Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: Shane on September 03, 2026, 08:45:23 AM

Title: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 03, 2026, 08:45:23 AM
The quality of ethos on display by long time players is... kind of, well, not unexpected and quite on brand these days.

There's a nice list of exploits and abuses by players - why? I dunno, but let's take a look at one that's not quite either.

I can recall the day when 2 sides would work to stop a reset, instead of one side helping the bigger side.

This is a common pattern in the mornings, knits and rooks low numbers against the bish swarmbois, and knits chose to still hit on rooks?  Low class.

I don't mind the .rpt abuse because calling out this low class play is worth knowing I made a painful point to these players. 

But anyway, knits.. really hitting 80 (after already taking 2-3 other undefended bases) while bish hit 79?  Every morning has been like this - one reason why I went rook from knits.

Seems like some knits skwads are just bish auxillary. 23-6 so much fun.

ENY cannot fix or impact this because ethos cannot be hardcoded.

(https://i.postimg.cc/pX85bzw5/c-chair-bois.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/Tpd3nLYT)






Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: popeye on September 03, 2026, 09:31:07 AM
Interesting new statistics for AFK players.  I wonder if the AFK player's callsign turns red in the radio list.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Sully on September 03, 2026, 09:53:06 AM
I will poke and stir. Usually never in the mornings though. Always in hopes of making something happen Shane <S>. Might feel some despair if the numbers are up against me but then just use some strategies to get to target. Those numbers are extremely low to embark on a great bish crusade from any pov it's discouraging
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 03, 2026, 09:53:50 AM
I don’t play day time
But at primetime Bish and Rooks tend to act as one country, almost daily, gang banging the snot out of knits, again almost daily, not one fight on the Bish Rook front. I’ve come to call them Rish.

We got so sick of it, especially a bish sqd who dump 2 bars on a near undefended bases of maybe 2-5.

So we left that front to give them nothing to shoot and put our forces on rooks. So no, we are nit going to split our forces every single night to be totally pummeled on both fronts.

So while another bish sqd milkruns in the morning I don’t want to hear it with what happens at primetime.

The harm this causes the game is big and knits just log off. They log in, look at map and log off.  THEY DO NOT CARE. This is why sqd stats matter not.

All Rish knows us full country horde gang bangs. “everyone gets their turn” ya those sides get it once every two weeks to a month and cry when they swallow their own meds. Again, not a singke fighgt on bish-rook front.

With low numbers it’s nothing but destructive, period.

You’re not doing any different with mornings as primetime. Ya knits get burned out and return favors. Get a kleenex

The perfect example why 2 countries would never work. Bush and rooks would just go to one side as Rish

<shrug>
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 03, 2026, 10:13:57 AM
I don’t play day time
But at primetime Bish and Rooks tend to act as one country, almost daily, gang banging the snot out of knits, again almost daily, not one fight on the Bish Rook front. I’ve come to call them Rish.

We got so sick of it, especially a bish sqd who dump 2 bars on a near undefended bases of maybe 2-5.

So we left that front to give them nothing to shoot and put our forces on rooks. So no, we are nit going to split our forces every single night to be totally pummeled on both fronts.

So while another bish sqd milkruns in the morning I don’t want to hear it with what happens at primetime.

The harm this causes the game is big and knits just log off. They log in, look at map and log off.  THEY DO NOT CARE. This is why sqd stats matter not.

All Rish knows us full country horde gang bangs. “everyone gets their turn” ya those sides get it once every two weeks to a month and cry when they swallow their own meds. Again, not a singke fighgt on bish-rook front.

With low numbers it’s nothing but destructive, period.

You’re not doing any different with mornings as primetime. Ya knits get burned out and return favors. Get a kleenex

The perfect example why 2 countries would never work. Bush and rooks would just go to one side as Rish

<shrug>

Could this have anything to do with rooks trying to take back bases that knits took earlier in the morning? You know, to prevent an evening knit win?

What will this look like in 8 hrs?    Or have bish already figured out how to game the afk eny update? 

(https://i.postimg.cc/yYhkxBvv/c-chair-cycle.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/JGn1dwwk)




Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 03, 2026, 10:45:40 AM
Yep, bish already learned gaming the afk eny update.   Saw B24's being used for the win...  what's the eny on those?  Oh... 20


AFK should not earn war win perks, maybe? Being AFK and all, right?



(https://i.postimg.cc/wMgQPz2R/c-chairs-afk.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/1n7FnLLy)

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 03, 2026, 12:21:44 PM
Could this have anything to do with rooks trying to take back bases that knits took earlier in the morning? You know, to prevent an evening knit win?

What will this look like in 8 hrs?    Or have bish already figured out how to game the afk eny update? 

(https://i.postimg.cc/yYhkxBvv/c-chair-cycle.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/JGn1dwwk)

Both can be true.

 Absolutely day milk running sets the pace for primetime. So it depends how you squint your eye each day/night

However EVERY SINGLE WEEKEND ( or 7 of 10)  is now every day bish and rooks work as one country with zero fights between them to gang knits. If cannit be that iften without some form if coordination, hence Rish.

At least one honorable sqd that switches sudes attempt to break that into a 3 front war. Kudos to them.

I have zero remorse bashing them on 200 as I watch 10-15 log because of it. So it’s not all about the hard fight, its watching them shove players to log off. They destroy numbers. And again, they do not care as ling as they don’t scratch their fingernail polish to roll almost undefended bases at prime time. I lost respect fir these antics. Then they get mouthy with air inflated balloon chest and rub it in.

I’m not afraid of a hard fight, its the destruction to the game Rish cause. They think its funny. Then whine like children here about liw numbers. Re-read that to ket it sink in.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 03, 2026, 12:32:14 PM
easy to solve the afk ENY exploit. Just remove EVY until more than 100 players are online.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 03, 2026, 12:38:04 PM
Can’t say it was an exploit. Not enough proof

However
Bish 29
Knits 18
Rooks 14

Knits got ENY
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 03, 2026, 12:46:34 PM
easy to solve the afk ENY exploit. Just remove EVY until more than 100 players are online.

meh, it's not so much about that as much as not rewarding those afk players with war win perks when they were... afk...
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: oTRALFZo on September 03, 2026, 01:02:47 PM
Trying to keep bases with the AM swarm of flies is all about impossible with the 25 bish vs 4 or 5 nits on the roster. you have just about 2-3 main choices if you ever log on as a nit/rook in the early AM
1) Fly fighter mode and get a million kills. Disregard any bases lost or what the map is doing. These are  very easy kills and gratifying if your into that thing.
2) Grab bases on the other less busy front. YES to some its boring but we do have those players that like taking bases
3) Fly for an hour and half in buffs to attack strats.

It drives me nuts too as a nit. I have logged on a few times early morning with the typical scenario: 3 nits on- 1 is on a long climb in buffs and the other 2 on the rook front. I dont agree with it but I got to understand it.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 03, 2026, 01:03:05 PM
Sad part. HT is doing his best to create fairness across the board. He’s trying to work with players to do so.

Some just make it harder for him to help us.


Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 03, 2026, 01:07:58 PM
meh, it's not so much about that as much as not rewarding those afk players with war win perks when they were... afk...

I feel like this is a minor issue at this point. I'm pretty sure most everyone has plenty of spare perk points. Does it really effect anything if a few afk players get more? I dont feel like anyone really uses all the points they have.
Not trying to be contrarian, just curious.Do a couple guys getting some undeserved perks effect your game, or did they have plenty of perks anyway. I just think unless perkies become rare or more useful this is a small problem.

on the other hand, maybe we will get a perk reset and a change in how perks are used then i could see this being an important distinction.

id almost make the argument that even afk or players who logged off probably contributed to that victory at some point.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 03, 2026, 01:15:51 PM
I feel like this is a minor issue at this point. I'm pretty sure most everyone has plenty of spare perk points. Does it really effect anything if a few afk players get more? I dont feel like anyone really uses all the points they have.
Not trying to be contrarian, just curious.Do a couple guys getting some undeserved perks effect your game, or did they have plenty of perks anyway. I just think unless perkies become rare or more useful this is a small problem.

on the other hand, maybe we will get a perk reset and a change in how perks are used then i could see this being an important distinction.

id almost make the argument that even afk or players who logged off probably contributed to that victory at some point.

Many of those morning players only play mornings into maybe lunch time and it's hard to earn perks when you're always under eny... so, yeah, winning the war perks are helpful to some.   

It's even more difficult for many to earn perks when numbers are more balanced because they're not used to dealing with that.

Personally, I'd rather see ENY values given an overhaul.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 03, 2026, 01:17:20 PM
Many of those morning players only play mornings into maybe lunch time and it's hard to earn perks when you're always under eny... so, yeah, winning the war perks are helpful to some.   

It's even more difficult for many to earn perks when numbers are more balanced because they're not used to dealing with that.

Personally, I'd rather see ENY values given an overhaul.

Fair enough. I would agree on ENY values getting an overhaul. we all know the yak-3 isn't 18 eny.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 03, 2026, 01:27:12 PM
In my opinion if you want completely fair you eliminate ENY.

I understand that overall the game is fair because everybody has the same rules, but it ends up being not fair in a practical sense because ENY is not applied to everybody at the same time.


Just because I happen to be on the side that has numbers at the moment. That's not my fault but I'm penalized for it and I have to take a crap plain and fly against people who are better than me so they can shoot me down easier? I don't like that. And then the other option is to either log off or change sides. And then when you change sides possibly flips the other way and then you get screwed anyway and then you can't change back. Lol.

