Originally posted by Drano
I think what you're saying is they're one and the same and I'm trying to throw a little clarity on the subject as they're certainly not.
No I'm not. I am saying that they are both E fighting tactics.
Don't look now but your descrition of what you call BnZ is actually a good example of energy fighting. Its a horrible example of BnZ tho.
In a BnZ attack the object is to not bleed your E state in any way shape or form. The defender or defenders E states are irrelevant so long as they lack the ability to outzoom you. You're not going to actively engage anyone in particular for longer than it takes to get a guns solution on them as doing that presents a possible danger to you and that's right out. A BnZ attack is made always against lower preferrably otherwise occupied NME. A BnZ attack is the preferred method if the attacker is also outnumbered by same. BnZ attack is as follows: go in hot--fast, hit hard taking any shots that present themselves--don't force shots (it bleeds E), and get out fast using that great speed to zoom back up to a position of safety. Make only shallow low-G turns or rolls on the pass if any at all. Repeat as necessary or until higher bad guys come along to break up your party.
Drano
Actually, in a BnZ attack, the most common maneuvers used is either the Cuban 8 or the Half Cuban. In both of these BnZ maneuvers, you do lose your energy in the climb but you regain it in the dive.
The defenders E state is relative because if they have sufficient energy, they can force the attacker into the defensive quite quickly.
You ever hear of the phrase "tap dancing on their heads"? That refers to the part when in the BnZ pass, you make the other plane break turn, which then in turns bleeds his energy off. Then either on the next pass, you can elect to dance on his head again or if he's sufficiently slow enough that he presents you a shot. Then you use your superior E state to extend beyond gun range, zoom up and repeat.
In any case, the way I outlined it above or even what you said, BnZ is just another among few different Energy Fighting tactics. And if you want to split hairs, there are also different variations of BnZ. But that still doesn't change the fact it is and will always be just a tactic.
ack-ack