Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: -gg- on July 31, 2026, 09:58:50 PM

Title: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on July 31, 2026, 09:58:50 PM
So remember a few weeks ago when we were talking about having a two-sided map in rotation? Some of you guys were saying that it would require a whole rewrite of the game. Lol. Well I just popped into the world war 1 arena and there's only a two-sided map. I guess they rewrote the game to do that right?

Guess it wasn't a big deal after all.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Wiley on July 31, 2026, 10:10:28 PM
Last I checked, WWI doesn't reset after victory conditions are met, does it?

Pretty sure things like that were the sticking point.

Wiley.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Molsman on July 31, 2026, 11:08:17 PM
AvA is also set to a 2 side War hence why it's Called Axis and Allies but that map doesn't reset either if War is won unless the Admins for the Arena Set it up that way.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on July 31, 2026, 11:16:52 PM
We’ve done this with several iterations in many threads. It will cost upwards of $600K minimum and require at least five or six people to design and test and validate and it would take 12 to 18 months. You can search the BBS and just the last year alone for a lot of this.

I think there’s a big difference between proving the engine supports two countries and converting the Main Arena to two countries. The WWI and AvA arenas don’t use the same strat system, reset logic, terrain layouts, scoring, or population balancing that the MA has been built around for over 20 years.

Looking at it as a business, not just coding, you’re probably talking 3,000–5,000 hours over 6–9 months with at least 4 people. A senior programmer, terrain developer, QA engineer, Dale leading the project, plus volunteer terrain builders converting and balancing maps. That doesn’t include community testing or post-release fixes. And that’s just to build it to get it finally validated and workable and all terrain and everything else is most likely double that.

At today’s market salaries, equipment, software, payroll burden, and overhead, I think you’re realistically in the $300,000–500,000 range just to execute the project. If you had to truly rebuild a small studio around it instead of one guy working from home, I don’t think approaching $1 million is nearly as far-fetched as people might think.

Please just enjoy what we have until we don’t have it anymore.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on July 31, 2026, 11:54:48 PM
600k minimum . Lol.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on July 31, 2026, 11:56:35 PM
So it would cost $600,000 minimum to make one map that has two sides on it? Wow! They must have invested a lot of money in making that two-sided world war 1 map
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Spikes on August 01, 2026, 12:14:46 AM
Which WW1 arena?
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Eagler on August 01, 2026, 07:31:43 AM
Here's an idea..  :joystick:

Let's make it one sided..

Everyone against everyone else  :airplane:

Plenty of red dar bar then  :aok

Eagler
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: CptTrips on August 01, 2026, 09:10:40 AM
So it would cost $600,000 minimum to make one map that has two sides on it? Wow! They must have invested a lot of money in making that two-sided world war 1 map

It's the strat\Eny\win the war logic.

Do you code?  If you do I'm sure you can imagine since he had the assumption he would never do it another way, that the 3-sided assumption is wired into every piece of logic.  I'm sure none of that was written to be configurable side.  I can imagine it would take a large rewrite, with all the associated risk of introducing unforeseen bugs.

And I am someone who think two-sides would solve a lot of problems.  But it is moot.  It won't happen.

1.  It probably would take a significant re-write.
2.  The other examples you site don't have all the Melee logic. 
3.  Hitech said he won't even consider it.

HT is VERY hesitant to just "try" stuff in the Melee.  Understandable.  It is the core of his business and income.

I don't think you could even  try it in a test arena.
HT always told me no other arena is allowed to have Melee logic like strat and base capture.  He doesn't want to create competitors for his Melee arena that is his bread and butter.  Melee has to be unique in that ability.

So as you pointed out, other arenas have faked a two-sides configuration, but none can ever have Melee capability, and he won't "experiment" with  core business arena.

Sadly, I don't see two-sides are a feasible option at this point in AH's life-cycle.

$0.02



Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 01, 2026, 09:28:58 AM
600k minimum . Lol.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

If you don’t want to put this in the proper context, that’s fine but it’s not a matter of just making a map. Your post title said “technical ability” It’s a minimum 18 month project that will require 4 to 5 people.

Minimum
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 01, 2026, 10:06:35 AM
Like somebody else said in one of the other threads, they made maps. And all you have to do is turn off all the other countries and leave one country or something. It's not a big deal to make a two-sided map from what they were saying.

Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 01, 2026, 10:07:19 AM
And to say that it cost $600,000 to make one two-sided map is utterly ridiculous. When you can see that they had access versus allies and world war I arenas that have two-sided maps.

Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Spikes on August 01, 2026, 10:12:26 AM
Like somebody else said in one of the other threads, they made maps. And all you have to do is turn off all the other countries and leave one country or something. It's not a big deal to make a two-sided map from what they were saying.


What WW1 arena only has two countries?
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: The Fugitive on August 01, 2026, 10:33:02 AM
And to say that it cost $600,000 to make one two-sided map is utterly ridiculous. When you can see that they had access versus allies and world war I arenas that have two-sided maps.

