design reflected that. At the time it was a medium sized map, some were way bigger. I'd originally intended to have airbases in the crater too but at some point HTC stated they didn't want "fighter town" style layouts in MA maps any more as it meant the rest of the arena became unpopulated, so I deleted them. Once it was released many GVers liked having a tank town largely free of aerial interference anyway.

Nowadays I agree the map is too big for the player numbers we have online but there is nothing I could do about it, even if I was inclined to. This is because when AH III was released HTC made CraterMA the default terrain that comes as part of the base game download and took over development of it themselves. Any changes made to it would have to be done by HT and would also need a new game version and download to be created, so its unlikely to ever happen.

The players who have spoken here are fighter-only players that dont regularly play the war. The original crater and AH3 version are as good as any we have access to. GREEBO your map is one of the all time greats dont let these mediocres convince you orherwise  :cheers: :aok
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 06, 2026, 02:20:14 AM
I was also a fighter-only player, so I know where the complainers are coming from. When we had 500 players in the MA we needed maps with several adjacent enemy fields per front or things just got way too crowded. Now we have maybe 120 players the same maps make it hard to find a fight, particularly when some are in GVs, guns or are actively trying to avoid fighting other players.

If I were able to to redesign CraterMA now for current conditions I'd add three airbases on the upper level of the crater to give it a fighter town as I think this is needed with current numbers. Each of these would have a spawn from an uncapturable base outside the crater, so the bases could be easily retaken if captured. Maybe add some low cloud over tank town to make it harder to bomb GVs.

Also I'd delete a bunch of other bases so there was only one GV capture path, one airbase capture path and one CV capture path per front outside of the crater. This would make it harder for timid players to avoid fighting other players. Finally I'd get rid of the excess trees at the spawn points.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Eagler on April 06, 2026, 07:49:47 AM
Not sure someone who logs in to fly at 25k for 3 hours to drop bombs on an usually unprotected base should have a say on maps or anything game play for the rest of us...

We need much smaller bases for the numbers we produce nightly..averages around 100 to 110 by 2100 eastern when I am logging off..

Eagler
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: mERv on April 06, 2026, 08:19:42 AM
Not sure someone who logs in to fly at 25k for 3 hours to drop bombs on an usually unprotected base should have a say on maps or anything game play for the rest of us...

We need much smaller bases for the numbers we produce nightly..averages around 100 to 110 by 2100 eastern when I am logging off..

Eagler

Talk about on over exaggeration of over 90% of bomber sorties in the game today. The vast majority of bomber flivhts happen under 15k in this game. Only a rare few waste that kind of time anymore.

What killed this game the most was the putspoken fighter community who pushed for a more combat flight sim enviroment away from the war. These same half-invested players only populate the arena but a few hours a week and a lot of them left anyways.

What makes this game great is the war. This above all else shoild be protected.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Eagler on April 06, 2026, 08:24:55 AM
The war is the last thing on my list when I log in for my hour each evening...

Dar bar and the closest decent fight is more the priority...

I usually have no idea who is ahead or what is needed at that time to win the map nor have I ever cared in all my time playing this game..  :joystick:

Eagler
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Dadtallica on April 06, 2026, 10:20:22 AM
The war is the last thing on my list when I log in for my hour each evening...

Dar bar and the closest decent fight is more the priority...

I usually have no idea who is ahead or what is needed at that time to win the map nor have I ever cared in all my time playing this game..  :joystick:

Eagler

But for others it’s the the opposite and you’re the outlier.

Everyone gets a seat at the table here.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: The Fugitive on April 06, 2026, 10:50:06 AM
The war is the last thing on my list when I log in for my hour each evening...

Dar bar and the closest decent fight is more the priority...

I usually have no idea who is ahead or what is needed at that time to win the map nor have I ever cared in all my time playing this game..  :joystick:

Eagler

You know what makes that dar bar your looking for when you log on? 

The war. If nobody is trying to take bases you wont find very many fighting.

Talk about on over exaggeration of over 90% of bomber sorties in the game today. The vast majority of bomber flivhts happen under 15k in this game. Only a rare few waste that kind of time anymore.

What killed this game the most was the putspoken fighter community who pushed for a more combat flight sim enviroment away from the war. These same half-invested players only populate the arena but a few hours a week and a lot of them left anyways.

What makes this game great is the war. This above all else shoild be protected.

Very little of the war game has changed over the years. The only thing that has, is the way players play the game. In the old days we had a number of players on all teams that posted missions all the time working to take bases and win the war. I was one of them years ago when I lead the 444th Air Mafia. Many times I would have so many players joining that I would just sit in the tower and co-ordinate 2, 3 sometimes 4 wings hitting multiple base along both fronts. "Mugz", "ET37" and many other would do the same. Today you dont see that as much

Today too many people are afraid to die, or just dont want to work for the base. You are the same. Saturday night youd come in to take a base, white flag it in your 600 bombers you fly and then leave if you survived. If the defense stopped the attack/base grab, you would all disappear and move 200 miles away and try another base on the other front, or try to sneak one on the same front but far away from the last attack.

