Aces High Bulletin Board
General Forums => Aces High General Discussion => Topic started by: Animl-AW on October 28, 2026, 08:58:10 PM
-
Watched this twice in 10 seconds. A T-34 (name withheld) shot down 2 planes, a 51 and D9 with one shot each. That's crazy.
The odds of a T-34 tank hitting an aircraft with its main gun were very low, especially if the aircraft was moving and flying at low altitude. It was possible, though, and a lucky hit could bring an aircraft down. 2 times in 10 seconds?
The T-34's main gun was designed to fight tanks, not aircraft. Depending on the version, it carried a 76.2 mm gun (T-34-76) or an 85 mm gun (T-34-85)
For a rough, illustrative estimate, a single shot at a moving aircraft in the very low single-digit percentages or below, depending heavily on the circumstances.
Just sayin
-
Its called practice. Some of these guys in these t34's fire more rounds than whole brigades ever did.
-
Its called practice. Some of these guys in these t34's fire more rounds than whole brigades ever did.
I'm not saying it's anything, I am saying it's near impossible and some do it over and over,.... I'll leave it right there. You'd be lucky to do that once in a lifetime if you practiced every min of the day for years. The odds are against any protective support.
-
I'm not saying it's anything, I am saying it's near impossible and some do it over and over,.... I'll leave it right there. You'd be lucky to do that once in a lifetime if you practiced every min of the day for years. The odds are against any protective support.
Your confusion real life with a game. Heck you could park a t34 in off line and I'll bet in an hour or two of shooting at the "predictable" path of the drones circling the field even you would start getting hits.
-
Your confusion real life with a game. Heck you could park a t34 in off line and I'll bet in an hour or two of shooting at the "predictable" path of the drones circling the field even you would start getting hits.
Ya I get it, as stated in RL. Predictable is different than random target course.
-
I’ve both done this back in the early days when I tanked a lot more than I do now and I’ve also been incredibly upset by people doing it to me.
It’s just muscle memory. Real life aside.
-
I guess there's something to be said about a gamer having 10,000 times more practice than real life.
However, that's like duck hunting with a .22 cal. I could see a set of buffs as the target is much bigger, the odds increase.
To be able to repeat it in seconds, better yet 100s of times, is way outside the scope of reality. It makes the imagination spin, it will surely grab your attention, as it should.
-
I guess there's something to be said about a gamer having 10,000 times more practice than real life.
However, that's like duck hunting with a .22 cal. I could see a set of buffs as the target is much bigger, the odds increase.
To be able to repeat it in seconds, better yet 100s of times, is way outside the scope of reality. It makes the imagination spin, it will surely grab your attention, as it should.
Kind of like "on the wing shooting" with Archery. Just takes practice. I have hit planes with an 88mm. Not puffy, actually hitting with the shell itself. I even watched a guy get 2 planes with a Shore Battery back-to-back. :eek: I have been main gunned a few times, 3 or 4? Most folk get killed by HE into the ground or nearby trees. Fixable with proper dive and recovery angles. They get a lot of practice, so it isn't all that improbable. Just another episode of "Well that happened!" and move along.
-
imporrible
Impossibly-Horrible, I like it :aok
-
The question are they using HE or AP? AP kills of aircraft are the stuff of legend.
-
Most folk get killed by HE into the ground or nearby trees.
I am a victim of this a LOT. Many times I fly about 500-600 meters off the ground to blow up when I near the tank.
My question is. In theory, that HE shell has to have an explosion above tree top and I have never seen any war footage or knowledge of a HE shell having a blast radius that even comes close to that. Maybe, possibly a Flak 88 can come close?
-
Add a 1 sec delay while firing a main gun of a tank from the unbuttoned commanders position. The other solution is don’t fly in a predictable path.
-
I heard a discussion once where they mentioned using hvap to shoot planes since it was supposedly fastest an flattest shooting. I've never seen the HE thing as most planes aren't that low to the ground.
-
There are 2 ways to "main gun" a plane.
1. Pure ballistics, if the round hits the plane it dies. That could be any type of round, HE/AP/HVAP
2. Aircraft is killed by the blast zone of an HE round, much like the effects of an 88 round exploding adjacent to an aircraft.
-
If the plane is diving straight down upon you and you can point your gun at it, it’s not that difficult to hit it in the nose with a little practice.
I’ve also definitely been hit by the Shell underneath me, but I fly on the deck quite a bit.
-
Is part of the issue the way we can just joystick the gun to a precise aimpoint way easier than they could move the gun IRL? How common were automated controls vs hand cranks and similar? It seems to me like we might have way way more precise and easy aiming controls than IRL.