Neither of those maps could work in the MA, and it not because people are trying to be Aholes here, it due to technical reasons. If you build or bring in a 2 sided map the war will never be won. The game computer would always be looking for the base totals from the third country.... that is no longer there.... to see if one of the two teams has met the criteria for a map win. And before you say "it doesnt matter if the war is won" to a vast majority of the player base is very much does matter.

Thats where all the time and money comes in. How tied into the game each country is. Strats, bases, other mechanics, all would have to be unwound and rewritten to have only two sides. Its a lot of money to spend to "test" if a 2 sided map would work in the MA.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: LCADolby on August 01, 2026, 12:43:56 PM
600k minimum . Lol.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Shame Chalenge isn't still around, he would have been able to do it for less.

Just keep him away from awkward questions... and snakes.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: The Fugitive on August 01, 2026, 02:03:29 PM
Shame Chalenge isn't still around, he would have been able to do it for less.

Just keep him away from awkward questions... and snakes.

Challenge was the sound guy. I wish I had his FMOD setup. I have been messing around with the program and Im starting to get the hang of it. If I had his pack I think I could fix the issues with it.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 01, 2026, 02:12:05 PM
Yes it sounds like we are being mean but the development is not worth the squeeze.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Animl-AW on August 01, 2026, 02:19:23 PM
Challenge was the sound guy. I wish I had his FMOD setup. I have been messing around with the program and Im starting to get the hang of it. If I had his pack I think I could fix the issues with it.

1) more sounds than you expect
2) some of what he did (bless his heart) were just not fixable. You need a consistent sound to make a loop. Any tiny flaw becomes a repeat annoyance. His 51 was a good example of this. There was a looping rattle, which wasn’t realistic.

If you plan on doing a 120 plane pack you’re talking about 400-450 sounds, or more, depending how deep you dig

I’ve gad FMOD setup for 4 years now. Perfect loops are the biggest chore. Then pistons running slow and fast.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Animl-AW on August 01, 2026, 02:20:24 PM
Yes it sounds like we are being mean but the development is not worth the squeeze.

Considering the hours put in, you may be right. Current sounds are not bad.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Randy1 on August 01, 2026, 03:04:39 PM
You have to think back to the days when Hitech and staff were debating over a beer how to build AH.  That is what is foundation going to look like.  That is when the three country game basis would have come from.  Hitech must have predicted problems with a two-country game back then.  The reasoning behind that decision may still apply even today.

My guess is two country battles would be less dynamic than the rolling changes that happen with three countries.  There can be rapid changes in a three country system as player number changes, and two countries against one changes.  Also in a two country system if one country gets really dominate the game dies.  Now, two countries can gang up on the dominate country and beat them down.

I think the three country is not perfect but a two country system is a game killer.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 01, 2026, 04:03:13 PM
Back in the day countries used to work together to end maps or stop another country from holding one.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Animl-AW on August 01, 2026, 05:30:33 PM
You have to think back to the days when Hitech and staff were debating over a beer how to build AH.  That is what is foundation going to look like.  That is when the three country game basis would have come from.  Hitech must have predicted problems with a two-country game back then.  The reasoning behind that decision may still apply even today.

My guess is two country battles would be less dynamic than the rolling changes that happen with three countries.  There can be rapid changes in a three country system as player number changes, and two countries against one changes.  Also in a two country system if one country gets really dominate the game dies.  Now, two countries can gang up on the dominate country and beat them down.

I think the three country is not perfect but a two country system is a game killer.

3 country massive  multiplayer was first in AW, where both HT and Pyro had played, before WB snd AH.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Animl-AW on August 01, 2026, 05:32:51 PM

If it could be done doesn’t matter
The MA will never be 2 country

End of story
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 01, 2026, 06:38:38 PM
I don’t come at these numbers and assumptions lightly. As a project manager by trade, I’ve spent a lot of time trying to map out what it would mean to do a lot of the things this community wishes to see happen. ChatGPT has made this even more detailed.

I have a project within GPT that I’ve been using for over 18 months now and a lot of chats are dedicated to plane sets and how to use them. You would be surprised what it can tell you it’s absolutely helped my ACM and all kinds of other gameplay things.

I also have a couple that do extensive research projects on these things. I’ve been working towards doing a wish list group to put context behind what is being asked. Some things are simple and would just require a couple parameter changes that could easily be done if philosophy were aligned. A lot of things, however, would take a coding push and infrastructure.

A switch to two countries only which is not something I think is a good idea anyway even if numbers continue to dwindle. It’s one of those things that just sounds great on paper.