The battles are what makes the game fun for me. Those battles also give the "fighter guys" something to do. As Greebo said, "Crater Map" is too spread out for a good war with the numbers we have these days, ideal for those hit and run tactics of a "smash and grab" type of thing. Picture "wack a mole".
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: LCADolby on April 06, 2026, 12:05:40 PM
Honest question Fugi, but in these battles you so enjoy, when was that last time you did not out number your opponents?
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: fudgums on April 06, 2026, 12:15:08 PM
Yea..same question. Even the fighters like battles. 30v1 isn’t a battle
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: oTRALFZo on April 06, 2026, 12:53:53 PM






Today too many people are afraid to die, or just dont want to work for the base. You are the same. Saturday night youd come in to take a base, white flag it in your 600 bombers you fly and then leave if you survived. If the defense stopped the attack/base grab, you would all disappear and move 200 miles away and try another base on the other front, or try to sneak one on the same front but far away from the last attack.



As opposed to attacking a virtual non defended front with 80 guys dropping hangers or vulching.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: The Fugitive on April 06, 2026, 01:28:50 PM
Ive been the under dog many many a time. If Im not flying with my squad I do the same thing as Eagler, find a dar bar and fly over there. Im sorry if when my squad gets together it becomes too much for some of you. But as a squad, you wont find us backing down or switching fronts because the defense shows up. JG11 seems to like spoiling our plans on Thursday night. Its more fun when there are defenders..... tho fighting jets all the time gets old  :)

Honest question Fugi, but in these battles you so enjoy, when was that last time you did not out number your opponents?

As Im am a war type player numbers are good. On the other hand we dont always have the numbers. Sometimes skill can out weigh numbers.

Yea..same question. Even the fighters like battles. 30v1 isn’t a battle

I think the radar isssue could help there. Like LilMak said in a big battle like that you have to work the outside edges and drag a guy or two away from the pack. You cant just dive in with your hair on fire and expect to come out on top. Just like an F4F fighting a K4 takes a certain strategy so does fighting more than one other guy.

As opposed to attacking a virtual non defended front with 80 guys dropping hangers or vulching.

The "Puppies" regroup and hit it again, verses run away. The only time Ive seen our guys change plan is when the defense is coming from too many bases and they split up to pork a couple to narrow down were the defense can come from.

The game is what you make it. If you cant get your team together to grab bases, get a few guy together to defend bases. 2 or 3 guys can mess up a mission by dropping the right guy at the right time. An M3 here, a goon there, or a set of bomber just before they drop.  Stop trying to pick as many kills as you can, stop worrying about dying and hurting your score. Concentrate on breaking up the mission. Sure your going to die. Last tour I didnt get as many sorties due to a vacatio in there but of the 75 I did get I died almost 50 of them, but I had fun  :D
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: MDStampf93 on April 06, 2026, 03:21:15 PM
JG11 seems to like spoiling our plans on Thursday night. Its more fun when there are defenders..... tho fighting jets all the time gets old  :)

I wouldn’t say it’s ALL the time, just most of the time  :D
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 09, 2026, 07:15:01 AM
This thread started me thinking about CraterMA and although I'm not overly keen on wrestling with the Terrain Editor and submissions process again I do find it sad that my map a source of frustration for many players these days. So below are a couple of map images I have made to show both the current version and what I think a revised version could look like. To get round the problem of this being AH's default terrain I'd probably have to rename it to something else, perhaps just "Crater" or maybe "CalderaMA". That way Hitech could just replace CraterMA in the rotation with the new version without it affecting the base game download.

The main differences on the new version are as follows:-

Fewer bases which should reduce the time the map is in the rotation.

No super large airfields.

Removed many of the front line airfields to concentrate the players into a smaller area.

Added three airfields inside the crater.

Created a single chain of V bases running outside of the ring of airbases with limited spawns to the airfields.

Grouped the factory strats around each City with its two flak bases and surrounding uncapturable airbases.

I can replace two of each country's four CV fleets with BB fleets, probably the two nearest the front lines. HTC are not keen on more fleets than the 12 this map has for frame rate reasons, so no additional fleets.

The idea here is that much of the time a player will only be able to choose between one of three nearby enemy airfields or 3 or 4 GV spawn points, one per front line plus tank/fighter town. More if there is also an enemy fleet close to a base. This limited choice should make it more likely a moderate darbar will generate and encourage more players to up or spawn in, either to attack or defend. Having fewer bases and spawns does makes it easier for bombers to shut down a country's front line bases so I could replace the medium air bases just behind each front line with large ones to make this harder. The crater airbases will get likely taken a lot so I'd place the SPs from outside bases higher than the crater bases to make it easier to retake them.

I'd welcome constructive criticism for this revised map, both what you do like and what you don't. Not expecting a universal consensus (this is the AH BBS after all) but am willing to make changes for a good idea or if enough people think a change needed. If there is enough support here for a revised map I'll put the idea to Hitech and if he is agreeable I'll start work on it.

Proposed revised CraterMA.

(https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=412354.0;attach=38326)


Existing CraterMA for comparison.

(https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=412354.0;attach=38324)






Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: JimmyD3 on April 09, 2026, 08:14:38 AM
I like it. You might consider moving the HQ's farther inland, if you plan on adding Battle Ships to the map. :rock
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: mERv on April 09, 2026, 09:04:27 AM
I wouldn’t say it’s ALL the time, just most of the time  :D

Whoever doesnt welcome engagements with WW2 jets on a frequent basis is MEDIOCRE!  :neener:

What do we say to the God of Duece's? Not today! :banana:
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: DmonSlyr on April 09, 2026, 01:04:51 PM
This thread started me thinking about CraterMA and although I'm not overly keen on wrestling with the Terrain Editor and submissions process again I do find it sad that my map a source of frustration for many players these days. So below are a couple of map images I have made to show both the current version and what I think a revised version could look like. To get round the problem of this being AH's default terrain I'd probably have to rename it to something else, perhaps just "Crater" or maybe "CalderaMA". That way Hitech could just replace CraterMA in the rotation with the new version without it affecting the base game download.