I've always thought from the commander's view the main gun muzzle shouldn't be exactly centered in the circle, it should be somewhere randomized within the circle. That would prevent accurate gunnery from the commander's position. People don't main gun planes as often from the gunner position do they?
And in game, it's really not that hard. As little time as I've spent in GVs and 88s etc, I have hit a few planes with a direct hit. Never went looking for it with HE even.
Wiley.
-
Add a 1 sec delay while firing a main gun of a tank from the unbuttoned commanders position.
Better solution would be to remove Commander Ability to Fire the gun. No tank produced during World War II had the ability for the commander to even fire the main gun.
The other Oddity about AH ground vehicles isThe commander's ability to have a super zoom Ability to spot targets At far ranges. In actuality they were lucky to have a pair of binoculars.
In controlled ballistic environments, the T-34’s guns were technically precise. Proving ground data for the 76.2mm T-34 gun showed a 50% chance of hitting the target at 1,000 meters.
In combat a Soviet T-34 tank engaging an enemy vehicle at ranges longer than 1,000 meters had an incredibly low first-round hit probability, generally estimated to be well under 10% to 20% in combat conditions.
Why??? theT-34s suffered from low-grade optical glass that was often described as dull or blurry, featuring a very narrow field of view. This made spotting targets and accurately estimating range past 500–800 meters immensely difficult for gunners.
T-34 was a legend in WW2, The USSR produced 54,550 T-34s during the war, the most produced tank of the war. But the tank also holds another record that few people ever talk about. Approximately 44,900 T-34s were lost to enemy action during the war 82% of total production.
But as people like to point out Aceshigh is a game not a Combat simulation...
Looks like we got the legend of the T-34, Not so much the reality.
-
The very first round fired by a tank at an airplane about 1.5k tracking shot killed it.I was just board so figured what the hell I see if he sees my tracers. Was me testing against pyro flying.
HiTech
-
Better solution would be to remove Commander Ability to Fire the gun. No tank produced during World War II had the ability for the commander to even fire the main gun.
The other Oddity about AH ground vehicles isThe commander's ability to have a super zoom Ability to spot targets At far ranges. In actuality they were lucky to have a pair of binoculars.
In controlled ballistic environments, the T-34’s guns were technically precise. Proving ground data for the 76.2mm T-34 gun showed a 50% chance of hitting the target at 1,000 meters.
In combat a Soviet T-34 tank engaging an enemy vehicle at ranges longer than 1,000 meters had an incredibly low first-round hit probability, generally estimated to be well under 10% to 20% in combat conditions.
Why??? theT-34s suffered from low-grade optical glass that was often described as dull or blurry, featuring a very narrow field of view. This made spotting targets and accurately estimating range past 500–800 meters immensely difficult for gunners.
T-34 was a legend in WW2, The USSR produced 54,550 T-34s during the war, the most produced tank of the war. But the tank also holds another record that few people ever talk about. Approximately 44,900 T-34s were lost to enemy action during the war 82% of total production.
But as people like to point out Aceshigh is a game not a Combat simulation...
Looks like we got the legend of the T-34, Not so much the reality.
Interesting concept
-
Better solution would be to remove Commander Ability to Fire the gun. No tank produced during World War II had the ability for the commander to even fire the main gun.
No pilot in wwii history was ever killed more then once.
HiTech
-
No pilot in wwii history was ever killed more then once.
HiTech
HA!
-
The very first round fired by a tank at an airplane about 1.5k tracking shot killed it.I was just board so figured what the hell I see if he sees my tracers. Was me testing against pyro flying.
HiTech
<cough> used the word “tracking” <cough>
Point being RL vs Game, the game side tends to be an immersion breaker followed by that unproductive 5 character “C” word, because in sim world it should.
-
Better solution would be to remove Commander Ability to Fire the gun. No tank produced during World War II had the ability for the commander to even fire the main gun.
<snip>
I think pretty much all of them did. The commander said "FIRE!" and the gunner fired right?
-
I think pretty much all of them did. The commander said "FIRE!" and the gunner fired right?
HT just removed the middle man! Efficiency!
-
No pilot in wwii history was ever killed more then once.
HiTech
How many were killed by a tanks main gun..
Eagler
-
I think pretty much all of them did. The commander said "FIRE!" and the gunner fired right?
Only after the Gunner identified the target.
No World War II tank gave the commander a direct, independent control stick or yoke to physically move and lay (aim) the main gun. In standard WWII tank doctrine, the commander laid out rough directions, targets, and range estimates verbally or via intercom/hand signals to the gunner.
How many were killed by a tanks main gun..
2... maybe?
The evidence is from personal memoirs, not formal battlefield confirmation, formal wartime verification remains elusive.