But let’s say the desire was there and someone wanted to do it whether it was Dale or the next owner if there ever was one. This is what it would take. A play in ten acts…

        Rewrite the country-state logic. The core arena code would need every hard-coded three-country assumption changed to two-country logic, including ownership, enemies, switching sides, scoring, country messages, and database records. This is likely a 2–4 month senior-programmer task before map or balance work begins. Also, it’s important to remember that AH is not built on universal code. It is a highly proprietary engine, not a modular commercial game engine.
* Rebuild the strategic system. The current model expects 3 HQs, 3 cities, 3 factory networks, 3 supply chains, and 3 sets of dependent fields. Every strat relationship would need to be reassigned, tested, and rebalanced so one side does not gain twice the strategic depth or leave a third network unused.
* Replace the map-winning formula. Current reset and victory conditions are based on one country taking territory from two opponents while retaining enough of its own. A two-country system needs a new percentage threshold, minimum-base rule, and anti-stalemate logic, followed by repeated simulations to determine whether wars last 6 hours, 3 days, or never end.
*   The arduous work to convert and validate every Main Arena terrain begins. Every active terrain would need to be reviewed, redesigned, and rebalanced for a true two-country war because you can’t simply remove one country from a map designed around three fronts, three strat systems, and three starting positions. This would require significant community involvement from terrain builders and an estimated 2,000–4,000+ hours of terrain development, followed by extensive playtesting to validate that each map remains balanced, competitive, and capable of producing healthy arena resets.
* Retune population balancing. With three countries, two sides can naturally pressure an oversized country; with two, a 60/40 population split means 50% more players on the larger side. ENY limits, perk bonuses, side-switch rules, and possibly automatic balancing would all need redesign to prevent repeated steamrolls.
* Modify the user interface and supporting systems. Country-selection screens, clipboard colors, score pages, roster displays, squad affiliations, country channels, warning messages, and victory announcements all currently expect Bishops, Knights, and Rooks. This is not difficult individually, but it creates hundreds of small regression points across the client and server.
* Run a dedicated beta arena and large-scale QA program. Internal testing cannot reproduce how 100–150 live players exploit capture routes, population shifts, and map geometry. A realistic test program would require 8–12 weeks, multiple full map cycles, volunteer players, telemetry, and several balance revisions.
* Build migration and rollback plans. Squads permanently associated with the removed country would need reassignment, historical statistics would need preservation, and players would need rules for choosing new sides. The old three-country system should remain deployable until the new format survives at least 30–60 days without major failures.
* Restart a small development operation to complete it professionally. A credible team would include Dale as system owner, 1 senior gameplay programmer, 1 terrain specialist, 1 QA lead, and part-time UI/community support for roughly 6–12 months. Salaries, payroll burden, hardware, software, testing, management, and post-release support put a realistic professional budget around $400,000–$800,000, with seven figures possible if the company must be fully rebuilt.
* Evaluate the financial return on investment. Assuming approximately 800 paying monthly subscribers (about $144,000 gross annual revenue at $15/month. This was the most latest player estimate by statistical availability of the player base publicly. It’s not even known if it’s correct. Credit to Lusche), a $400,000–$1,000,000 development project would likely require growing and sustaining the subscriber base to roughly 1,500–3,500 paying users over several years to reasonably recover the investment while still covering normal operating expenses, making ROI one of the most critical factors in determining whether a major feature should proceed.

From the extensive research I’ve had completed. This is the best estimate of those things at a minimal or maximum cost and resources. And as any of you know for any project, especially one in the IT world two weeks means two months means hang on a minute.

I don’t like peeing in Cheerios, I just like the thought projects. I wanna see the biggest the best for this game just like the rest of you, but we may have already had it and have as much as we’re gonna get now. I’m cool with that.



Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 01, 2026, 07:29:36 PM
Now that you've put it that way, I could see that it could take between 600,000 and 5 million dollars to make one map that had two countries on it.

How much do you figure it took to make the axis versus allies map? Maybe around 3 million and 5 years of testing?

What about the current two-sided world war 1 map? That didn't even appear until recently. How many hundreds of thousands of dollars do you think Dale spent making that map?


🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 01, 2026, 07:30:14 PM
.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Spikes on August 01, 2026, 07:34:31 PM
Where is this two-sided world war 1 map?
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Wiley on August 01, 2026, 08:06:45 PM
Now that you've put it that way, I could see that it could take between 600,000 and 5 million dollars to make one map that had two countries on it.

How much do you figure it took to make the axis versus allies map? Maybe around 3 million and 5 years of testing?

What about the current two-sided world war 1 map? That didn't even appear until recently. How many hundreds of thousands of dollars do you think Dale spent making that map?


🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

If it's easier for you to swallow, gg, look at it this way- HT is a big old meanie who won't do what you want.

End result is the same, less pointless talky talky.

Wiley.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Lusche on August 01, 2026, 08:20:48 PM
The war is already two sided. Just the maps are not.

It's prime time now, so it's late night for me, but I'm in the MA since hours. And all those hours there is basically no combat between Knights and Rooks. Apart from rare forays of a single Jabo or bomber or occasional BB duel, the is no combat between them, no attempts of capturing a field. Both countries are dog piling on the Bishops. For hours now.
Last time I was on during prime time it was the same, but this time it was the Knights getting smashed by Bishops and Rooks. For hours.
Yes, 20 years ago we had similar, but it never went on for that long, not 3,4 or even 5 hours during prime time. (And during euro hours, things are often worse).
(And IMHO the reason is not "lame donut players", but the low numbers, which prevents the creation of two separate fronts)


Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Animl-AW on August 01, 2026, 08:49:52 PM
I don’t come at these numbers and assumptions lightly. As a project manager by trade, I’ve spent a lot of time trying to map out what it would mean to do a lot of the things this community wishes to see happen. ChatGPT has made this even more detailed.