The main differences on the new version are as follows:-

Fewer bases which should reduce the time the map is in the rotation.

No super large airfields.

Removed many of the front line airfields to concentrate the players into a smaller area.

Added three airfields inside the crater.

Created a single chain of V bases running outside of the ring of airbases with limited spawns to the airfields.

Grouped the factory strats around each City with its two flak bases and surrounding uncapturable airbases.

I can replace two of each country's four CV fleets with BB fleets, probably the two nearest the front lines. HTC are not keen on more fleets than the 12 this map has for frame rate reasons, so no additional fleets.

The idea here is that much of the time a player will only be able to choose between one of three nearby enemy airfields or 3 or 4 GV spawn points, one per front line plus tank/fighter town. More if there is also an enemy fleet close to a base. This limited choice should make it more likely a moderate darbar will generate and encourage more players to up or spawn in, either to attack or defend. Having fewer bases and spawns does makes it easier for bombers to shut down a country's front line bases so I could replace the medium air bases just behind each front line with large ones to make this harder. The crater airbases will get likely taken a lot so I'd place the SPs from outside bases higher than the crater bases to make it easier to retake them.

I'd welcome constructive criticism for this revised map, both what you do like and what you don't. Not expecting a universal consensus (this is the AH BBS after all) but am willing to make changes for a good idea or if enough people think a change needed. If there is enough support here for a revised map I'll put the idea to Hitech and if he is agreeable I'll start work on it.

Proposed revised CraterMA.

(https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=412354.0;attach=38326)


Existing CraterMA for comparison.

(https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=412354.0;attach=38324)

Yes!  :rock thank you for this Greebo. While I do wish more of the area surrounding the volcano could be removed to tighten things up, I dont know if possible. The revised version would IMO make battles feel larger fighting for the Vehicle fields. I do like the addition of fighter fields in the middle area. I would hope that more folks choose not to be in those areas anyway in order to give credence to the war battle outside the TT FT area, but does give fighters an opportunity to fight  :aok
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 10, 2026, 02:54:18 AM
I like it. You might consider moving the HQ's farther inland, if you plan on adding Battle Ships to the map. :rock

Thanks, that's something I hadn't considered as battleships were introduced after I last worked on terrains. What is the maximum effective range of the battleship's guns in the game?

I could just move the HQs over to the cluster of other strats. However now I think about it having all the strats grouped together so tightly would probably cause frame rate issues for players with marginal PCs. I vaguely recall that's why HTC dropped the super large all-in-one strat cities that AH II used to have in the first place. So I will likely have to spread them out a bit more than on the revised map. Perhaps into groups of two strats, a flak base and a V base (for radar coverage) with the three clusters sited mid way between the three uncapturable bases.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 10, 2026, 03:19:51 AM
Yes!  :rock thank you for this Greebo. While I do wish more of the area surrounding the volcano could be removed to tighten things up, I dont know if possible. The revised version would IMO make battles feel larger fighting for the Vehicle fields. I do like the addition of fighter fields in the middle area. I would hope that more folks choose not to be in those areas anyway in order to give credence to the war battle outside the TT FT area, but does give fighters an opportunity to fight  :aok

I suspect some GVers won't be happy with the fighter town bases but given player numbers I think they are needed to kick start the aerial fight outside of peak hours. If there was some sort of air base without ordnance bunkers that would be ideal, but sadly we don't have that.

I think at least two choices of spawn and nearby airfield between each pair of countries is necessary otherwise it becomes too easy to shut the fight down. FT/TT plus one choice of each per front line is the minimum for this. The thing about not having spawns to every nearby field is it makes some fields strategically important, the second V base in from the front line will likely become a much fought over spot for instance.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Dadtallica on April 10, 2026, 08:27:11 AM
Airfields without ords is an interesting idea.

Perhaps the mapmakers can disable them at certain fields?
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 10, 2026, 10:26:13 AM
Only thing a mapmaker can disable at a field are which rides can up there (no Me 163 etc.) While he could create a custom airbase that lacked ords it wouldn't be allowed on an MA terrain because of the risk of it introducing a bug that crashes the arena. It would need HTC themselves to create such a base and I can't see that happening.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 10, 2026, 11:00:40 AM
Stripping ords from bases sounds so arcade. We do need a level of reality in the MA, IMO.

No offense, but most ideas I read removes a challenge, a game without challenge is not a good game.

Perking all planes except your own choice is a great example.

Frankly, if there is no challenge I’m not interested.

Its all setting wack-a-mole work-around to the real problem, numbers.
On my video comments several of 10k say they didn’t know the game still exist or happy it does and want to return. Yall stopped getting the word out. Ya don’t have to “sell” it, simply let people know it still exist.

We need to be above critical mass of 120 for the game and maps to work as designed.

Setting wack-a-mole is the lazy way out. Stop stupid stuff like full country hording that chase players out is a good start.

Frankly, I don’t want to be the only one doing the leg work just to get bashed from the unappreciates who do nothing but complain how someone does something they refuse to do.

Let others know when events are happening, its your top “sales” point, exploit it.

Anyone who thinks what I do/did is for some form of attension is lost in themselves. Why I quit, if thats what you think then you do it.