But I'm not changing sides. I don't like to goof around and try to equalize the game for someone else. I don't mind if I'm outnumbered or anything else that goes on the game. I don't care who rolls bases or anything. I just want an even chance to fight against another person. And I don't like being penalized for whatever is happening in the arena that's beyond my control.

Get rid of the ENY. Keep the perk system and all that. Give newbies free planes I don't care. Just don't penalize me for no other reason than to give someone else an easier chance at killing me. Why am I being penalized?
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 03, 2026, 01:39:25 PM
In my opinion if you want completely fair you eliminate ENY.

I understand that overall the game is fair because everybody has the same rules, but it ends up being not fair in a practical sense because ENY is not applied to everybody at the same time.


Just because I happen to be on the side that has numbers at the moment. That's not my fault but I'm penalized for it and I have to take a crap plain and fly against people who are better than me so they can shoot me down easier? I don't like that. And then the other option is to either log off or change sides. And then when you change sides possibly flips the other way and then you get screwed anyway and then you can't change back. Lol.

But I'm not changing sides. I don't like to goof around and try to equalize the game for someone else. I don't mind if I'm outnumbered or anything else that goes on the game. I don't care who rolls bases or anything. I just want an even chance to fight against another person. And I don't like being penalized for whatever is happening in the arena that's beyond my control.

Get rid of the ENY. Keep the perk system and all that. Give newbies free planes I don't care. Just don't penalize me for no other reason than to give someone else an easier chance at killing me. Why am I being penalized?
Eny probably isnt going anywhere, Dale likes it, and it can be a useful tool.
Maybe a simple compromise of being able to use perk points for eny planes. Something like 50 points for a 5 eny plane would probably do it. along with a eny rebalance of the existing planeset.

id like to see all the 5 eny planes perked just to get some variety, but that wont happen either.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 03, 2026, 01:44:04 PM
Eny probably isnt going anywhere, Dale likes it, and it can be a useful tool.
Maybe a simple compromise of being able to use perk points for eny planes. Something like 50 points for a 5 eny plane would probably do it. along with a eny rebalance of the existing planeset.

id like to see all the 5 eny planes perked just to get some variety, but that wont happen either.

A useful tool that puts one player at a disadvantage for the sake of another. That's my problem with it. I don't want the disadvantage OR the advantage. I want an equal plane set to what anyone else is able to select from.

Rather than penalize players, give the outnumbered side cheaper perk planes or something. Don't take stuff away from anyone.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 03, 2026, 01:48:48 PM
Quote
Eny probably isnt going anywhere, Dale likes it, and it can be a useful tool.
Maybe a simple compromise of being able to use perk points for eny planes. Something like 50 points for a 5 eny plane would probably do it. along with a eny rebalance of the existing planeset.

Agreed

Lawlessness will not promote fairness it will exploit it. They try to break ENY, they will try to break much more without it

It all looks good on paper to remove rules and road blocks. Its when you thrown in human nature it burns like a bonfire.

Issue is to tweak it to work right. Which HT has already acknowledged he is willing to do.

Repeats just get ignored. That war will not be won

I don’t care for ENY, I don’t like stopping for stop signs either.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 03, 2026, 01:53:40 PM
Another way to put this is that ENY system that makes you not have as much fun during certain times that you play because other people are not having as much fun, so the penalty has to turn against you so that they can have more fun while you don't have fun.
And it's only fair in the fact that it can happen to anyone. So one day maybe it'll be someone else's turn not to have fun because they can't play on an even playing field.

So it's like, tough crap. The two hours that you have to fly tonight you're going to only be able to pick crappy planes because this is your turn to sacrifice for the other team. The other team needs to have more fun or the ability to kill you easier and you just have to take it tonight. So either stop complaining or log off. Lol.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Spikes on September 03, 2026, 01:54:28 PM
The fundamental aspect of ENY is that it is compensating for more numbers on one side without forcing players to another side. You might be forced to fly a P-51B instead of a P-51D, or an La-5 instead of an La-7, but the side you fly on has X% more players. Logically, there is a good chance you'd have more friendlies in the fight with you. The rationale is that an La-5 + P-51B vs. a P-51D (or insert any low ENY value plane here) is considered "fair".

I assume that ENY rarely gets high enough to force people into "crap planes" (at least as far as the MA is concerned) like the C.202, 110C, or P-40C. I'm talking higher than 30. I'm sure Lusche could provide more numbers info. I also believe there is an upper limit to the max ENY number, but no idea what that is. 31 maybe?

Most multiplayer games have some sort of side balancing in place. Most force you to another side or don't let you join a particular side upon entry. ENY is a decent compromise. There's a server in IL2 that has no side balancing and is often 2:1, sometimes 3:1, and it isn't real fun getting piss pounded by Tempests and Ponies every sortie.

I do think that players should be able to switch to the lower # side at any time. That would alleviate a lot of issue. I don't really care what side I fly on, but I don't like the auto-switch because sometimes it pulls you away from a good fight.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Mayhem on September 03, 2026, 01:55:18 PM
Eny ....
(https://images.meme-arsenal.com/9796a5c859758fa972abd8eaeef14f73.jpg)
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 03, 2026, 01:59:27 PM
A useful tool that puts one player at a disadvantage for the sake of another. 

it's not that personal, the intent is to put one entire side at a disadvantage to negate the major advantage in numbers they have. I see it kind of as a for the good of all thing.

on the other hand, i do agree sometimes the punishment is so harsh that it is no longer worth playing. This causes players to log off. That is not ideal.

of course if people are getting constantly horded 5-1 by ponies they are gonna log also.

and since people would revolt if you forced team balancing, options are kind of limited.

there needs to be some compromises i think. Ideally something that doesnt leave players feeling they have to log off.
maybe when eny kicks in, a pop up that gives some free perk to anyone willing to jump sides.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 03, 2026, 02:00:03 PM
Another way to put this is that ENY system that makes you not have as much fun during certain times that you play because other people are not having as much fun, so the penalty has to turn against you so that they can have more fun while you don't have fun.
And it's only fair in the fact that it can happen to anyone. So one day maybe it'll be someone else's turn not to have fun because they can't play on an even playing field.

So it's like, tough crap. The two hours that you have to fly tonight you're going to only be able to pick crappy planes because this is your turn to sacrifice for the other team. The other team needs to have more fun or the ability to kill you easier and you just have to take it tonight. So either stop complaining or log off. Lol.

With all due repeat. No matter how you paint the same intent, repeat until the world goes flat, it will not remove it. It won’t he the magic wand. <shrug>

These points have all been made over 5000 times. Its not a new approach.
It’s kinda beating a dead horse

<S>
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 03, 2026, 02:14:21 PM
I'm entitled to voice my opinion. Customer giving feedback. I don't need others to tell me my experience is invalid - because it's 100 percent valid. During the time that I play, I am usually unable to fly planes that others are able to fly and it's not through any fault of mine. It's taking my game experience and penalizing me and there's no other way you can word that. That's the net effect of it.

Take my ability to choose a good plane because some other player is on a side that has three less players. That's messed up.


Taking away from my game experience so someone else can enjoy the game a little more while I enjoy it less.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 03, 2026, 02:25:47 PM
Also, ENY doesn't seem to solve anything. You still see people here crying about gang-banging. Animl, you complain about gang banging. So what does ENY solve? Still get gang banged, Still have to be outnumber and people still complain.

ENY causes people to sit in the tower to wait it out. Some people stick it out until they get tired of being shot down. Some people log. 18Whiskey logged off for two or three days because of it. I see it every night.

Last night, for awhile, we actually have ENY is our favor. That's the first time in maybe three weeks or more that I have EVER seen even a 1.0 perk bonus on our side. I fly maybe 2 hours a night and I can not remember the last time that has happened.

I don't mind being outnumbered. I don't care. That doesn't bother me.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 03, 2026, 02:27:40 PM
I'm entitled to voice my opinion. Customer giving feedback. I don't need others to tell me my experience is invalid - because it's 100 percent valid. During the time that I play, I am usually unable to fly planes that others are able to fly and it's not through any fault of mine. It's taking my game experience and penalizing me and there's no other way you can word that. That's the net effect of it.

Take my ability to choose a good plane because some other player is on a side that has three less players. That's messed up.


Taking away from my game experience so someone else can enjoy the game a little more while I enjoy it less.

Your opinion is valid. I just don't think the solution can be to drop eny completely. I agree that would be a quick fix, but it will introduce other issues. I think if we want it to change we have to find some valid compromise that expands the system in a way that gives players options and incentives.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 03, 2026, 02:30:23 PM
Also, ENY doesn't seem to solve anything. You still see people here crying about gang-banging. Animl, you complain about gang banging. So what does ENY solve? Still get gang banged, Still have to be outnumber and people still complain.

ENY causes people to sit in the tower to wait it out. Some people stick it out until they get tired of being shot down. Some people log. 18Whiskey logged off for two or three days because of it. I see it every night.

Last night, for awhile, we actually have ENY is our favor. That's the first time in maybe three weeks or more that I have EVER seen even a 1.0 perk bonus on our side. I fly maybe 2 hours a night and I can not remember the last time that has happened.

I don't mind being outnumbered. I don't care. That doesn't bother me.

and to be fair in general i agree. i dont care about being outnumbered as much as being hampered in choice.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Spikes on September 03, 2026, 02:43:18 PM
So what does ENY solve? Still get gang banged, Still have to be outnumber and people still complain.
I just explained what it solves. Hitech explained what it solves. If you didn't have ENY and had forced side balancing, people would complain. If you had no side balancing and it was always 2:1:1 or 3:1:1, people would complain. People are always going to complain.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 03, 2026, 02:49:06 PM
I just explained what it solves. Hitech explained what it solves. If you didn't have ENY and had forced side balancing, people would complain. If you had no side balancing and it was always 2:1:1 or 3:1:1, people would complain. People are always going to complain.