I have a project within GPT that I’ve been using for over 18 months now and a lot of chats are dedicated to plane sets and how to use them. You would be surprised what it can tell you it’s absolutely helped my ACM and all kinds of other gameplay things.

I also have a couple that do extensive research projects on these things. I’ve been working towards doing a wish list group to put context behind what is being asked. Some things are simple and would just require a couple parameter changes that could easily be done if philosophy were aligned. A lot of things, however, would take a coding push and infrastructure.

A switch to two countries only which is not something I think is a good idea anyway even if numbers continue to dwindle. It’s one of those things that just sounds great on paper.

But let’s say the desire was there and someone wanted to do it whether it was Dale or the next owner if there ever was one. This is what it would take. A play in ten acts…

        Rewrite the country-state logic. The core arena code would need every hard-coded three-country assumption changed to two-country logic, including ownership, enemies, switching sides, scoring, country messages, and database records. This is likely a 2–4 month senior-programmer task before map or balance work begins. Also, it’s important to remember that AH is not built on universal code. It is a highly proprietary engine, not a modular commercial game engine.
* Rebuild the strategic system. The current model expects 3 HQs, 3 cities, 3 factory networks, 3 supply chains, and 3 sets of dependent fields. Every strat relationship would need to be reassigned, tested, and rebalanced so one side does not gain twice the strategic depth or leave a third network unused.
* Replace the map-winning formula. Current reset and victory conditions are based on one country taking territory from two opponents while retaining enough of its own. A two-country system needs a new percentage threshold, minimum-base rule, and anti-stalemate logic, followed by repeated simulations to determine whether wars last 6 hours, 3 days, or never end.
*   The arduous work to convert and validate every Main Arena terrain begins. Every active terrain would need to be reviewed, redesigned, and rebalanced for a true two-country war because you can’t simply remove one country from a map designed around three fronts, three strat systems, and three starting positions. This would require significant community involvement from terrain builders and an estimated 2,000–4,000+ hours of terrain development, followed by extensive playtesting to validate that each map remains balanced, competitive, and capable of producing healthy arena resets.
* Retune population balancing. With three countries, two sides can naturally pressure an oversized country; with two, a 60/40 population split means 50% more players on the larger side. ENY limits, perk bonuses, side-switch rules, and possibly automatic balancing would all need redesign to prevent repeated steamrolls.
* Modify the user interface and supporting systems. Country-selection screens, clipboard colors, score pages, roster displays, squad affiliations, country channels, warning messages, and victory announcements all currently expect Bishops, Knights, and Rooks. This is not difficult individually, but it creates hundreds of small regression points across the client and server.
* Run a dedicated beta arena and large-scale QA program. Internal testing cannot reproduce how 100–150 live players exploit capture routes, population shifts, and map geometry. A realistic test program would require 8–12 weeks, multiple full map cycles, volunteer players, telemetry, and several balance revisions.
* Build migration and rollback plans. Squads permanently associated with the removed country would need reassignment, historical statistics would need preservation, and players would need rules for choosing new sides. The old three-country system should remain deployable until the new format survives at least 30–60 days without major failures.
* Restart a small development operation to complete it professionally. A credible team would include Dale as system owner, 1 senior gameplay programmer, 1 terrain specialist, 1 QA lead, and part-time UI/community support for roughly 6–12 months. Salaries, payroll burden, hardware, software, testing, management, and post-release support put a realistic professional budget around $400,000–$800,000, with seven figures possible if the company must be fully rebuilt.
* Evaluate the financial return on investment. Assuming approximately 800 paying monthly subscribers (about $144,000 gross annual revenue at $15/month. This was the most latest player estimate by statistical availability of the player base publicly. It’s not even known if it’s correct. Credit to Lusche), a $400,000–$1,000,000 development project would likely require growing and sustaining the subscriber base to roughly 1,500–3,500 paying users over several years to reasonably recover the investment while still covering normal operating expenses, making ROI one of the most critical factors in determining whether a major feature should proceed.

From the extensive research I’ve had completed. This is the best estimate of those things at a minimal or maximum cost and resources. And as any of you know for any project, especially one in the IT world two weeks means two months means hang on a minute.

I don’t like peeing in Cheerios, I just like the thought projects. I wanna see the biggest the best for this game just like the rest of you, but we may have already had it and have as much as we’re gonna get now. I’m cool with that.

I get your end point, but it's not that big of a production. If i were estimating a job I may go that route to ensure I don't go over budget. I would not agree 600,000 for that.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 01, 2026, 11:46:43 PM
If it's easier for you to swallow, gg, look at it this way- HT is a big old meanie who won't do what you want.

End result is the same, less pointless talky talky.

Wiley.