Never ever even once did I ever get pushback from the AW crowd, not once. Its rampant here. I do it so I have a game to play, I should have done it in shades. I became repulsed which makes Animl haters happy, they are your enemy of numbers in the first place.


Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 10, 2026, 11:43:52 AM
The crater airbases without ords idea was an offhand remark, I wasn't seriously expecting it to happen. Having said that I think in this case it would add a challenge for those people who wanted to take out TT GVs from these airbases. They'd have to use tank busting planes like the Il-2, Ju 87G and Hurri IID rather than just dropping 1K bombs on them. Taking out the other airbases would be more about covering your attacking GVs from the air and less about bombing the base flat.

I agree numbers is the real problem but I think map design can help here. Currently players log in outside of peak hours and see half a dozen tiny dar bars across the long front line and just log off again. The chances of getting a decent fight are just too small to make it worth the time to investigate. If all those tiny dar bars were compressed into one bigger one though they'd be more likely to up. This then becomes a benign circle, more players upping mean a bigger darbar that means more players upping and so on.

Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 10, 2026, 12:27:24 PM
I’m not a GVer, my opinions on how maps work would just add to the GVer vs Pilot bias. That does exist.

IMO, any large change is very risky. They always get bigger reactions than predicted, sometimes not good.

On bbs we’re probably at 10% of all players that voice opinions. I would not consider these few speak for the masses. I can get different input on 200.

I think maps should bend to the current average numbers, but leave buffer room for higher peak numbers. The way the MA plays varies sharply on number count. Above 120 it’s a different game. Tweaks yes, big changes, nope. IMO

Thats how far I can go. I’m not involved in the mechanics and idiosyncrasies of any one map. It’s either fun or it’s not.

A life time ago, when I had some control of main arena settings, I gave the players exactly what they begged for for a long time,…it took 2 months to create and test, once they got exactly what they asked for they didn’t like it in RR arenas, full realism praised it. Biggest complaint, realistic “made kills harder” <blank stare>

Input is very haphazard, careful how you waste time. No haphazard changes. Study the situation, make your case, throw it up against the wall and see if it sticks. Most don’t with the whole masses. We make educated guesses, HT has data streams. I’m a data guy. Math is absolute.

Preaching to the choir actually. Sorry.

If we only listen to the masses stop signs and lights would be removed, negative impact. Players should not make decisions, ever.

That drivel said, what ever truly makes the full masses happy and better game play has my unsolicited support. <shrug> but it’s a rarity.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: DmonSlyr on April 10, 2026, 01:52:21 PM
The crater airbases without ords idea was an offhand remark, I wasn't seriously expecting it to happen. Having said that I think in this case it would add a challenge for those people who wanted to take out TT GVs from these airbases. They'd have to use tank busting planes like the Il-2, Ju 87G and Hurri IID rather than just dropping 1K bombs on them. Taking out the other airbases would be more about covering your attacking GVs from the air and less about bombing the base flat.

I agree numbers is the real problem but I think map design can help here. Currently players log in outside of peak hours and see half a dozen tiny dar bars across the long front line and just log off again. The chances of getting a decent fight are just too small to make it worth the time to investigate. If all those tiny dar bars were compressed into one bigger one though they'd be more likely to up. This then becomes a benign circle, more players upping mean a bigger darbar that means more players upping and so on.

I think you are 100% correct and have the right idea. Its all about the maps in today's day and age. Thats why I think your adjustments are great because Ive been wanting CraterMA gone for a while now. Along with bowlMA and Oceania. The best way to build #s is by starting with the off hours and that starts with fun battles on the map even with low #s. These types of maps also keep players logged in longer as the night ends where you might play until 12am instead of 10:30 because the battle is so good. Thats what builds #s over time.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 10, 2026, 03:52:14 PM
Not if they don’t know it exist. No one thing draws players. Maos just jeep them in the door once they get here
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Dadtallica on April 10, 2026, 03:59:34 PM
Good grief just go away.

Every thread isn’t about you.

Hey Animl… nobody wants you here.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 10, 2026, 05:07:43 PM
Good grief just go away.

Every thread isn’t about you.

Hey Animl… nobody wants you here.

How was that about me? you’re one of the 5 on many ignore list

You tried to make the locked thread about me, you idiot

Multi personality issues, depends on your audience right?

You just made it about me, flake. Get mental help with your flip flop personality, whacko

Obvious drug rehab in order, sad little man

People like you is why I no longer lift a finger anymore.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Dadtallica on April 10, 2026, 09:02:04 PM
lol no way just no. I will gladly make this poll in game or elsewhere just say when.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Lazerr on April 10, 2026, 09:41:14 PM
And..... triggered
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 11, 2026, 03:38:32 AM
You turned this into a ghost town with your whacko child drama.
You trued that last year just too, didn’t go well for you.

You say I made it about me when you tried to make a whole insulting thread about me just to have it locked, so you came to this one to spew your vomit. Fruit

Btw you made my very point. A do nothing who complains about doers.

You ARE 1 of the 5 players ignored because of lil girl drama like this. You ARE one of the 5 yep you are. YOU made this thread about me because the other got locked. Get help
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 11, 2026, 03:43:49 AM
And..... triggered

From someone who trolls politics and sees ghost that aren’t there
The unstable
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: mERv on April 13, 2026, 02:38:48 PM
Good grief just go away.

Every thread isn’t about you.

Hey Animl… nobody wants you here.