Why would you have to have forced side balancing if ENY was removed?

ENY does not make people change sides  that I've ever seen. Only a very small percentage of players have auto-side switching enabled and those are the only people I ever see changing sides.

Most people sit in the tower waiting for ENY to change, or they will fly a crap plane that they don't want to fly or they will log before they will switch sides.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 03, 2026, 02:55:55 PM
it's not that personal, the intent is to put one entire side at a disadvantage to negate the major advantage in numbers they have. I see it kind of as a for the good of all thing.

on the other hand, i do agree sometimes the punishment is so harsh that it is no longer worth playing. This causes players to log off. That is not ideal.

of course if people are getting constantly horded 5-1 by ponies they are gonna log also.

and since people would revolt if you forced team balancing, options are kind of limited.

there needs to be some compromises i think. Ideally something that doesnt leave players feeling they have to log off.
maybe when eny kicks in, a pop up that gives some free perk to anyone willing to jump sides.

It's not personal - but it affects me personally. I don't care what others are doing and it's not my fault that the side I'm on has numbers.

It's a lot to ask to have a paying player taking a penalty for someone elses benefit. So they can have a better game experience. I don't care what the intent is, the result is that I am personally getting shafted so someone else can have a better time.

I get slaughtered over and over flying a crap plane by others flying LA7s because they need to have a leg up?

I sit in the tower. I fly the crap planes, then I log. And it happens every single night.



Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: haggerty on September 03, 2026, 02:56:38 PM
ENY does its job, if I wake up early and jump on the game im fighting alone or with 1 other person against 13+ bish,  they are all ENY gimped and unable to take anything they know how to fly while im flying free Tempests.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Spikes on September 03, 2026, 02:58:58 PM
Why would you have to have forced side balancing if ENY was removed?
Because people would complain.

ENY does not make people change sides  that I've ever seen. Only a very small percentage of players have auto-side switching enabled and those are the only people I ever see changing sides.

Most people sit in the tower waiting for ENY to change, or they will fly a crap plane that they don't want to fly or they will log before they will switch sides.
I typically switch to the low #s, but the issue with that is the switch timer far outlasts how often a side numbers can fluctuate, or a fight dies or the front moves. More enemies and cheap jets, what's not to love? There are downsides to the side switching option. Like I said, personally, I don't like it, nor do I use it.

Again, I'm not sure what sort of "crap planes" you're referring to, but unless ENY is sticking you in 30+ ENY planes, the majority in the 15-25 range are just fine.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 03, 2026, 03:13:26 PM
Part of my issue is also when people tell me that other planes are not so bad, or to "just learn to fly xxx". Like shaming me or dismissing a very legitimate point regarding my game experience.
 
I do fly other planes. A lot.




Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Spikes on September 03, 2026, 03:23:47 PM
I'm not shaming anyone. You are entitled to your opinion, I am entitled to mine.

The K4's ENY is 20 and is one of the best planes in the game. If you don't like it, that is just fine, but that doesn't mean it is "crap".
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Eagler on September 03, 2026, 04:44:13 PM
Not enough ammo in the k4 for most folks..

Eagler
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: captain1ma on September 04, 2026, 01:53:40 PM
Part of my issue is also when people tell me that other planes are not so bad, or to "just learn to fly xxx". Like shaming me or dismissing a very legitimate point regarding my game experience.
 
I do fly other planes. A lot.

come to Monday Night Madness in the SEA2 on Monday Nights. it will make you a better pilot and you'll have lots of fun. no perked planes. even jets on occasion. most of the crew in there will happily teach you and we use a targeting computer to help you with your aim. then when you get a crappy plane, you'll be deadly in it. Eagler flys a BF109F-4 most of the time. even though he wont admit to it, hes a terrorist in it. Horrido in his BF110. same thing, hes the nicest terrorist you'll ever meet, but he's very good in it. think about it?!! you're always welcome!
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Chris79 on September 04, 2026, 05:28:36 PM
I'm not shaming anyone. You are entitled to your opinion, I am entitled to mine.

The K4's ENY is 20 and is one of the best planes in the game. If you don't like it, that is just fine, but that doesn't mean it is "crap".


I believe the K4s eny is 15.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Chris79 on September 04, 2026, 05:29:48 PM
Not enough ammo in the k4 for most folks..

Eagler
A. Trigger discipline
B. Take a G14 with gondies to feel the power between your legs
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Lusche on September 04, 2026, 06:14:05 PM

I believe the K4s eny is 15.

Correct.

K-4: 15
G-14: 25
F-4, G-2, G-6: 30
E-4:40
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Eagler on September 05, 2026, 08:13:09 AM
A. Trigger discipline
B. Take a G14 with gondies to feel the power between your legs

I find the g2 with gonds the best 109 configuration..better than the g6 or g14 w/gonds..the rate of fire seems better in the g2..

The k4 is when there's a crowd and you need the speed... :airplane:

Eagler
Title: Fugitive - player ethos
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 12:17:28 PM
The other thread was locked for rule #3, so I'll put it where it should have gone, which is here, I guess.

==============


Look at this screenshot.  Tell me what you infer from it.  Then I'll point out what you so conveniently overlook. Then someone will come to your defense and I'll have a nice quote from the man in response.


(https://i.postimg.cc/mkjRnQsC/ahss411.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/7J5pGJbZ)
Title: Re: Fugitive - player ethos
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 12:29:45 PM
The other thread was locked for rule #3, so I'll put it where it should have gone, which is here, I guess.

==============


Look at this screenshot.  Tell me what you infer from it.  Then I'll point out what you so conveniently overlook. Then someone will come to your defense and I'll have a nice quote from the man in response.


(https://i.postimg.cc/mkjRnQsC/ahss411.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/7J5pGJbZ)

I'll be the dumb one, maybe just explain the issue? Bish are winning, bish have a ton of guys in flight, bish have eny, what am i missing?
Title: Re: Fugitive - player ethos
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 12:32:56 PM
I'll be the dumb one, maybe just explain the issue? Bish are winning, bish have a ton of guys in flight, bish have eny, what am i missing?

I'll suggest going back to the very first post in this thread and give it some more thought. 

protip: It's only indirectly related to ENY
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 12:33:40 PM
I'm not understanding that either, Shane,

One thing that I'm confused about is why the Inflight, AFK and Waiting numbers don't add up to the totals logged in and the percentage "non AFK"
Title: Re: Fugitive - player ethos
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 12:36:31 PM
I'll suggest going back to the very first post in this thread and give it some more thought. 

protip: It's only indirectly related to ENY
  That seems dangerously close to having to do critical thinking on a saturday. maybe spoon feed it to me like im 5.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 12:41:02 PM
I'm not understanding that either, Shane,

One thing that I'm confused about is why the Inflight, AFK and Waiting numbers don't add up to the totals logged in and the percentage "non AFK"

Go re-read my first post.  Day after day of this for the past 4 years I've been back.  (I think I have actually shamed a few players from leaving the morning bish swarm, so there's at least that.) 

The evenings are less grindingly redundant in that numerical imbalances and double teamings are more short lived, fluid and can still be addressed in fun ways because there are still sufficient numbers at play.


I had my own questions about that "waiting" category, but it's not relevant to the underlying theme of ethos.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 12:43:17 PM
Shane, it's not always an entire country working together. In your OP example you talk about "Knits" attacking 80"  - and it's just one bomber going there. That's not "Knits" attacking 80, that's one guy.

Lots of times I hear "Bish this..... Rooks always do this...." talk as if they all act as a team. Mostly they don't. Squads don't even always act as a team.

Anyway, who cares?
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 12:47:33 PM
Go re-read my first post.  Day after day of this for the past 4 years I've been back.  (I think I have actually shamed a few players from leaving the morning bish swarm, so there's at least that.) 

The evenings are less grindingly redundant in that numerical imbalances and double teamings are more short lived, fluid and can still be addressed in fun ways because there are still sufficient numbers at play.


I had my own questions about that "waiting" category, but it's not relevant to the underlying theme of ethos.

I dunno, im slow today. I agree players should police themselves, but as long as your not going to mandate auto side balancing, there isnt much you can do about actual numbers. People are animals and behave in pretty predictable ways most of the time. Ideally people would see how lopsided it was and even themselves out, but for various reasons that just will not happen. Especially in this game where everyone is absolutely set in thier ways of how its always been.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: The Fugitive on September 05, 2026, 12:55:55 PM
The imbalance in numbers.... to me anyway.... are those sitting in the tower that have NOT tripped the 5 minute timer and so are still counted towards the ENY calc.

Im with toasted, "Bish are winning, bish have a ton of guys in flight, bish have eny". Yes the Bish are a horde and number wise its not fair. But short of forcing "side balancing" it rarely is balanced.

Im part of the "Sic Puppies" , one of those horrible Bish squads that bring a thousand guys to take a base. Why? we enjoy flying together. Even if we are hitting undefended bases we have fun. The game side is just fodder for all the comments on squad channel. Im sure there are many others in the game that do the same thing so your never going to see balanced fights. To make the game side more challenging Id like us to split or force to take two bases at a time, but then the radio chatter get confusing as you dont know whos where, and splitting the guys to two channels takes half the fun away from the comments and the ribbing.