I don't feel that way at all. I'm not complaining about anything. I was just suggesting that it would be cool to try a two-player map. I'm not crying for one or anything. But I am arguing against the people who say it's a technical and possibility to pull it off. Lol. That made me laugh out loud. $600,000 at least. Hahaha!

I'm having a lot of fun in the game. I'm enjoying it a lot. Doesn't mean I can't have suggestions does it? Like a wish list kind of thing or just to argue about something. I don't have any delusions or illusions that any of these changes would take place. I actually couldn't care less.

Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Spikes on August 02, 2026, 07:24:18 AM
I don't feel that way at all. I'm not complaining about anything. I was just suggesting that it would be cool to try a two-player map. I'm not crying for one or anything. But I am arguing against the people who say it's a technical and possibility to pull it off. Lol. That made me laugh out loud. $600,000 at least. Hahaha!

I'm having a lot of fun in the game. I'm enjoying it a lot. Doesn't mean I can't have suggestions does it? Like a wish list kind of thing or just to argue about something. I don't have any delusions or illusions that any of these changes would take place. I actually couldn't care less.


Can you please point out the map that's already two-sided?
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Wiley on August 02, 2026, 10:58:52 AM
But I am arguing against the people who say it's a technical and possibility to pull it off.

Of course it's not a technical impossibility, nobody is saying it is.  What they are saying with varying degrees of detail, is the way the game is currently coded, it is not merely a matter of flipping a switch to have a 2 sided map function correctly in the Main Arena with all the things the Main Arena does.  Further, I am adding that HT has said repeatedly that he will not do the work for a 2 sided MA, and wouldn't do it if there was a big red button on his desk that would do it.  Since he's the one that gets to make the decision, it doesn't matter if it's 600 grand for a map, or $3.50 and a pack of gummi bears.  It's not happening.

Add to that some players have chosen this particular hill to die on (as well as shorter switch time), and every couple months we get another thread that seems to think it will be the one to convince him out of the literal hundreds.

Wiley.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 02, 2026, 11:29:29 AM
I don't feel that way at all. I'm not complaining about anything. I was just suggesting that it would be cool to try a two-player map. I'm not crying for one or anything. But I am arguing against the people who say it's a technical and possibility to pull it off. Lol. That made me laugh out loud. $600,000 at least. Hahaha!

I'm having a lot of fun in the game. I'm enjoying it a lot. Doesn't mean I can't have suggestions does it? Like a wish list kind of thing or just to argue about something. I don't have any delusions or illusions that any of these changes would take place. I actually couldn't care less.

You asked the technical ability to put one two sided map in the MA.

What I’ve shown is simply that it’s not impossible, it’s just highly impractical in the melee arena. It’s just not anywhere near as simple as making a map and sticking it in. The only way to do it is to reconfigure the entire system. By the way, it takes these fellas the better part of a year to make one map.

I’ve hired and created these teams before. Projects like this don’t just happen because we want them to. If you’re not gonna put your wish list in the proper context, then just put it in the wish list sub forum with all the rest of them.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 03, 2026, 12:53:03 AM
Can you please point out the map that's already two-sided?

Axis versus allies? One of the world war One arenas.
I haven't checked if axis versus allies is still available but it used to be and I used to play there it's two sides.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 03, 2026, 12:54:19 AM
You asked the technical ability to put one two sided map in the MA.

What I’ve shown is simply that it’s not impossible, it’s just highly impractical in the melee arena. It’s just not anywhere near as simple as making a map and sticking it in. The only way to do it is to reconfigure the entire system. By the way, it takes these fellas the better part of a year to make one map.

I’ve hired and created these teams before. Projects like this don’t just happen because we want them to. If you’re not gonna put your wish list in the proper context, then just put it in the wish list sub forum with all the rest of them.


🍍🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🍍
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: CptTrips on August 03, 2026, 08:57:57 AM
Axis versus allies? One of the world war One arenas.
I haven't checked if axis versus allies is still available but it used to be and I used to play there it's two sides.

I made WWIWF.  It's still 3 sides, but one side is hidden off in a corner with the bare minimum of strat to satisfy the terrain editor validation.

I assume AVA and the FSO and Scenarios are the same.

There are always 3 sides.  One side may be de-emphasized, but it's there.

But those arena where you fake it, don't have to run the Melee base capture, eny, strat, win-the-war logic.  So they can get away with faking two sides.

Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Max on August 03, 2026, 09:07:53 AM
Whether a 2 sided map takes a week, month, year or whatever is beside the point. Hitech is retired. His last fully involved commitment to the game was the rewrite of the graphics engine that evolved into AHIII. That was 10 years ago.

What you see is what you're gonna get until the balance  between income & expenses tips the balance in favor of the latter.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 03, 2026, 09:19:37 AM
But everybody really wants it to happen so just make it happen OK??
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Eagler on August 03, 2026, 09:33:45 AM
Whether a 2 sided map takes a week, month, year or whatever is beside the point. Hitech is retired. His last fully involved commitment to the game was the rewrite of the graphics engine that evolved into AHIII. That was 10 years ago.

What you see is what you're gonna get until the balance  between income & expenses tips the balance in favor of the latter.

