Top-down show for IJN carrier has the best water. The closer shots look like bad 3d you might find in an amateur student project.
Yes water is hard, but that looks like a fogged plate glass that was tinted blue, and is WAY too reflective. You notice it's almost flawless? It's perfectly reflective, too? They need to go back to the drawing boardon that. From alt it looks good, from lower it looks crap.