German Panzer Ace Otto Carius in his book "Tigers in the Mud".
and
Soviet Red Army Captain Dmitriy Loza in his historical memoir "Commanding the Red Army's Sherman tanks".
-
So if some of them weren’t there or were killed in action and it was just the one guy, did he not know what to do? I’m pretty sure he could’ve fired the stupid gun.
This has become a really silly argument now.
-
On a somewhat unrelated topic but kind of related.........
Why don't we have multiplayer tank Crews in AcesHigh? Similar to the way our competition does in other Games/Sims?
Or is that a bridge too far?
-
Its called practice. Some of these guys in these t34's fire more rounds than whole brigades ever did.
It’s callled shooting from commander’s hatch with a red dot on the screen. Remove commander shooting and the game will get waaaaay more true to “nature’
-
Most of the really good GVers can do this. Ive been the victim of it many times. In the air and HE into the ground in front of me if im on the deck. So much so, that when im around tanks, im always zooming in to see where their gun is pointed. Very gamey, but well within the possibility of some of the better guys in here to do with how the current game is setup. I dont think its anything nefarious.
-
Approximately 44,900 T-34s were lost to enemy action during the war 82% of total production.
That's an interesting stat I did not know!
-
On a somewhat unrelated topic but kind of related.........
Why don't we have multiplayer tank Crews in AcesHigh? Similar to the way our competition does in other Games/Sims?
Or is that a bridge too far?
We used to, then I choose to model the tank as a system instead of each station. Usage went up 3 fold after the change.
HiTech
-
So if some of them weren’t there or were killed in action and it was just the one guy, did he not know what to do? I’m pretty sure he could’ve fired the stupid gun.
This has become a really silly argument now.
Sure he likely could, but unless his limbs and neck were REALLY abnormally long and flexible, I am skeptical he could do it with his head stuck out the hatch on the turret.
Wiley.
-
I'm sure Bratt Pitt could do it ... :banana: :banana: :banana:
Eagler
-
I'm sure Bratt Pitt could do it ... :banana: :banana: :banana:
Eagler
This guy could...
https://youtube.com/shorts/_8JgC92WSe4?si=xUukbxMGlPyu4bQE (https://youtube.com/shorts/_8JgC92WSe4?si=xUukbxMGlPyu4bQE)
-
Chuck Norris could with both hands tied behind his back...
-
Sure he likely could, but unless his limbs and neck were REALLY abnormally long and flexible, I am skeptical he could do it with his head stuck out the hatch on the turret.
Wiley.
Or could we just assume you have AI teammate just like when you’re shooting in your bomber guns that are down there doing the stuff anyway???
Are we really gonna die on this hill?
-
Or could we just assume you have AI teammate just like when you’re shooting in your bomber guns that are down there doing the stuff anyway???
Are we really gonna die on this hill?
Good point. A case could likely be made for bomber gunnery being a bit too good too.
When it creates an outcome that is V A S T L Y at odds with reality, I don't think considering ways to limit it is out of line at all.
Are you saying the gunner and driver could move the tank from the commander's instructions instantly with enough precision for accurate gunnery? I am a bit skeptical.
I just think most of the issue could be solved by the gun not being precisely aimable from the commander position.
Wiley.
-
Got it. Have the commander's position work off voice commands to turn and elevate the gun and tell the driver what to do. :joystick:
Wiley.
-
Changing from Commander to gun position to gunners takes about 3-4 seconds if the gunners seat are already empty in most tanks. The gunner sit between commanders legs below.
In the west, you start as a loader, then proceed to be a driver, then gunner, and finally, Commander - then Platoon Commander of 3-5 tanks depending on army. To be a company commander you to need to be commissioned.
The commander can do all others work, the gunner can do loading and driving etc. Commanders took the highest casualties because normally you had the hatch open to get a 360 view.
-
Good point. A case could likely be made for bomber gunnery being a bit too good too.
When it creates an outcome that is V A S T L Y at odds with reality, I don't think considering ways to limit it is out of line at all.
Are you saying the gunner and driver could move the tank from the commander's instructions instantly with enough precision for accurate gunnery? I am a bit skeptical.
I just think most of the issue could be solved by the gun not being precisely aimable from the commander position.
Wiley.
I’m mostly saying you’re putting way too much thought into it and just pretend you have people in the tank doing stuff!
-
Main gunner guy here. You can go ahead and do away with main gunning aircraft the same day you do away with triple plane bomber formations carpet bombing your own town or base to kill enemy GVs in it/on it, and doing no damage to the structures. Or the same day you do away with A-20's releasing regular non-parachute bombs any lower than their designed bombing altitude of 8500 feet.