If we had two, three time the players we have today there would be more fights at different fronts and you could find the fight you want to play in, but with these numbers its not going to happen often.
Title: Re: Fugitive - player ethos
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 01:00:11 PM
  That seems dangerously close to having to do critical thinking on a saturday. maybe spoon feed it to me like im 5.

(https://i.postimg.cc/8P4D18YJ/pfarmemba.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)

Avert your eyes, below will be more words.

Two days apart, both around 8-9am cst, different maps.  Look at base counts. Why are knits hitting rooks instead of trying to take some of their bases back to prevent the win?

(https://i.postimg.cc/W4JQqx5X/corpah.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 01:08:03 PM
Shane, it's not always an entire country working together. In your OP example you talk about "Knits" attacking 80"  - and it's just one bomber going there. That's not "Knits" attacking 80, that's one guy.

Lots of times I hear "Bish this..... Rooks always do this...." talk as if they all act as a team. Mostly they don't. Squads don't even always act as a team.

Anyway, who cares?

Sigh, I can't expand the map big enough to show, but there was zero bish/knit activity. If you actually look at that image, you will see TWO plane dar blocks and a gv dar near the base. That's 3 of 4 and that 4th is very much within one of those dar blocks because nothing was happening on the knit/bish front.  I was there. I am there. Everyday.

I did display that on another screenshot tho... right here in this thread.

The mental gymnastics some of you are engaging in...  :rolleyes: 
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 01:10:50 PM
Part of the issue is also the maps, Sometimes you just want the map over with so your just trying to hasten one sides win.
Once your getting spanked and double teamed, sometimes a reset just looks like a better option.

the maps really do us no favors here, they are pretty much all geared to 1k players.

And you really cant break up the squads who come in like the pups and just break the equation.
(nor would you really want to i dont think)

You could however fix some of this with a better side switching option...
1. incentivize side switching when numbers are really bad, offer 50 perk points to swap

2. you may expand this to have it automatically move the player back to thier prefered team as more players log on and it evens out.
3. or have a time option, like switch for 30 min for x perks switch for an hour ect..
there are probably a bunch of ideas that could be used to make players think switching was a good idea.

better to try and incentivize people to do the right thing than force them to.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 01:15:45 PM
I'm not trying to be obtuse. I just don't really care. When I play, I have zero concern for who's winning the map or what country is attacking another.

I look at your OP and I pointed out that one guy in is attacking your base. That's what I see and I don't see any issue.

Sometimes the big hoard and fight is too far away for me (Knits) and I'll just go somewhere to try to start a fight with anyone. I don't typically want to fly more than 1 sector and I don't want to fly by myself into a giant hoard with two other counties involved - because no matter how you want to think of it, no two countries ever fully cooperate and try to attack the larger side.

I don't get bothered in the least by what you get bothered by. I just don't care. I only care about finding something to do for an hour or two.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 01:18:59 PM
Part of the issue is also the maps, Sometimes you just want the map over with so your just trying to hasten one sides win.
Once your getting spanked and double teamed, sometimes a reset just looks like a better option.

the maps really do us no favors here, they are pretty much all geared to 1k players.

And you really cant break up the squads who come in like the pups and just break the equation.
(nor would you really want to i dont think)

You could however fix some of this with a better side switching option...
1. incentivize side switching when numbers are really bad, offer 50 perk points to swap

2. you may expand this to have it automatically move the player back to thier prefered team as more players log on and it evens out.
3. or have a time option, like switch for 30 min for x perks switch for an hour ect..
there are probably a bunch of ideas that could be used to make players think switching was a good idea.

better to try and incentivize people to do the right thing than force them to.

Good ideas

I like the incentive options over the coercion/penalty any day.  I don't care what is given away to anyone else.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 01:23:09 PM
I only care about finding something to do for an hour or two.

That's the other thing, only like 50% of players are trying to win the war. the other 50% are just looking for a fight. Nothing wrong with this at all.

and most players prefer having someone to fight with as well as against. I'm safer in a group of friendly planes, i may not want to switch sides to be getting gang banged 5-1.

just another reason you will never be able to count on player ethos to even this out. if you want to even it out some system will have to be put in place to incentives or force it. otherwise no one will swap because its not in their best interest. and that's really animal rule number 1 isn't it.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Spikes on September 05, 2026, 01:26:37 PM
Personally, my only incentive needed to switch is just the ability to switch again within a reasonable time. It was mentioned somewhere and I like the idea, to always be able to move to the low # side. Or even if trying to go to another low # side cuts the timer to an hour.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 05, 2026, 01:30:53 PM
Part of the issue is also the maps, Sometimes you just want the map over with so your just trying to hasten one sides win.

What would you think if there was a system to offer the losing sides, terms of surrender?
Anyone could initiate the vote. Only the currently losing sides could vote, but if the majority of those agree, there is an immediate surrender, the winning side wins and the map rotates.
Rather than a slow painful slog on a map nobody likes.

I've played games where you could vote on next map. Similar idea.  Maybe if surrender is voted for, another vote lets the losers vote for the next map.

Not promoting that.  Just curious.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 01:32:29 PM
Personally, my only incentive needed to switch is just the ability to switch again within a reasonable time. It was mentioned somewhere and I like the idea, to always be able to move to the low # side. Or even if trying to go to another low # side cuts the timer to an hour.

Yea, honestly id also switch from time to time if i could go back in an hour or so. Really it kind of feels like your penalized if you switch sides currently.
I don't want to just be autoswitched though. A pop up saying things were off balance and asking for a switch for an hour would be cool i think. bonus if it includes a few perk points to get more people to do it.

I don't think we need to throw the current systems away, i do think we could maybe tweak them a bit.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 01:34:03 PM
What would you think if there was a system to offer the losing sides, terms of surrender?
Anyone could initiate the vote. Only the currently losing sides could vote, but if the majority of those agree, there is an immediate surrender, the winning side wins and the map rotates.
Rather than a slow painful slog on a map nobody likes.

I've played games where you could vote on next map. Similar idea.  Maybe if surrender is voted for, another vote lets the losers vote for the next map.

Not promoting that.  Just curious.

i like this in theory. though i might have the second place team also get some (but not a full) vote i think.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 05, 2026, 01:35:25 PM
i like this in theory. though i might have the second place team also get some (but not a full) vote i think.

The vote is person not per country.

If the majority of the losing players want out, let them out. 

Better than seeing them log off in disgust.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 01:38:04 PM
The vote is person not per country.

If the majority of the losing players want out, let them out. 

Better than seeing them log off in disgust.

yea, fair enough. there are times everyone knows its over. also would be better to rotate the map earlier in the night instead of killing the night early because the map ended and no one logs back on.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 05, 2026, 01:44:33 PM
yea, fair enough. there are times everyone knows its over. also would be better to rotate the map earlier in the night instead of killing the night early because the map ended and no one logs back on.

Letting your enemy win is the friction to prevent it from being used frivolously.

Getting to chose the next map is the palliative.

It would also be a good metric to see what maps get picked if users have a choice.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 02:00:05 PM
I'm not trying to be obtuse. I just don't really care. When I play, I have zero concern for who's winning the map or what country is attacking another.
I look at your OP and I pointed out that one guy in is attacking your base. That's what I see and I don't see any issue.

At least 3 verifiable knits hitting rooks in that OP screenie.   :rolleyes: :aok  Let's find them! The 4th is there somewhere too.

(https://i.postimg.cc/C13gPkKG/ostrich.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/YGzZj4Y0)


I get it, you only care about your own narrow experience as it relates to eny. This thread is not for casuals.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: socktigs on September 05, 2026, 02:05:00 PM
Bish Ethos...

1. Cowardice masked by group action
Many Bish are afraid of confronting someone directly. By acting in a group, they can appear tough and confident while hiding their own fear or insecurity.

2. Anonymity and reduced accountability
In a group, each member can claim they are “just following orders” or that they didn’t personally cause the harm. This anonymity makes it easier for Bish to act without fear of direct consequences, as others may protect them from blame.

3. Social status and control
Some Bish target the less numerous to assert dominance or control over others. In peer groups, excluding or harassing smaller individuals can signal who is “in” and who is “out,” reinforcing the Bish’s position within the group.

4. Power and intimidation through numbers
Bish often act in groups because they believe “there’s strength in numbers” and fear standing up for an even fight. A larger group can overwhelm a smaller target.

5. Unity and bonding
When the Bish targets someone, it can create a shared “enemy” that unites group members. This fosters camaraderie and reinforces group identity. The victim becomes a focal point for group interaction, and members may take turns bullying them to “fit in”  and mask personal responsibility.

6. Lack of Reflection
Bish do not own mirrors.  This would require them to look at themselves and face past behavior.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Kruel on September 05, 2026, 02:09:37 PM
Grown old men crying others won't play the game the way they want, lol. I see nothing has changed since 2015.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 05, 2026, 02:19:54 PM
on another note, i wonder what would happen if you could only take other team bases if you owned 90 percent of your own.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 02:22:29 PM
I don't care how others play the game. Shane. I only pointed out 80 because you said " Knits attacking 80" and it's just one guy.

Complaining about how people play a game isn't what I'm about. I don't care.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 02:46:12 PM
I don't care how others play the game. Shane. I only pointed out 80 because you said " Knits attacking 80" and it's just one guy.

Complaining about how people play a game isn't what I'm about. I don't care.
ok 2 knits attacking 79, 1 attacking 80, same fundamental point remains knits hitting rooks. 

Really.  :rolleyes:

Shoo... this thread isn't for you by your own admission.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 02:52:44 PM
ok 2 knits attacking 79, 1 attacking 80, same fundamental point remains knits hitting rooks. 