Ahhh yes its Dadtallica the mediocre speaking on behalf of the community again without the communities endorsement to do so.

ANIML is in fact wanted around here. Hell he has done more for this game than you have by a long shot.

Stick to paying your $15 and padding your enemies score my guy your awful at everything else.

From someone who trolls politics and sees ghost that aren’t there
The unstable
  :x :banana: :rock

And..... triggered
:rofl
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 14, 2026, 11:18:32 AM
Thanks merv,
I don’t get it, but it didn’t start with me. Blue Baron, Gypsy Baron, even Gray Eagle, some mass talent behind AW took the same treatment in the first days. It was sad and sick the people that were beat down and/or chased off.  “…this is our game, we don’t need you…”. The contributions they were capable of were huge. We were not welcomed with open arms by far. These guys towered over me, but I learned from them.

I know there was a lil bad blood that Kesmai didn’t take Ht and Pyro onboard. They could have helped save AW. Both very talented. I was for it. But my vote didn’t count. In the end the byproduct was AH. HT invented several things (he pattened?)

Before my return I went to HTC FB page to see the status of the game. All HT did was a 2019 post a pic of a tank skin and he was beat down for that. That sickened me. He never posted again that I know. I can’t blame him.

Point being, a much more unpleasable and angry crowd.

It’s not new to AH. It makes no sense.

What does make sense is the majority of Animl haters are disgruntled former players with a very negative agenda to be here. They hate that I try to help something when their whole goal is to break everything. I’m a counter to their negative efforts. I must be gone for them to succeed in killing it, so they can say “I told you it would die”, well ya, they are forcing it. It’s a sick obsession they totally lost control of.

I never saw people quit a game but hang around with a negative agenda longer then they actually played the game.

Most SANE people don’t kick a GF to the curb, break up, then show up at her home everyday to throw rocks at the windows to harass her for their own doing. That is not sane. There’s something very wrong upstairs and its mire obvious to others than themselves, that is the norm.

What they did was double down on the negative to overcome anything I do, again, not sane, absolutely NOT honest brokers. Deviates and proud of it.

I can go on, but my main point IS they will nnot crush me the way they did the people above. I would rip off my own arm and beat them with the bloody end over giving them another win.

The only current customer if that tribe is in this post, I don’t get that, and not going to waste time trying to. I’m not putting effort to please foot stomping fecal farming former whiners. No one should ever respond to a foot stomping child. To do so encourages to do it more to get what they want. So at times I can’t blame HT for sitting back. I might do the same. He sad byproduct of that feeds the disgruntled firmer players goal. Catch 22.

Personally, after yrs of patterns with that tribe, they would be permabanned, they contribute NOTHING but angst and hate.

I’ll abide to HT pressing the shock collar button, but I refuse them a negative win. Kesmai had a shock collar on me too. Turn it off and I’m holding heads. This is the white glove side of me. Even when I did hold power I only used privs 3 times.i would clean house here.

No matter what they pull, they are NOT running me off. Learn it, live it, love it. They aren’t going to do to me what they did to my elders. Nope, not happening. Former players consuming our forum with BS should not be happening. They are not customers, they will not be customers, they have no standing. They drive customers off. They eat their own feet, they eat your feet too. Toxic poison.

When we brought numbers up they either skimmed them or scared em off. It looks like I don’t respect them because I don’t, plenty of reason.

They should like when I’m loud, because when I’m silent its because I’m about to oress a button, which I don’t own. Lucky them. Losing 4 firmer players to gain 20 customers? It would happen in half a breath.

Evidently, the saga continues. That is what the rotten shame is.
I’m a good guy, until I’m not.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: LCADolby on April 14, 2026, 12:15:13 PM

ANIML is in fact wanted around here. Hell he has done more for this game than you have by a long shot.


You are 2 peas in a pod, both known for mental instability and ramblings that are full of inflated self aggrandising.  :old:
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 14, 2026, 12:47:35 PM
You are 2 peas in a pod, both known for mental instability and ramblings that are full of inflated self aggrandising.  :old:

Projection

What do you contribute here besids hate and drama from your ego?

I refer to the loving post about me, just more needless drama.

Peopke like you chased off players and turned bbs into a ghost town. Congrats
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: LCADolby on April 14, 2026, 01:22:24 PM
Projection

What do you contribute here besids hate and drama from your ego?

I refer to the loving post about me, just more needless drama.

Peopke like you chased off players and turned bbs into a ghost town. Congrats

Piss off and eat a dick, hypocrite professional victim.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 14, 2026, 01:30:09 PM
Piss off and eat a dick, hypocrite professional victim.

And there ya go, look no further
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: LCADolby on April 14, 2026, 01:38:05 PM
And there ya go, look no further

You've pushed me to be open hostile towards you I've ran out of diddlys to give for you and your delusional ramblings blaming everyone else but yourself.

..and why are you typing to me shouldn't you be eating dick?
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 14, 2026, 01:59:51 PM
You've pushed me to be open hostile towards you I've ran out of diddlys to give for you and your delusional ramblings blaming everyone else but yourself.

..and why are you typing to me shouldn't you be eating dick?

All for highlighting a video clip for promoting the game. You’re a real gem.
Have I started hate threads about you?

What exactly have I done to you? Call you out on bad behavior that hurts the forum?

Right now you willfully exercise a prime example.

You will NEVER own me.

As I clearly stated, I do not start 15-70 page drama threads. Right now, you are thriving on drama you’re not going to get.