Yep but some just like to yell at the clouds...

We can make it a two sided game..just takes us to login correctly for it to happen..

Same chance of that happening as it is to have HT code it for 2 sides..

 :cheers:

Eagler
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Chris79 on August 03, 2026, 09:36:41 AM
I can’t imagine it being all that difficult.
Create a map where the third countries bases are scattered evenly amongst the other 2 and disable flight for that country.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: CptTrips on August 03, 2026, 09:50:34 AM
I can’t imagine it being all that difficult.
Create a map where the third countries bases are scattered evenly amongst the other 2 and disable flight for that country.

How does that affect ENY?

How does that affect auto-switch?

How does that affect the win-the-war field ownership percentage?

What happens on a reset and the countries rotate position?

Setting it up is one thing.  How it functions is another.  The problem is that behavior is undefined (because you are circumventing the designed behavior) and the negative effects are hard to predict and HT doesn't like to "experiment" with the Melee.  And no other arena is allowed to have the win-the-war logic to test in.

But even if it were technically feasible, HT has stated he won't consider it.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Spikes on August 03, 2026, 09:54:36 AM
Axis versus allies? One of the world war One arenas.
I haven't checked if axis versus allies is still available but it used to be and I used to play there it's two sides.
There's a 3rd country base in the bottom left of ww1wf. There are no maps that exist that only have two countries. It is not possible.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 03, 2026, 10:14:20 AM
Do people actually read these threads or just the last few posts. The repetition in responses is pretty telling. What are we even doing here anymore?
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 03, 2026, 10:52:36 AM
But everybody really wants it to happen so just make it happen OK??

no. I was just saying it would be cool to try. To put it in rotation.....  but the warriors come out and act like someone is trying to rewrite the bible. So uptight and hilariously Karen-ish behavior out of some of you.

Then we have the ridiculous reasons ( and a $600,000 estimate)  for why it can't happen, and that's why I'm here laughing at those.

Nothing more than that.

Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Spikes on August 03, 2026, 10:56:24 AM
Well you were wrong about a 2 sided map already existing so why wouldn't you be wrong about other things? Lol.

Lol.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: CptTrips on August 03, 2026, 11:06:58 AM
no. I was just saying it would be cool to try. To put it in rotation..... 

I'd love to see a true two-side experiment.

I'm not being a Karen, I'm just explaining why I wouldn't hold your breath.

It will never happen because HT said he won't consider it even if it were technically feasible (and I'm pretty sure it isn't feasible without serious code changes).

I don't take a stand on the estimate, because it doesn't matter.  Even if it were an easy change, a days worth of work, HT said he won't consider it.

I don't know how else to explain it to you.

Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Max on August 03, 2026, 11:17:36 AM
(https://i.postimg.cc/GhtBjY3W/lilengine.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 03, 2026, 02:31:39 PM
You said it would be cool to try and ask for the technical feasibility and it’s been explained to you in an amazing amount of ways. You literally have to rewrite the coding of aces high… it’s bible so to speak. That takes people time and money. Expensive people who take a long time to do expensive things.

But now, where are the warriors trying to put a stop to some kind of change what you just wanted to try something… ok go do it then? Please report back?

Have you ever hired a team of developers and given them a project of this detail. Remember, this is a proprietary code, not a commercial engine so unless it was somebody who has already worked on the code, they would also need to be training time.

What you thought was a two sided map is not it’s just a three sided map with one side hidden and as you’ve been explained several times it can’t be used in the MA… without recoding.

Dale would be lucky to get through of it for 600K or less.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 03, 2026, 02:51:55 PM
 :rofl
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: hazmatt on August 03, 2026, 02:52:57 PM
I'm pretty sure the melee will never be changed.

I think the only possibility of this happening would be to have an arena setup with a 2 sided map like Axis and Allies or the Western front Arena but I'm pretty sure it would lose the "win the war" and "eny" functionality.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Chris79 on August 03, 2026, 05:24:28 PM
How does that affect ENY?

How does that affect auto-switch?

How does that affect the win-the-war field ownership percentage?

What happens on a reset and the countries rotate position?

Setting it up is one thing.  How it functions is another.  The problem is that behavior is undefined (because you are circumventing the designed behavior) and the negative effects are hard to predict and HT doesn't like to "experiment" with the Melee.  And no other arena is allowed to have the win-the-war logic to test in.

But even if it were technically feasible, HT has stated he won't consider it.

For a test run it would be relatively easy. As for Eny, that would require programming.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: CptTrips on August 03, 2026, 05:30:42 PM

For a test run it would be relatively easy. As for Eny, that would require programming.

How do you get past the "HT won't consider it" part?
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 04, 2026, 07:55:15 AM

.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 04, 2026, 08:26:38 AM
Well you were wrong about a 2 sided map already existing so why wouldn't you be wrong about other things? Lol.

Lol.

Really? haha. I was ignoring answering you on that question because I knew you were dying to spring into action with that. HAHAHAHAHA

I said this on the first page. all you have to do is leave one base on one country and have it hidden off the map ( like axis vs allies) and disabled

Axis v Allies is a two sided map and so is Western Front WWI.