Really.  :rolleyes:

Shoo... this thread isn't for you by your own admission.

I honestly didn't know what you were getting at.

Anyway, you said "Knits attacking 80 while Bish attack 79" 

Really didn't even know what you were getting at.


The thread is for me because I get to have my opinion on what you're saying. You want to somehow control how entire countries behave/play  and I do not.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 05, 2026, 02:57:52 PM
Grown old men crying others won't play the game the way they want, lol. I see nothing has changed since 2015.

Why are you here?

Candy Crush not working?
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 03:45:29 PM
I honestly didn't know what you were getting at.

Anyway, you said "Knits attacking 80 while Bish attack 79" 

Really didn't even know what you were getting at.


The thread is for me because I get to have my opinion on what you're saying. You want to somehow control how entire countries behave/play  and I do not.

ethos... do I need to link the definition(s)?

The point I was making was clearly stated in that OP.

"...quality of ethos on display..."

"...let's take a look at one..."

"...common pattern in the mornings..."

"...knits and rooks low numbers..."

"...knits chose to still hit on rooks..."

"ENY cannot fix or impact this because ethos cannot be hardcoded."

"...recall the day when 2 sides would work to stop a reset..."

Just sayin'...

No, I want players to regulate themselves with some sportsmanship.

"And please do not tell me AH is war, because it is not, it is a War game. And games are ment to be fun and fair.
While war is not ment to be either fair or fun."    ~HiTech '04

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Busher on September 05, 2026, 04:01:32 PM
Bish Ethos...

1. Cowardice masked by group action
Many Bish are afraid of confronting someone directly. By acting in a group, they can appear tough and confident while hiding their own fear or insecurity.

2. Anonymity and reduced accountability
In a group, each member can claim they are “just following orders” or that they didn’t personally cause the harm. This anonymity makes it easier for Bish to act without fear of direct consequences, as others may protect them from blame.

3. Social status and control
Some Bish target the less numerous to assert dominance or control over others. In peer groups, excluding or harassing smaller individuals can signal who is “in” and who is “out,” reinforcing the Bish’s position within the group.

4. Power and intimidation through numbers
Bish often act in groups because they believe “there’s strength in numbers” and fear standing up for an even fight. A larger group can overwhelm a smaller target.

5. Unity and bonding
When the Bish targets someone, it can create a shared “enemy” that unites group members. This fosters camaraderie and reinforces group identity. The victim becomes a focal point for group interaction, and members may take turns bullying them to “fit in”  and mask personal responsibility.

6. Lack of Reflection
Bish do not own mirrors.  This would require them to look at themselves and face past behavior.

Sounds like human nature in western society to me.

Two options when you're grossly outnumbered. 1: get lots of pick kills or 2: Log off.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 04:14:09 PM
ethos... do I need to link the definition(s)?

The point I was making was clearly stated in that OP.

"...quality of ethos on display..."

"...let's take a look at one..."

"...common pattern in the mornings..."

"...knits and rooks low numbers..."

"...knits chose to still hit on rooks..."

"ENY cannot fix or impact this because ethos cannot be hardcoded."

"...recall the day when 2 sides would work to stop a reset..."

Just sayin'...

No, I want players to regulate themselves with some sportsmanship.

"And please do not tell me AH is war, because it is not, it is a War game. And games are ment to be fun and fair.
While war is not ment to be either fair or fun."    ~HiTech '04


You were also talking about exploits - so forgive me if I was confused by your wording and for saying that Knits ( one guy) was attacking 80 while Bish attacked 79.

I was just trying to figure our where you were going.



Quote
The quality of ethos on display by long time players is... kind of, well, not unexpected and quite on brand these days.

There's a nice list of exploits and abuses by players - why? I dunno, but let's take a look at one that's not quite either.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: AKIron on September 05, 2026, 04:16:17 PM
Why play a game with people you don't like?
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 04:18:45 PM

You were also talking about exploits - so forgive me if I was confused by your wording and for saying that Knits ( one guy) was attacking 80 while Bish attacked 79.

I was just trying to figure our where you were going.

Double teaming the low side isn't quite an exploit (hiding in buildings) or abuse (such as .rpt) as much as it's.... what words did I use? Oh, right. "...low class."

Now that you're up to speed... ethos...  any opinion on the OP now?
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 05, 2026, 04:27:24 PM
Double teaming the low side isn't quite an exploit (hiding in buildings) or abuse (such as .rpt) as much as it's.... what words did I use? Oh, right. "...low class."

Now that you're up to speed... ethos...  any opinion on the OP now?

Yes.  I don't see it as deliberate double teaming the low side when in your example, Knits were the low side with only 4 players in flight AND owned less of their bases than Rooks.

I see it as 4 players on different sections of the map looking for a fight or something to do. I also see it as needless whining about nothing.


Where was the big hoard? Probably WAY out of the way for the 4 Knits that were on.

Players don't all act as one team.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: JimmyD3 on September 05, 2026, 05:22:57 PM
Well I almost made it not posting on this thread, but alas, Socktigs got laughing so hard I had to respond, funniest post I've ween n months.  :rofl :rofl

socktigs  :rock :salute
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 05, 2026, 05:27:47 PM
Yes.  I don't see it as deliberate double teaming the low side when in your example, Knits were the low side with only 4 players in flight AND owned less of their bases than Rooks.

I see it as 4 players on different sections of the map looking for a fight or something to do. I also see it as needless whining about nothing.


Where was the big hoard? Probably WAY out of the way for the 4 Knits that were on.

Players don't all act as one team.

You're not there in the mornings to have an informed opinion about what is actually happening.  Shall I start posting daily screenshots to prove how cluelessly you're defending that kind of game play?  I don't think any evidence would convince you, tho'
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 05, 2026, 06:45:52 PM
I see it as 4 players on different sections of the map looking for a fight or something to do. I also see it as needless whining about nothing.

Don't underestimate Shame's determination.

He is >< this close to nagging everyone into playing the way he wants.

A couple of thousand more posts and he will be victorious.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 05, 2026, 08:34:25 PM
Don't underestimate Shame's determination.

He is >< this close to nagging everyone into playing the way he wants.

A couple of thousand more posts and he will be victorious.

Which is weird I underestimate your lack of playing the game in 15 years that you have a clue.

Maybe 2000 more post and we all follow your rotten carrot
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Badboy on September 05, 2026, 10:17:28 PM
Interesting discussion

My take on this is that there is a fairly simple explanation for why, when there are two large sides and one much smaller side online, both large sides tend to attack the small one. We also often see that, when the two large sides eventually have to attack each other, very little defence takes place. Both concentrate on attacking undefended or weakly defended bases in a race to meet the victory conditions first, gaining territory quickly at minimum personal cost and risk.

I don't think this requires collusion or secret alliances. It can arise naturally from a combination of game theory, the incentives built into the game and normal human self interest. Different players and sides can independently make perfectly understandable choices which, taken together, produce behaviour that looks coordinated.

This does not mean that every player shares these motivations. Some players simply want to fight, test their personal skill, fly or drive particular vehicles, or enjoy the game in whatever way appeals to them. There are many different reasons why individuals play. I am not suggesting anything about the motives of any particular player. I am looking only at the overall behaviour we repeatedly see in the arena. If that behaviour occurs consistently, it suggests that these incentives are influencing enough players to shape the behaviour of the sides as a whole.

Let me start with an analogy:

Imagine three men adrift in a lifeboat with only enough food and water for two. Two are much larger and stronger than the third. Assume each acts purely in his own best interest and that any pair can overpower the third.

For either large man, the safest partnership is with the other large man. Together they can overpower the much smaller man with relatively little risk of injury. Joining the small man in a fight against someone of his own size would carry a much greater risk. So both large men independently have the same rational preference: each would rather join the other large man against the weakest. The two large men throw the smaller one overboard, after which there is enough food and water for both and neither has any reason to risk fighting the other.

Nobody needs to particularly like the other large man. Their interests simply coincide because the weakest opponent is the least costly one to confront.

Something similar seems to happen in the game.

Suppose the populations are 100, 90 and 30. The 100 side can fight the 90 side, where resistance and losses are likely to be much greater, or attack the 30 side, where territorial gains should be considerably cheaper. The 90 side independently reaches exactly the same conclusion. No agreement or cooperation between them is required. Both simply choose the easier target: the greatest gain at the lowest expected cost.

The victory conditions reinforce this. A side needs 90% of its own country and 20% of both enemy countries, so both large sides need enemy territory anyway. It therefore makes sense for both to take easy territory from the weak side first and postpone the more expensive fight between themselves.

Eventually the two large sides do have to compete directly, but even then we often see both tending to avoid direct confrontation, each continues attacking rather than defending.

I think this is partly because territory itself has little value beyond counting towards victory, whereas being killed has a direct personal cost to players in points, rank, perks and ego. Capturing weakly defended or undefended territory is therefore much more attractive to an individual player than fighting hard to defend territory elsewhere.

Defence is also often particularly expensive. The attacker chooses the time and place and can concentrate his forces beforehand. Attacking aircraft may already have an altitude advantage, tanks may already be established in strong positions and in numbers, and ships may already be shelling defensive positions before sufficient defenders can react.

The first defenders therefore tend to arrive outnumbered and at a considerable disadvantage. They may have to die repeatedly simply to slow the attack while reinforcements arrive. Even then, many of their side's players may prefer to remain on an attack elsewhere rather than abandon a successful offensive to join a costly defence, so adequate reinforcements may never arrive.