Maybe you should stop typing to me. I don’t care what you think. You’re a problem and you’re proving it.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: mERv on April 14, 2026, 03:02:06 PM
Somebody shut this thread down before someones house gets egged  :banana:

We are now at a level 7 FUSS on MaX's FUSS-O-METER :rofl

CraterMA is a great map and here to stay :aok
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: LCADolby on April 14, 2026, 03:07:47 PM
@Animl

These are the rules you break on daily basis and HiTech allows it, while I get warnings etc.;
Quote
1- Posts are to be made in the relevant forum. Users are asked to read the forum descriptons before posting.
2- Threads should remain on topic, do not "hijack" topics.
4- Flame baiting, flaming, being abusive, being disrespectful, trolling, spamming or posting to incite or annoy is not allowed. If you cannot make a positive contribution to the thread, then just stay out of it.
5- Members are asked to not act as "back seat moderators". If you feel a post violates the forum rules, the use the "Report to Moderator" link in the post to report it.

I have no intention returning to AH while you are going around unpunished.

I am not disgruntled with the game, just you and your continued existence on the BBS.

I'm a problem you and HiTech's inaction created.

You've made AcesHigh my biggest regret. What a waste of time, energy, money and talent.

I hope it shuts down sooner rather than later now, so I can have the satisfaction HiTech has denied me of being rid of you.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: fudgums on April 14, 2026, 04:52:43 PM
Yall need a Xanax and cigarette.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 15, 2026, 05:38:43 AM
I've been playing around with the what I am now calling CalderaMA in the Terrain Editor and the map below is what I will send to Hitech for his approval before I do any serious work on it.

Changes include:-

Repositioning some bases to make things fairer for both sides on each front line. The previous layout had one front line V base much closer to the opposing side's airbase than the other.

Added a central airbase for each country as distances were too great between the airfields otherwise.

Spread the strats out a bit while still keeping them within the triangle of uncapturable bases.

Deleted some V bases to bring the base count down to 111 (from CraterMA's 150).

(https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=412354.0;attach=38329)


Sorry for the on topic post, let the histrionics continue....
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: The Fugitive on April 15, 2026, 08:10:33 AM
Could you make the three airbases in the crater "townless" bases?

With the fewer GV spawns t may move players to the crater for GV battles and dive bombers really cut into that kind of fun. If it becomes annoying GVers could take the bases to stop the air attacks at least with in the crater.

Just a thought
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 15, 2026, 09:24:49 AM
Sorry but airbases have to have towns (or a map room) on an MA terrain, failing to add them would be flagged by the Terrain Editor's error checking routine. The only way to achieve what you want would be to make the crater airbases uncapturable (replacing one of the triangle of uncapturable bases). However this would block the central attack route and I think there needs to be three aerial and ground attack routes for each country, otherwise its too easy for a country to be swamped by the other two sides. I can't see HTC going for an uncapturable fighter town anyway. As I said before in this thread the ideal solution would be custom ord-less airbases but unfortunately custom airbases are not allowed in an MA terrain.

My current thinking with the crater airbases is to make them easier to retake than to take. I plan to place the spawn points from the outside airbases at a higher altitude than the airfield and the ones from inside at a lower. Also possibly use some low cloud cover over tank town and over the outer spawn points to make it harder to bomb GVs.

Bear in mind those players bombing GVs will make an ideal target for the other two countries' fighters. The idea here is to generate a fight with low numbers after all.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: The Fugitive on April 15, 2026, 09:30:35 AM
Some of the new maps have townless bases. The maproom is on the airfield. You drop ack and then you can run troops to take the field. It makes the fields easier to take and in the crater I think they may transfer that much quicker, depending the alt of the base inside the crater and the spawns.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 15, 2026, 09:44:36 AM
Sorry Fugitive I completely misread your original post, thought you wanted to prevent the airbases being taken, not make it easier. I could certainly put a map room on those bases rather than a town if that's what players want.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 15, 2026, 10:01:52 AM
Thinking about this some more, if one side takes all three airbases it kills the GV battle as well, as the side with the airbases can just bomb the other two sides' GVs with impunity, assuming they still have any V bases there. Better to have all three sides with an airbase so at least there is a chance for enemy fighters to attack the jabos. So whether the base has a town or a map room I think I'd still make the SP alts favour the country attacking from outside the crater. That way supplies and troops can be run into the base faster and possibly GVs can bombard the base from above.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Animl-AW on April 15, 2026, 11:48:44 AM
@Animl

These are the rules you break on daily basis and HiTech allows it, while I get warnings etc.;
I have no intention returning to AH while you are going around unpunished.

I am not disgruntled with the game, just you and your continued existence on the BBS.

I'm a problem you and HiTech's inaction created.

You've made AcesHigh my biggest regret. What a waste of time, energy, money and talent.

I hope it shuts down sooner rather than later now, so I can have the satisfaction HiTech has denied me of being rid of you.

Nonsense
You quit 10 yrs before my return. Since then, 2022, you only played a total of one month.

You created your own problems, victim of yourself. You are incapable of responsibility. You think the world owes you. You’ll keep the drama addiction going return or not.
Your tell is you’ve wanted it to die long before my return, you bad mouthed HT long before my return.

I do not bow to you.
You hijacked this thread to spread your endless hate with immature insults.
 You should have just left me alone.

I was even accused if stealing Challenger’s sounds, a lie to make me look bad to the masses.