So, no 600k or special development needed and we could have a two-sided map in the rotation. The laws of physics don't need to be altered.


Like somebody else said in one of the other threads, they made maps. And all you have to do is turn off all the other countries and leave one country or something. It's not a big deal to make a two-sided map from what they were saying.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Spikes on August 04, 2026, 08:37:04 AM
Ignoring me? Sounds childish.

But regardless, they are not two-sided. "All you have to do" is pulling a lot of weight here when you have no idea how any of it works. It is possible to disallow people from joining a country, but there is currently no way to force people off of a side or to a given side. I also don't believe it is possible to place bases "off map" or make them "hidden" as I'm sure we would have done things like that in SEA terrains long ago. I haven't seen an AvA map recently but maybe jaeger found a way.

I'm not a map maker, so I don't have all the answers and can't be certain, but I've been a CM helping run two-sided events for probably as long as you were banned from here, so that's got to count for something.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: hazmatt on August 04, 2026, 08:57:29 AM
for probably as long as you were banned from here, so that's got to count for something.

Ouch. What's this all about? I missed something obviously.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 04, 2026, 09:13:42 AM
Ignoring me? Sounds childish.

But regardless, they are not two-sided. "All you have to do" is pulling a lot of weight here when you have no idea how any of it works. It is possible to disallow people from joining a country, but there is currently no way to force people off of a side or to a given side. I also don't believe it is possible to place bases "off map" or make them "hidden" as I'm sure we would have done things like that in SEA terrains long ago. I haven't seen an AvA map recently but maybe jaeger found a way.

I'm not a map maker, so I don't have all the answers and can't be certain, but I've been a CM helping run two-sided events for probably as long as you were banned from here, so that's got to count for something.

I wasn't really ignoring you, I was refraining from answering your "gotcha" question that you kept asking like a little kid. Lol.

Why don't you log into the access versus allied arena right now and go check out the map. It's a two-sided map. There's one base hidden off the map. It's not meant to be part of the map but obviously you can go to it. It's not meant to be part of the gameplay just like the world war I arena ONE base that's left there.

So you're telling me that those are not two-sided maps? Lol!

It's incredible what you guys say here. Just come here for laughs mostly because a lot of people here are totally ridiculous
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 04, 2026, 09:33:37 AM
We’re all being punked right??

This cannot be real.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 04, 2026, 10:51:59 AM
What do you mean trolled? I mean you are being pretty ridiculous and saying that you can't make a two-sided map when there's two sided maps that you can log into right now.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 04, 2026, 10:55:38 AM
I'm a quick learner. I could probably take a weekend and learn how to make a map. Probably make a two-sided map for about 50 bucks. Save almost $600,000.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: CptTrips on August 04, 2026, 11:06:19 AM
I'm a quick learner. I could probably take a weekend and learn how to make a map. Probably make a two-sided map for about 50 bucks. Save almost $600,000.


OK. 

Call HT and offer to make a two-sided map for the Melee.

Report back with the conversation notes.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Spikes on August 04, 2026, 11:25:58 AM
There's one base hidden off the map. It's not meant to be part of the map but obviously you can go to it.

So you're telling me that those are not two-sided maps? Lol!

So it is a hidden base that's not really hidden? I'm well aware what the intention of them is supposed to be, since I've been involved with map design for quite some time. There are still limitations like I stated prior, the inability to disable a country entirely and force people onto the other two countries.

Also as CptTrips stated, HT has no desire to have a two sided war and it would require major code changes. How much change or how much money, who knows.

So yes, they are not technically two sided maps, since this thread is about the technical feasibility of it.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: CptTrips on August 04, 2026, 11:33:03 AM
And with the graphics, and subscription model, and competition,  all that work and risk wouldn't make any market difference at this point.

LTM

Long-term-maintenance.

Just keep it running.


Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: AKIron on August 04, 2026, 12:07:05 PM
(https://i.ytimg.com/vi/187trX0mo1o/maxresdefault.jpg)
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: The Fugitive on August 04, 2026, 12:20:15 PM
(https://media.tenor.com/eXUNsQdTZ20AAAAe/troll-feed.png)
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: AKIron on August 04, 2026, 12:24:06 PM
5 pages in it's a little late for that.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: The Fugitive on August 04, 2026, 12:25:04 PM
5 pages in it's a little late for that.

It seems some people need reminding  :)
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: CAV on August 04, 2026, 01:09:43 PM
Personally I'm okay with the three-sided system. And I think recoding the game towards a two-sided system would be a bridge too far. But...


Would like to see the radar turn back the old system.

Maybe a few lines of coding preventing two teams from gangling up on one...
Something as simple as once you take a base from one A side. The next base taken must be from side B.

And a simple, easy attrition system. Something that is simple and easy. Like, Once you die from enemy action 3 to 5 times from the same base. You are locked out of that base for an hour.

CAV
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: hazmatt on August 04, 2026, 01:58:27 PM

Would like to see the radar turn back the old system.