That gives players yet another reason to attack rather than defend.

So I think much of this behaviour follows from one simple incentive:


With a large population imbalance, that means both large sides are naturally drawn towards attacking the small side first. Later, when the large sides must compete with each other, the same incentive can turn the war into a race through each other's weakly defended or undefended territory, with victory going to whichever side captures the required percentages first. The fastest path being the path of least resistance.

That may be frustrating for players who prefer frequent direct combat, while other players may enjoy the teamwork, territorial progress or simply winning the war. There are many different motivations among individual players, and I am not claiming that any particular player is consciously making these calculations.

The point is simply that the overall behaviour is clearly visible in the arena. That suggests these incentives influence enough players to shape the behaviour of the sides as a whole. What looks like collusion can therefore emerge naturally from the game's incentive structure interacting with ordinary human self-interest.

At least that's how it looks to me.

Food for thought.

Badboy
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 05, 2026, 11:08:37 PM
Food for thought taken, and agree

However (always a however/but), when it goes to the limits and then harming numbers, that's not a great direction they put the game in.
While a gamer calls it just taking what they can bully, others call it bad sportsmanship and low taste.
When ya take RL logic and mix it with gamer mentality, things kinda go south. Not everyone has a true gamer mentality.

41, 27, 36, that average 5 to 6 out of 7 days is way over the edge.

Most times, they are not fighting much, at one base can be 15 vs 3-5, they are just being drip fed kills and ok with it....and then the defenders tire and leave, and the attackers just continue to milk-run bases.... and that's my point.

When they have 2-3 dar bars full country hordes on each side of the gangers and they put all their eggs in two baskets, one base each,.... that's 4-5 wasted battles that could have promoted fun.

There is no fun at 12 vs 5 almost nightly. So the repeat victims simply log, or group to fight one side and have at least a chance.

In a nut shell, we lose numbers that would have promoted more numbers.
When players aren't having fun too long, they become former players.

More numbers breeds more numbers.
Since it became a rooted habitual, we have not hit critical mass but maybe 1-2 nights per week the last 2 months. You're in trouble.
Critical Mass (about 100-120) is center point, or 0 on a meter.
Below CM - Less numbers breeds less numbers.
Ya need to be well over critical mass, but ya can't there because they are chased to log. Catch 22.

I feel aromatic aroma of spite when ya try to convince them do it not so much.
"You asked us not to, therefore we shall".
"It's hurts numbers/game"
"Ya, but it's funny"

Al-righty then!
Whata ya gonna do with that?
Play non-stop wack-a-mole and depend on settings in an attempt to control human nature?
Or no settings and it just goes into a rapid spiral? (Yes it absolutely will)

It's a science no one seems to have the answer. Obviously HT is trying to find that.

This would all be just funny if we still had 500-750 in the MA, but then it probably wouldn't happen at all, too many battles.

It doesn't hurt me, it hurts the game.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 05, 2026, 11:18:16 PM
The point is simply that the overall behaviour is clearly visible in the arena. That suggests these incentives influence enough players to shape the behaviour of the sides as a whole. What looks like collusion can therefore emerge naturally from the game's incentive structure interacting with ordinary human self-interest.

Exactly.  It's a game-design issue.

No amount of foot stomping or nagging will change anything.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 12:02:38 AM
Badboy has it right.

But
It's a human nature problem in a melee situation. It's not a design error, it is the MMP design and it's been here for 38 years.
AW was not any different.

This is the same exact problem when AW went south below CM. It's not the first time I've seen it, and I know the possible outcome.

It's not meant to be a formal red felt smokers jacket with a pipe and brandy by a fireplace design. It's meant to be Bat S crazy, rock & roll, not a symphony.
A bad game design is one that has very little fights.

Bad game designs don't keep lifers for 27 yrs and rolling like this has.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: captain1ma on September 06, 2026, 07:32:35 AM
at the end of the day its just a game. play it any way you like. i prefer organized and atleast a little courtesy, but at the end of the day. its just a game. have fun and stop taking it so seriously!  :noid  :bolt:
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 08:17:32 AM
Notice who jumped in to feed the negativity.
Someone who is rarely right about anything. But talks the Game God talk as if he is. Yet did a lot of damage here with passive aggressive bashing, skimming and having the ignorant do illegal acts for him. Or have his manipulated puppy boys come in to stir the pot.

For god sakes him and his pups closed a music thread.  Blaming me for locks, seems threads are licked without me in them.

All in a game bbs of a game he hasn’t played in 15 years, but has an opinion on what goes on inside of it.

Dude sells snake oil, the ignorant buy it.

Surprised we didn’t get a dcs video.


Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 08:40:34 AM
at the end of the day its just a game. play it any way you like. i prefer organized and atleast a little courtesy, but at the end of the day. its just a game. have fun and stop taking it so seriously!  :noid  :bolt:

True enough, it’s just a game.
But some choose to play it in ways that doesn’t allow others to play the way they like. That’s where the anger comes from. They prevent the fun of others. Sure they can do that their way. They can also end up shooting empty beer cans because they shove players out.

Kinda like rights, you have rights only until it impedes the rights of others. And thats why HT uses ENY and side balancing. To avoid this exact problem. Others want to be able to play the way they choose too. Because when they can’t they leave. It’s that simple.

When you spend more time in the MA you’ll start to notice irritating patterns.

Take note who is not in this convo like the black plague, the ones who rip fun from ohers. They know we know who they are, they ran out of lame excuses.


Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 06, 2026, 12:33:35 PM
Well part of the game is winning the war. To win the war you have to take bases and take away things players don't like. Lol. I mean that's literally part of the game. You take away the vehicle hangers you can go bomb the strat and take away things that they use to enjoy the game. Lol. If your object is to win the war you start taking everybody's bases. You shoot other people down when they're trying to fly somewhere.  I'm sure they don't like that but that's part of the game. lol

The only thing that I would consider bad is people who are cheating or something. Other than that you play within the limits of the game and nothing you do is going to be something that's wrong or bad.

Everybody likes to do different things. For me, I don't complain about anything people do in the game. If there's a hoard there's a horde. Deal with it.

The only thing wrong with the game are people who expect other people to want to respect a certain ethos in the game regarding base capture or whatever. That's never going to happen.



Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 06, 2026, 01:28:43 PM
The only thing wrong with the game are people who expect other people to want to respect a certain ethos in the game regarding base capture or whatever. That's never going to happen.

Exactly.  Grown adults do not care for other players finger-wagging at them telling them how to play.  Some people around here think someone put them in charge.

The only rules anyone has to follow are from HTC, and the constraints built into the software.  Within that, they can play as they please.  THAT is the entire point of a sandbox.

This game was designed as a 3-sided war.  Any side can attack any other as they please.  It might attack based on maximizing it's victory odds, or it might be settling scores against a side that usually dominates and is temporarily under-populated.

If HT thought that was a problem, he'd have coded it differently.  That is why I said it was a game-design issue, not a game-design problem. 

It is how the game was designed.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 01:32:03 PM
Let me put it in a nut shell.

I’m not going to debate just to debate 1000 ways to say the same thing.

I said what I said, its not going to change

I’d rather jab a pen in my eye.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: JimmyD3 on September 06, 2026, 01:34:26 PM
Well part of the game is winning the war. To win the war you have to take bases and take away things players don't like. Lol. I mean that's literally part of the game. You take away the vehicle hangers you can go bomb the strat and take away things that they use to enjoy the game. Lol. If your object is to win the war you start taking everybody's bases. You shoot other people down when they're trying to fly somewhere.  I'm sure they don't like that but that's part of the game. lol

The only thing that I would consider bad is people who are cheating or something. Other than that you play within the limits of the game and nothing you do is going to be something that's wrong or bad.

Everybody likes to do different things. For me, I don't complain about anything people do in the game. If there's a hoard there's a horde. Deal with it.

The only thing wrong with the game are people who expect other people to want to respect a certain ethos in the game regarding base capture or whatever. That's never going to happen.

Well said gg, that's how I see the game as well. Do I like being vulched, or gang banged, no but it is part of the game.  :rock
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 01:36:48 PM
Well said gg, that's how I see the game as well. Do I like being vulched, or gang banged, no but it is part of the game.  :rock

Sorry bud
Thats a work-around to your squad that does it.
You only enjoy it because it’s on top on the GB

My days are limited here because it blows chunks.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 01:39:57 PM
Exactly.  Grown adults do not care for other players finger-wagging at them telling them how to play.  Some people around here think someone put them in charge.

The only rules anyone has to follow are from HTC, and the constraints built into the software.  Within that, they can play as they please.  THAT is the entire point of a sandbox.

This game was designed as a 3-sided war.  Any side can attack any other as they please.  It might attack based on maximizing it's victory odds, or it might be settling scores against a side that usually dominates and is temporarily under-populated.

If HT thought that was a problem, he'd have coded it differently.  That is why I said it was a game-design issue, not a game-design problem. 

It is how the game was designed.

How dense can you be?

HT IS trying to find a fix with ENY, evidently IT’S A FN ISSUE!

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 06, 2026, 01:43:36 PM


Of course, this wouldn't be a problem with two-sides.

 :rofl
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 01:46:57 PM

Of course, this wouldn't be a problem with two-sides.

 :rofl

Go play your powder puff game and play with your young boys

You matter zero


Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: JimmyD3 on September 06, 2026, 02:16:39 PM

Of course, this wouldn't be a problem with two-sides.

 :rofl

Wrong, it would still be a problem, and  you know that. :rolleyes:
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: hitech on September 06, 2026, 02:21:39 PM
Now that I am updating again the plan is to implement a Max # of fields one country can capture from another.