Because of your drama we have no video on home page. You are destructive
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: LCADolby on April 15, 2026, 12:23:21 PM
Nonsense
You quit 10 yrs before my return. Since then, 2022, you only played a total of one month.

You created your own problems, victim of yourself. You are incapable of responsibility. You think the world owes you. You’ll keep the drama addiction going return or not.
Your tell is you’ve wanted it to die long before my return, you bad mouthed HT long before my return.

I do not bow to you.
You hijacked this thread to spread your endless hate with immature insults.
 You should have just left me alone.

I was even accused if stealing Challenger’s sounds, a lie to make me look bad to the masses.

Because of your drama we have no video on home page. You are destructive

What a load of utter bollocks.

Full on inaccuracy and mostly describes you.

Go eat a dick and choke on it.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: LilMak on April 15, 2026, 01:24:38 PM
So what’s the consensus? Because it looks like other tank town maps. Seems if they’re all capturable, one side will roll them during off hours. Looking at the layout, might be fun if the air bases are able to be taken but the V bases would not. I’d also take into consideration the altitudes of each base. If the air bases are higher than the V bases, it makes it easier for jabos to harass the GVs doing their thing in the middle which would be counter intuitive to letting the tanks duke it out.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: icepac on April 15, 2026, 03:27:54 PM
Isn't the crater itself there to discourage the weasels who fly planes at tank town?   

Can we disable Ord. and bombers within the crater?
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: DmonSlyr on April 15, 2026, 06:32:38 PM
I recon if you just take out the other teams ord, they wont be able to bombard. Or you can just call them out on 200. Thats always fun!
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: JimmyD3 on April 15, 2026, 08:59:16 PM
Thinking about this some more, if one side takes all three airbases it kills the GV battle as well, as the side with the airbases can just bomb the other two sides' GVs with impunity, assuming they still have any V bases there. Better to have all three sides with an airbase so at least there is a chance for enemy fighters to attack the jabos. So whether the base has a town or a map room I think I'd still make the SP alts favour the country attacking from outside the crater. That way supplies and troops can be run into the base faster and possibly GVs can bombard the base from above.

Bustr did a map with several bases with just map rooms and no town. They worked out pretty well, the only problem was you could drive through the map rooms,  park a gv inside and no one was the wiser. I installed them on a couple of my maps, but I didn't like how they allowed that. What I found was the Map Room Collision attribute was not checked. when I did set the Collision attribute ,it flagged an error and would not allow me to upload it.  Talked to Hitech about the issue, he said that was an issue with the error checker and he corrected it.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 16, 2026, 02:55:15 AM
Isn't the crater itself there to discourage the weasels who fly planes at tank town?   

Can we disable Ord. and bombers within the crater?

My original idea when designing CraterMA was to have airbases within the crater but at one point HTC went off fighter town layouts for MA maps so I replaced them with V bases before it was finished. So the crater making it hard to bomb tank town was a happy accident at the time rather than my intention.

When we had up to 500 players in the MA this layout worked fine, there were enough players to both keep the strat game going and to populate tank town. Now we have at best 150 players I don't think we can afford to split the players up like that any more. Using the centre of the map for all three sides' pilots and GVers works much better when numbers are very low, perhaps 50 or less. Anyone logging in is much more likely to see a reasonable size darbar in the crater as there are potentially twice the number of local enemies than anywhere else on the map. This makes them more likely to join in than log and so grow player numbers.

There is no way a map designer can disable ord at an airbase on an MA map. The only way to do it at all is to design a custom airbase with no ords but unfortunately custom objects are forbidden on MA maps. This is because such custom objects might introduce a bug that crashes the arena, something that HTC absolutely can't afford to happen to the MA. This issue keeps coming up so if and when Hitech gets back to me about my map revisions I may ask him whether he'd consider an ord-less base for MA use or some other way to permanently disable ords at specific fields. I'd rather disable ords than bombers as a bomber hangar would allow anti tank aircraft like the Ju 87G to still be used.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 16, 2026, 03:36:36 AM
So what’s the consensus? Because it looks like other tank town maps. Seems if they’re all capturable, one side will roll them during off hours. Looking at the layout, might be fun if the air bases are able to be taken but the V bases would not. I’d also take into consideration the altitudes of each base. If the air bases are higher than the V bases, it makes it easier for jabos to harass the GVs doing their thing in the middle which would be counter intuitive to letting the tanks duke it out.

The crater rim that the airbases would sit on is currently 6,000 feet high with the V bases around 100 feet. I originally made it this high because it is the highest altitude an airbase may be placed on an MA terrain (fully loaded Lancs struggle to take off any higher). I could lower the crater rim but I doubt that will help much. It was not my original intention to give GVers a place to fight in isolation and I don't think it is healthy for the game to let them do it now, we don't have enough players for that these days. There is always the outer ring of V bases to fight over if the jabos are camping TT. With so few SPs to choose from it should make defending these V bases much more likely to generate a fight than with the current layout.

The crater bases will get taken at some point, whether in off hours by a few players or by a horde when it is busier. My intention however is to make it easier to retake or resupply the airbases from outside the rim than it is from inside by advantageous placement of SPs and the same with the crater V bases.

