Toad, in the post you made (and asked for my opinion) that had the "agree" "disagree" stuff, I agreed and disagreed with all the things you agreed and disagreed with.
But it seemed obvious to me. For eg.:
"But before you fight and win, by force or otherwise, you have to realize that you are in a war"
or
"Above all, never surrender to terror."
Sure, fine...
It seems to me your questions would produce more interesting answers if you began to explore who we are at war with and why. THEN apply those things and see if they're getting done the way your author proposes.