HiTech
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 06, 2026, 02:25:01 PM
Wrong, it would still be a problem, and  you know that. :rolleyes:

Two against one wouldn't.   :rofl

In any case, if HT changes it then that is the new constraint.  Again, the only constraints are the rules HTC makes and the software constraints HT implements.


At no time should players have to submit to the arbitrary rules other players try and dictate.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 06, 2026, 02:37:15 PM
Now that I am updating again the plan is to implement a Max # of fields one country can capture from another.

HiTech

One thing I was talking about to a couple of squad mates on the radio last night...


And I have no idea what this would require and I'm not suggesting anything. I was just thinking that would really be cool if there was almost an AI kind of system in the game. Built into the game that would explain some of the strategies and some of the nuances. Like things that you have to kind of look up to know you can just kind of ask AI or click on something and it would tell you. One of those will be like base captures

Like without having to look up the percentages and kind of figure out how many bases or what bases or anything like that to take, that would be cool if you could click on something and it would say okay now you need only like two bases of Bishop or one base of rook or whatever. And maybe even suggest which bases to go after. People in our squad know how to do all that anyway and I don't have any clue.

The other thing is like just complicated things that to me are complicated. Like the number of guns that are in a town when you look at the down times. Like I can never remember how many guns are supposed to be down or whatever. That would be kind of cool if you could sort of get like an AI briefing or something about the current state of the war or a base or anything like that.

Or even just general things in the game. Like aircraft performance or anything like that.


I realize that's way out of the scope of anything that you're probably dealing with right now. Just thought it would be cool
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 02:37:44 PM
Wrong, it would still be a problem, and  you know that. :rolleyes:

Jimmy
Trips new book

“How to discourage your own game with intensional horrible advise”.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 06, 2026, 02:41:15 PM
At no time should players have to submit to the arbitrary rules other players try and dictate.

Totally correct. This is why ethos have slipped so far down the sketchy slope - lack of buy-in by those possessing low gaming integrity alongside community inertia by those unwilling, or unable, to change their perspective.

I already said as much in the OP, "...ethos cannot be hardcoded." 

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 06, 2026, 02:42:13 PM
I realize that's way out of the scope of anything that you're probably dealing with right now. Just thought it would be cool

Aces High Copilot.   :rofl

Or even just use AI to scan the code and generate a full manual with all the strat system expained.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 06, 2026, 02:45:22 PM
Aces High Copilot.   :rofl

Or even just use AI to scan the code and generate a full manual with all the strat system expained.

Or maybe... ask others?  That's the whole point of chat. Just about any question can be answered fairly quickly considering how long many have played. 

But...its also eye-opening how many still don't know some basics.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 06, 2026, 02:45:39 PM
If you think about it, an AI type of feedback/strategy suggestion could in effect be used to orchestrate game play overall. Suggesting to people which bases should be defended or attacked. It's not hard limiting things but kind of directing the game flow and possibly bringing countries and people into the common battle points or whatever

And yeah, have it explain all of the features and systems and whatever. A lot of exciting possibilities.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 06, 2026, 02:49:23 PM
If you think about it, an AI type of feedback/strategy suggestion could in effect be used to orchestrate game play overall. Suggesting to people which bases should be defended or attacked. It's not hard limiting things but kind of directing the game flow

And yeah, have it explain all of the features and systems and whatever. A lot of exciting possibilities.

He could setup a local Ollama server (for security and avoiding token costs) and train it on the code and other documents(Maybe some of the experienced players could volunteer as model trainers).
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 02:49:52 PM
Now that I am updating again the plan is to implement a Max # of fields one country can capture from another.

HiTech

Thanks HT.

The man is adjusting the game for the negative effects of dweebery and the self-absorbed.
Enough is enough. It’s out of hand.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 06, 2026, 02:51:03 PM
He could setup a local Ollama server (for security and avoiding token costs) and train it on the code and other documents(Maybe some of the experienced players could volunteer as model trainers).

Or you could be quiet with your failed pompous suggestions
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 06, 2026, 02:59:16 PM
Thanks HT.

The man is adjusting the game for the negative effects of dweebery and the self-absorbed.
Enough is enough. It’s out of hand.

I don't think it's because people are dweebs or self-absorbed that they go after the easy bases and targets. HT is trying to balance the game, but it's not because people are selfishly trying to kill someone else's fun. People will naturally try to take easy bases and they will naturally try to have an advantage over someone else.

It's just a game and people are only playing it to have fun. I personally don't feel like I have to play any certain way for someone else's benefit. I'll happily vulch someone a hundred times if they let me and I'll be laughing and having fun doing it. That rarely happens for me though.

I let myself get vulched in a tank about 16 times in a row the other night. I wasn't mad - I was trying to get out of a camped GV hanger and I had fun trying.

Some people get mad at the way the game goes  - hordes or whatever. It's not some orchestrated thing people do to try to ruin the game. It's just people playing the game.

HT is trying to balance things - but it's not like people are out there trying to ruin the game.






Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Dadtallica on September 06, 2026, 04:29:33 PM
Now that I am updating again the plan is to implement a Max # of fields one country can capture from another.

HiTech

I love AI :banana:

The beta tester line forms behind me! :joystick:
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Mol on September 06, 2026, 05:20:14 PM
Posted in error
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Oldman731 on September 06, 2026, 07:46:53 PM
Now that I am updating again the plan is to implement a Max # of fields one country can capture from another.


Interesting.  So if the Bishops, as a wild example, have captured all that they can capture from the Knights (another example)...then...they would have to fight the Rooks to accomplish anything, or simply defend against a Knight (or Rook) counterattack.

Could be fun, especially for we mercenaries.

- oldman
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Badboy on September 06, 2026, 10:07:58 PM
Some isolated quotes:

Quote
  • But some choose to play it in ways that doesn’t allow others to play the way they like.
  • That’s where the anger comes from.
  • They prevent the fun of others.
  • You have rights only until it impedes the rights of others.
  • Others want to be able to play the way they choose too. Because when they can’t they leave. It’s that simple.
  • When you spend more time in the MA you’ll start to notice irritating patterns.

Those are good points points but those things are hardwired into the game.

That sentiment was expressed very early in the evolution of the game. I'm thinking of Jonathan Baron’s 1999 article “Glory and Shame: Powerful Psychology in Multiplayer Online Games”, which referenced Air Warrior. The article explores how glory and shame work in online gaming, their consequences, and how they influence the culture that develops within a game. It describes something that seems particularly relevant here.

Baron argues that, in competitive online games, “glory is achieved at the price of shaming others.” He specifically discusses multiplayer air combat games where kills are publicly announced, identifying both victor and vanquished. That is exactly what our text buffer does. When you kill someone, everybody sees who killed whom. Your success is therefore not private: your glory is somebody else's publicly recorded defeat. The two go together.

The same principle extends beyond individual kills. To win the war we must take other players' bases, achieve local numerical superiority, destroy their equipment and resources, and generally make it harder for them to fight back. Our success necessarily means players on the other side are losing something.

So, expressed rather bluntly, a large part of the competitive structure of the game amounts to pissing off as many enemy players as possible while preventing them from doing the same to you. You prevent them from playing the way they like, they sometimes get frustrated and angry.

That does not mean players set out with the intention of annoying other people. They are simply trying to win. But winning involves killing enemy players in front of an audience, taking their bases, destroying resources such as hangars and field guns, and using superior numbers, strategy, tactics or teamwork to prevent them achieving their objectives. You prevent them from doing what they want and you do it so everyone can see.

Putting other players on the receiving end of defeat and loss is therefore not an accidental side effect of victory. It is built into the process by which victory is achieved. Whether any particular player actually gets pissed off by it is another matter, but that some will is an almost inevitable consequence of the requirements for victory.

Baron points out that this can have a serious downside. In multiplayer air combat games the levels of glory and shame can become so high, particularly for new players, that many simply don't stay.

That doesn't mean every player is motivated by glory and shame. People play for combat, skill, teamwork, immersion, flying particular aircraft and plenty of other reasons. But the competitive achievement system itself is fundamentally adversarial: success for one player or side is produced by imposing defeat, loss or frustration on another.

Glory and shame therefore have a powerful effect on game dynamics, player relationships and, inevitably, some of the dialogue we see here and on Channel 200.

That raises an interesting design problem: how do you preserve enough glory and competitive consequence to make winning meaningful without allowing the corresponding shame and frustration to drive players away?

Baron does offer some answers, particularly protecting new players and designing games so that different kinds of players can make useful contributions. We already have attempts at balancing mechanisms here: training for newcomers, restrictions on aircraft and vehicle availability for larger sides, and so on. But all of them have costs. Restrictions frustrate players on the larger side. Being overwhelmed by superior numbers frustrate players on the smallest side, particularly when the imbalance happens at regular daily intervals. Training cannot make a new player competitive with an experienced one quickly enough to prevent many from leaving before becoming hooked.

It is a difficult balance because conflict and frustration are not unfortunate things that occasionally intrude into the game. They are consequences of the way competitive success is created. If I shoot you down, capture your base, destroy your equipment or prevent you achieving your objective, I have succeeded precisely because you have failed. Making those successes and failures visible to everybody adds to the glory and shame.

So perhaps saying “the object of the game is to piss off the enemy” is deliberately crude, but there is a serious point behind it. Nobody needs to be trying to upset anybody. We are simply trying to win. It just happens that many of the things we have to do to win are exactly the things most likely to frustrate the people trying to stop us.