If one side takes the airbases but leaves the V bases some jabos will just switch to the victorious side to bomb the other sides' GVs so you still won't get a jabo free fight, it is better for GVers that all three sides have an airbase so the jabos have to worry about enemy fighters.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 16, 2026, 03:41:05 AM
Bustr did a map with several bases with just map rooms and no town. They worked out pretty well, the only problem was you could drive through the map rooms,  park a gv inside and no one was the wiser. I installed them on a couple of my maps, but I didn't like how they allowed that. What I found was the Map Room Collision attribute was not checked. when I did set the Collision attribute ,it flagged an error and would not allow me to upload it.  Talked to Hitech about the issue, he said that was an issue with the error checker and he corrected it.

Good to know the bug was fixed. My current thinking is to go with the townless idea for the crater airbases, they are going to get taken anyway and it will make it easier to retake them with the way I am going to place the SPs.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 16, 2026, 03:47:55 AM
I recon if you just take out the other teams ord, they wont be able to bombard. Or you can just call them out on 200. Thats always fun!

That's always an option, although they'll likely just resupply the base until the ords are up again. A better tactic would be to have friendly fighters over TT feasting on all the jabos and bombers. Personally I think calling out on 200 is counterproductive, some players love to think of themselves as "notorious" and want to be called out for what others think of as bad behaviour.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: LilMak on April 16, 2026, 10:02:01 AM
The crater rim that the airbases would sit on is currently 6,000 feet high with the V bases around 100 feet. I originally made it this high because it is the highest altitude an airbase may be placed on an MA terrain (fully loaded Lancs struggle to take off any higher). I could lower the crater rim but I doubt that will help much. It was not my original intention to give GVers a place to fight in isolation and I don't think it is healthy for the game to let them do it now, we don't have enough players for that these days. There is always the outer ring of V bases to fight over if the jabos are camping TT. With so few SPs to choose from it should make defending these V bases much more likely to generate a fight than with the current layout.

The crater bases will get taken at some point, whether in off hours by a few players or by a horde when it is busier. My intention however is to make it easier to retake or resupply the airbases from outside the rim than it is from inside by advantageous placement of SPs and the same with the crater V bases.

If one side takes the airbases but leaves the V bases some jabos will just switch to the victorious side to bomb the other sides' GVs so you still won't get a jabo free fight, it is better for GVers that all three sides have an airbase so the jabos have to worry about enemy fighters.
All understandable. Speaking as a Jug dude, it would be beneficial to lower the altitude of the airbases to make it a bit more difficult for heavy fighters to grief the GV guys if possible. Contrary to popular belief, I want the tank guys to have their fun too.

That aside…Looking at the layout, I think it might be interesting to make the central GV bases uncapturable but have the airbases able to be taken. Especially with the altitude disparity. I think setting it up that way would keep the crater in play continuously since GV spawns feed the base taking effort (C-47s have been rendered useless with proximity dar). No team would have complete control of the crater. The central airbases, no matter how far any given team is pushed past the front lines, could always be threatened and GV fights in the crater would be indefinite. Adding a single central GV base with spawns to all three airbases which IS able to be captured might spur it further.

To summarize:

Three central GV bases as depicted with spawns to only one airbase (starting team) and spawns to the center of the crater. Not able to be captured.

One central GV base (a bullseye if you will) with spawns only to the three airbases around the crater but being constantly threatened by the other three bases.

Hope that makes sense.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: Greebo on April 17, 2026, 02:54:31 AM
I can certainly lower the crater airbases, 6K is too much of an advantage over any other airbase on the map anyway, none of which are higher than 2K.

The central airbase is an interesting idea but sadly it won't work for an MA terrain. It would have to be initially assigned to one of the three countries (a fourth neutral country would introduce a whole load of other issues). The country that initially owns it now has one extra base than the other two which unbalances the victory conditions for the map. So OK you give the other two countries each an extra base somewhere else on the map. This is also unfair as the central base is far more likely to get taken than the other two bases. There are rules that say an MA map must be fair to all three sides, must have equal numbers and types of fields and a central base breaks these rules.

BTW there are loads of other rules and guidelines regarding MA maps, far more than special event maps. If anyone's interested I once wrote a BBS post about it here (https://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/index.php/topic,393532.msg5240029.html#msg5240029). Its pretty old but should still be mostly correct.

I am not a fan of making the crater V bases uncapturable, griefers would still kill the hangars or bomb the GVs from the airbases. I have doubts about whether Hitech would allow it anyway (I vaguely recall someone else's MA map idea getting rejected for uncapturable fighter town or tank town bases).

Can I just state here that don't care much about tank town or fighter town being permanently active but I do care about all players, both pilots and GVers, having fun. Fighter town and tank town is just useful to kick start the fight when the map first appears. However the important thing about this new layout is that even after all the crater bases get taken by one side each countries' GVers or pilots will still usually only have three spawns or three nearby airbases (plus occasionally a fleet) to choose from. This means either two spots on the ring of airbases, two on the ring of V bases and one on the spokes leading to the crater. It is this concentration of the few available players that I hope will generate a fight even outside of peak hours.

Other QOL improvements I hope to make for GVers is to move the airbase towns nearer to the airfields and reduce spawn point to map room travel times. Also I'll try to create kill zones between the spawns and the map rooms where a defending GV can ambush incoming enemies. Finally I will clear spawn points and the routes to the map rooms of excess trees.
Title: Re: CraterMA isnt perfect but....
Post by: LilMak on April 17, 2026, 10:40:25 AM
Makes perfect sense Greebo. Still fun to spitball. I appreciate your feedback. Honestly, I appreciate all your efforts and would like to thank you for all you’ve contributed over the years.