-
Main gunner guy here. You can go ahead and do away with main gunning aircraft the same day you do away with triple plane bomber formations carpet bombing your own town or base to kill enemy GVs in it/on it, and doing no damage to the structures. Or the same day you do away with A-20's releasing regular non-parachute bombs any lower than their designed bombing altitude of 8500 feet.
What you're talking about is selective realism, and it always drives me nuts. Somebody picks one item in the game and says it's not realistic, while ignoring all the other decisions we make because we're dealing with a PC, a joystick that isn't anything like the real thing, a flat screen, and one person instead of a crew.
A few examples:
- A real stick moves when you trim. Ours can't, because they are spring-loaded to return to center.
- A real airplane takes a good 30 minutes to preflight before you're ready to take off. Ours are ready in 5 seconds.
- Real people die once in their lives. We die 1,000 times an hour.
- Real pilots didn't get five-kill sorties five times in a row. For some of our players that isn't unusual at all.
- Real tanks had a crew of four, with several sets of eyes watching what was going on. We have two eyes on a flat screen.
- Real bombers had multiple gunners looking every which way. We have two eyes looking at a flat screen.
There are a bunch of choices we make that have nothing to do with modeling a single position accurately. It's all about an accurate representation of the entire system.
HiTech
-
The main thing that will make any sim unrealistic and accusations flying like comets;
In RL you would never ever get this amount of practice of any one item, better yet many.
The "Annie Oakley" effect of using a .22 cal rifle in target tricks like splitting a playing card takes us out of the realm of any "norm". No matter the opinion, the brain grabs on to it, sometimes distracted by it.
The human brain is incredibly good at detecting skill in games, especially when someone performs something so precise, fast, or unexpected that it almost feels impossible.
Your brain is constantly predicting what will happen next. What's interesting is that your brain doesn't just recognize the action itself. It recognizes the difference between what it expects a human to be capable of and what it just witnessed. This happens through a process called predictive processing. When someone performs an incredible skill, your brain notices that the result doesn't match its prediction.
Your brain is constantly learning what is normal. When it encounters something that breaks those expectations, it detects an anomaly.
This is closely related to prediction error: your brain expected one outcome, but something very different happened. An anomaly doesn't necessarily mean something is impossible. It means something is sufficiently unusual that your existing understanding struggles to explain it.
In the 90s I worked with David Copperfield. I helped test the trick props. I did a 7 show run with him, so it was almost daily. What my brain had to grasp was, the theatrical lead-up is actually seeding the viewer's brain and setting it up on what it should expect. Your eyes will not be where they should be. Those tricks were so easily done it shocked me that anyone was fooled. But when I watched the show, after spending hours setting up special lav microphone systems, testing lights for shadows in the right places, sight-lines...etc. then seeing it operate it was convincing, even though I knew how it was done.
Point being. The practice level of skill is a mental distraction within itself....in any game. It would not happen like that in RL without 10,000 hours of practice. So the repetitive gaming environment creates anomalies.
I can see a nose-on approach of an AC to a tank is a smaller but steady predictable target. I thought about well the way it's setup it pulls us into that extra edge, but then,... would we need a 3-4 player crew to run the tank if that was separated? I think any game would allow you to bounce around.
But wait there's more,... The human body can suffer serious internal injuries if bounced around like some fly.
All that said; B-17 "Death Stars", loaded with 6-8 players were epic fun.
-
What you're talking about is selective realism, and it always drives me nuts. Somebody picks one item in the game and says it's not realistic, while ignoring all the other decisions we make because we're dealing with a PC, a joystick that isn't anything like the real thing, a flat screen, and one person instead of a crew.
A few examples:
- A real stick moves when you trim. Ours can't, because they are spring-loaded to return to center.
- A real airplane takes a good 30 minutes to preflight before you're ready to take off. Ours are ready in 5 seconds.
- Real people die once in their lives. We die 1,000 times an hour.
- Real pilots didn't get five-kill sorties five times in a row. For some of our players that isn't unusual at all.
- Real tanks had a crew of four, with several sets of eyes watching what was going on. We have two eyes on a flat screen.
- Real bombers had multiple gunners looking every which way. We have two eyes looking at a flat screen.
There are a bunch of choices we make that have nothing to do with modeling a single position accurately. It's all about an accurate representation of the entire system.
HiTech
This is John Wick style, am I back… Oh yeah I’m back! :airplane:
-
Watched this twice in 10 seconds. A T-34 (name withheld) shot down 2 planes, a 51 and D9 with one shot each. That's crazy.
Was it brando? If so he LIVES in the t-34, rarely would you see him in anything else. He also misses heaps.
-
Was it brando? If so he LIVES in the t-34, rarely would you see him in anything else. He also misses heaps.
Na, bit of the same of the cheater claimers tribe. Several do it