Perhaps the real design challenge is not to remove glory and shame, because doing that would remove much of what makes victory and defeat matter. It is to keep them in balance: enough glory to make success rewarding, without so much shame that defeat stops being fun and players decide they would rather play something else.

But some degree of shame, disappointment and frustration is probably unavoidable in a genuinely competitive game. If one player's success necessarily requires another player's failure, those emotions cannot be eliminated entirely without also removing much of what makes the competition meaningful.

So part of the solution may not be trying to design them out of the game, but helping players put defeat in perspective, cope with it, learn from it and come back wanting another go.

That has always worked for me.

Badboy
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: hazmatt on September 07, 2026, 01:37:50 AM
because doing that would remove much of what makes victory and defeat matter. It is to keep them in balance: enough glory to make success rewarding, without so much shame that defeat stops being fun and players decide they would rather play something else.

So part of the solution may not be trying to design them out of the game, but helping players put defeat in perspective, cope with it, learn from it and come back wanting another go.


This makes sense to me and I have seen examples of it in some of the games I play/played. One of the better ones has fighter combat that those with that skill set while at the same time offering opportunities to those who might not have the great air combat skills skills to attack ai or to fly ground attack missions against ai or bomber missions for the most misguided. I really think there's something to having multiple options allowing them to put defeat in perspective.
Good write up.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 07, 2026, 09:04:32 AM
Good writing Badboy. Objective POV.

Seeing how I’ve flown basically 37 yrs with no AI I strictly oppose it.

It has become normalized in other games to fill gaps. But it is not true MMP. My interest would fade. I’m not alone on that.

It won’t solve current problems. IMO.

I think if Icon dar can drive many out AI would be worse. We don’t have a buffer to cover mistakes.

So far, limiting how many bases a country can take looks good on paper, lets see how it actually falls in place.

Baby steps.

I’d like to get past the small beans and see maybe new terrain and town tiles and damage model animations. Yet gave to be careful not to go too far and count some out. We have no buffer for any bad change.

Slipping back into subject
GBs are going to happen. It’s when it’s always against one country nightly it causes great harm. I watch those log-offs. The numbers that log would have put us into CM.

Last night, the table finally flipped on the rook GBers, first thing they did was whine to me they are getting it. I’m a hypocrite <blank stare>. Yea, once or twice a month you get it and you lose your mind, think how pissed you’d be almost every night. Not listening to it. Swallow your own meds.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: nrshida on September 07, 2026, 01:40:03 PM
The present system doesn't address the primary problem which is a huge concentrated imbalance. I never saw 324-36-24 country disposition when the game had a lot of players, and ENY was likely designed but 27-3-2 was quite common for me in Euro-daytimes when I last looked.

Game needs a mechanism to spread out the massively over-populated side such as capping equipment and resources per base in a dynamic calculated manner or some other adaptive mechanism. That's even faithful to real wars - equipment is always finite. Don't think ENY even zone-based or perks would solve it. 3 x ubernoobs in P47D-11s are as much trouble as 1 F4U-4 stick who knows what he's doing. Haven't even addressed radar yet, Lilmak seems to have that issue covered.

Forcing side-switching is never going to work when people fly with friends at the same time of day most days of the week or have learned to who know following certain organised squads let them pick up scraps of 'food'. You can watch the log-out timings to infer that. It's just the nature of most humans to be loyal to an arbitrary group.

If HiTech does go further enriching the ground war with players from other platforms then deepening the strategic possibilities of activities might be a good idea. It's pretty simplistic and abstract presently.

Balance of the different gameplay modes / opportunities is what is lacking not trying to balance numbers of players. If the Bish horde want to endlessly roll bases like Energizer Bunnies every morning in exactly the same way for years then that's their bag (/issue). If I find defending perpetually results in a 5, 7 or even 9-on-1 the hard way, plus a slice of smack-talk for even trying and it's NEVER rewarding - then I'm going to conclude the MA is no longer for me and do other hobbies. Ask me how I know.

It isn't about trying to force others into a certain gameplay which suits you, the issue is creating an environment which allows other gameplay modes to some extent.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Randy1 on September 07, 2026, 02:03:17 PM
I have seen all three countries fight against common sense on different occasions. 
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 07, 2026, 02:20:04 PM
I'll tell you that last night when I was on there were low numbers of course. It was like 2:00 a.m. Pacific time. But the rooks and the bishops had a battle going on in the North East part of the map that I couldn't even get to. I mean part of the problem is the maps. When you can't get to a fight.

It would be cool if they were some dispersed bases in locations around the maps that would assure that anybody could get to a fight if they wanted to. Non-capturable basis.

But people are going to always go for the easy targets. Especially the milk runners that just want to bomb and take over bases at night when no one's on. That's what I wanted to do last night was just to go after some of those guys but I couldn't even get to them. So eventually I did get a pony with drop tanks and headed that way but it's just so ridiculously long to get over there and then you have no radar or anything and then once you get over there you're kind of screwed trying to get back. And it's just not fun.

So I logged off not being able to do anything about what was going on on the map. Not able to engage at all with anybody.


Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Randy1 on September 07, 2026, 02:21:50 PM
Now that I am updating again the plan is to implement a Max # of fields one country can capture from another.

HiTech

I like this Max capture plan.   

Would you consider both max capture per country and a max loss per country.  As an example, no country could capture no more than 25% of one of the other countries, and no one country could lose any more than say 60% of their own bases?    It could be of the two capture methods, the best maybe the max loss per country may offer low player countries the best protection.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 07, 2026, 02:37:16 PM
I like this Max capture plan.   

Would you consider both max capture per country and a max loss per country.  As an example, no country could capture no more than 25% of one of the other countries, and no one country could lose any more than say 60% of their own bases?    It could be of the two capture methods, the best maybe the max loss per country may offer low player countries the best protection.

I'm curious, how would that work?

Would you bomb the crap out of everything and the white flag just won't raise? 
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 07, 2026, 02:49:34 PM
I would guess that when a threshold was reached that the bases icons would somehow change to something that resembled an uncapturable base.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 07, 2026, 03:06:43 PM
I would guess that when a threshold was reached that the bases icons would somehow change to something that resembled an uncapturable base.

That would be a good idea, but if someone bombed it anyway, is everything invulnerable but just no white flag?  (I don't expect you to know, just thinking it thru.)

If they leveled everything before it was available, would the flag instantly go up as soon as it was?  Or would the building reconstitute and they start over?

I guess in the grudge case, they could still keep the weaker side leveled and unable to fly from the front line, even if they couldn't capture.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 07, 2026, 03:10:39 PM
Yeah I don't know. Just guessing, but I would think that you should be able to still bomb the crap out of those bases but just not capture them. So the motivation would be to not really do that like why would somebody continue to do that just out of spite or something? I think that when people are trying to roll a map all they're trying to do is really quickly capture a base.

I guess we will see.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CptTrips on September 07, 2026, 03:15:13 PM
Yeah I don't know. Just guessing, but I would think that you should be able to still bomb the crap out of those bases but just not capture them. So the motivation would be to not really do that like why would somebody continue to do that just out of spite or something? I think that when people are trying to roll a map all they're trying to do is really quickly capture a base.

I guess we will see.

Yeah.  Though even if you can't capture, it doesn't hurt to keep them flattened and not a threat.  Like "Mowing the Lawn" strategy.   
Especially if it generates glorious "HATE" as Dok used to say.  :devil 

Bottomline, is if sides are allowed to get grossly out of whack, everything else you do seems like a bandaide on an arterial wound.

I expect there will be new emergent gameplay tactics.

Hope it works.  Being GB sucks.  Unless you're in Vegas with the Swedish Swimsuit Team.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 07, 2026, 04:07:00 PM
maybe a revolt function would be cool to force some fights. just spitballing.


something like if you take an enemies base, but you haven't deployed from it in x time, then it starts to go white flag on its own and you have to up something to reverse the process.
you could pretty much force all three sides to have to be fighting the other two fronts all the time.

not sure if it would be an improvement but I'm toasted and its an idea.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: The Fugitive on September 07, 2026, 04:11:44 PM
I dont mind "spit ballin'" but so far it all sounds like forcing players to play the game a way they dont want to.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: toasted on September 07, 2026, 05:05:48 PM
yea, really ideal situation would be to find a way to incentivize desirable behavior without necessarily penalizing others.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Dadtallica on September 07, 2026, 05:34:43 PM
Countries used to work together to stop a horde or a reset. Let’s do that again.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: -gg- on September 07, 2026, 05:50:59 PM
yea, really ideal situation would be to find a way to incentivize desirable behavior without necessarily penalizing others.

Yep.

Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: CAV on September 07, 2026, 07:12:05 PM
How about....

Keep the sandbox open,  Let each side make their own Tactical decisions but...

If side A wants to push side B, they can do so But each additional base requires more troops.
1 base - 10
2 base - 20
3 base - 30
etc, etc

Oh... And other than the  first base...put a time limit on how long they have to do so.... even if the town is still down.

Till they capture a base from side C and then it resets back to 10 for side b and then it starts again.

CAV
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Animl-AW on September 07, 2026, 09:53:47 PM
Why play a game with people you don't like?

You don't have to worry about that since there are not many fights outside AI in your game
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Dadtallica on September 08, 2026, 01:13:31 AM
Even AI cannot code everything for curbing human behavior… yet.
Title: Re: player ethos in the bucket
Post by: Shane on September 08, 2026, 08:08:17 AM
Now that I am updating again the plan is to implement a Max # of fields one country can capture from another.

HiTech

nvm, read data wrong. 

But I do hope something gets done along these lines.