Originally posted by Karnak:
Er..., in my experience the Bf109G-10 is the best plane in AH at this time. If HTC adds the Fw190D-9 or Spitfire Mk F.XIV that might change, but as it is the G-10 has so much speed and such a climb rate that it allows even a poor pilot like me to hold my own. Whenever I try the supposed easy rides that people are accused of cheating for using, e.g. Spitfire Mk IX, N1K2, Fw190A-5 or P-51D, I get slaughtered (I have had some success in the Fw190A-5 and N1K2, but nothing compared to the Bf109G-10).
Because of my personal experience with the Bf109G-10 I just can't take any of the whines by the LW fans seriously. I my opinion they have the best fighter in the game and they still aren't satisfied.
Sisu
-Karnak
Disagree Karnak. 109G10 has the weaker weapons set in AH excluding C202.30mm not considered here as a weapon of choice for a newbie. (Yak9 has more punch as its guns are better). It has the weakest elevator response in AH, it has abysmal control over 400mph IAS, it has the worse torque effects apart those of the typhoon, and rolls like a pregnant whale.If you damage an elevator or aileron of this plane it wont be no longer an effective fighter as its response would be unexistant...(a roll to the right at low speed is simply impossible without rudder assistance if you have only one aileron).
Not to forguet the little cockpit. Seems good but you cant move inside it.
THe reasons you give for it being the best plane in AH are: speed climbrate and acceleration. You say that with those only you cant be touched. And I must agree with you. If you dont want to fight, the 109G10 will make you untouchable. But happens that most of us want to engage, not only rtb alive. Once engaged in a close combat the 109G10 is easy meat if you play your cards well and the G10 stays fighting (wich, again, most of LW nuts we do).
The G10 simply CANT bounce a con, as compression makes the bounce impossible. Simply CANT engage a buff unless it has a 30mm on board (but a newbie cant fire a 30mm), and is outturned by everything but a Fw190A8.It has the worse range of Any plane in AH...
You can play the "survival" game very well in it, but if you want to engage cons you are in deep trouble. I dont give a ratz's bellybutton about people with 50 K/D in P51 or G10 as I know they stay high and out of touch unless they see a hopelessy alone plane with less E than him.
Sorry,for me the P51D is a way better arena plane than G10. And by much. H2H I admit that 109G10 does hold its own if flown properly, but ask Hangtime how did he felt on a G10 after the duel with hristo.
THe P51 can do fast dive bounces, and pull away, the P51 can win some angles if needed with the wise use of combat flaps, and its speed allows it to chose the terms of engagement...
And P51 acceleration is near that of G10 in a 0G dive. Few people notice it but the dive qualities of the P51 are simply awesome, because its low drag and good hispeed handling.
And I wont say anything about range, as we all know about it.
so for me the P51 is, hands down, best arena plane than G10.
Fw190D9 will be a very good plane for AH planeset, but I still think that P51 has the advantage over it. P51 will have better turning (with flaps) than D9, will be faster, and will have more firepower. Only advantages of D9 will be climbrate (and not by much),rollrate and acceleration. For me the P51D will be better, but the gap will be narrowed with the 190.
And dont tell me the 190A5 is better plane than P51. A5 cant dictate the terms of an engagement while P51 can. 190A5 cant disengage a combat when in inferiority while P51 can. A5 manouvers better than P51, but so does too Spitfire IX and it isnt better than P51D.
About SpitXIV I'll break for once my own compromise of not messing with it again...
You first say that 109G10 is the best plane here and then you say that you want a G10 with more and better weapons (2 hispanos and 2 50 cals), with better climbrate at some altitudes,better cockpit visibility, and with the maneouverability and turnrate of the Spitfire IX?.
All planes in AH have advantages and Drawbacks. Spitfire XIV wont have any serious drawback. Its a perk plane.
Sorry if you dont like it, but I feel it that way.
[This message has been edited by RAM (edited 08-14-2000).]