This idea seems to be shared by many people. The problem appears to be that the people who are listened to aren't calling for this to change. In my experience the way it works is you could have 100 people that want something but nothing will change until one of the people who are actually listened to suggest it and then it will get changed. My suggestion would be to find one of those people and have them suggest it.   :noid
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Lazerr on August 04, 2026, 02:24:49 PM
There isn't enough players to support a 3 sided war anymore.. maybe for a few hours in US primetime.  Especially with a 14.95 a month price tag.  There just isn't enough p2p interaction the rest of the time.

It's the only way to grow the game IMO... if it stays like this it will wither away slowly.  I've accepted the later, and log in rarely just to observe maps that are too big and spread out.. and cheesedog gameplay from the remaining player base.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: hazmatt on August 04, 2026, 03:01:30 PM
and cheesedog gameplay from the remaining player base.

 :rofl
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: The Fugitive on August 04, 2026, 03:08:52 PM
Personally I'm okay with the three-sided system. And I think recoding the game towards a two-sided system would be a bridge too far. But...


Would like to see the radar turn back the old system.

Maybe a few lines of coding preventing two teams from gangling up on one...
Something as simple as once you take a base from one A side. The next base taken must be from side B.

And a simple, easy attrition system. Something that is simple and easy. Like, Once you die from enemy action 3 to 5 times from the same base. You are locked out of that base for an hour.

CAV

The attrition thing will never happen. If there is only one fight going on your front in a low numbers time, your out of the fight for an hour.

The other point I put forward years ago. I suggested that after team A took two bases from Team B they would have to take at least one base from Team C. Some of the coad for it may already be in the game from back in the days when we had the "base capture path". It didnt seem to catch much attention back then, but I think it would be a boon for low number times like we have now, generating a fight on different fronts. Major down fall with the idea is it is forcing players to do something other than what they want. Forcing players to do something has never been a good idea around here.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: -gg- on August 04, 2026, 03:17:07 PM
So it is a hidden base that's not really hidden? I'm well aware what the intention of them is supposed to be, since I've been involved with map design for quite some time. There are still limitations like I stated prior, the inability to disable a country entirely and force people onto the other two countries.

Also as CptTrips stated, HT has no desire to have a two sided war and it would require major code changes. How much change or how much money, who knows.

So yes, they are not technically two sided maps, since this thread is about the technical feasibility of it.

You're very childlike it seems. Purposely obtuse. They made those two sided maps even with the limitations of the game. Functionally they are two-sided maps meant to be two-sided maps. Axis versus allies is a two-sided map and you're not going to tell me otherwise just because of the fact that they had to leave a Bass from the third country hidden and not usable in the game. Don't be ridiculous

So they could easily put a two-sided map into the rotation in the main arena and it wouldn't cost $600,000 to do it.

Trolling? I don't think so. Just responding to the idiocy of a few people here. People that made it out like it's in a possibility to make a two-sided map and put it into the rotation. Ridiculous. It's quite easy to do.


Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: hazmatt on August 04, 2026, 03:27:27 PM
You're very childlike it seems.

This have something to do with his avatar? I find it rather hypnotic.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Spikes on August 04, 2026, 03:38:22 PM
You're very childlike it seems. Purposely obtuse. They made those two sided maps even with the limitations of the game. Functionally they are two-sided maps meant to be two-sided maps. Axis versus allies is a two-sided map and you're not going to tell me otherwise just because of the fact that they had to leave a Bass from the third country hidden and not usable in the game. Don't be ridiculous

I'm sorry you think that. The maps are not two sided. They are coded to have 3 sides and that is unavoidable. If you think otherwise, give HT a call. Not sure he will be able to get through the density, though.
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: Dadtallica on August 04, 2026, 03:45:54 PM
You're very childlike it seems. Purposely obtuse. They made those two sided maps even with the limitations of the game. Functionally they are two-sided maps meant to be two-sided maps. Axis versus allies is a two-sided map and you're not going to tell me otherwise just because of the fact that they had to leave a Bass from the third country hidden and not usable in the game. Don't be ridiculous

So they could easily put a two-sided map into the rotation in the main arena and it wouldn't cost $600,000 to do it.

Trolling? I don't think so. Just responding to the idiocy of a few people here. People that made it out like it's in a possibility to make a two-sided map and put it into the rotation. Ridiculous. It's quite easy to do.

lol YES!!! You can just make a two sided map and stick it in the MA.

Then what???????????????????

What?????
Title: Re: On the technical feasibility of making a two-sided map.
Post by: CptTrips on August 04, 2026, 04:21:00 PM
So they could easily put a two-sided map into the rotation in the main arena and it wouldn't cost $600,000 to do it.

Except that it wouldn't function properly.

Also, HT would never allow it, even if it did.  He doesn't think a 2-sided design makes a good arena.  Period.  Full stop.

If you want to argue that point, that is another discussion.  But that was his stance last time I saw him comment of the option.

You can't test the idea in another arena because I was told no other side arena is allowed to have win-the-war.  And you wouldn't want to divide the already low numbers.