Knowing that laptop components don't quite reach the performance level of their similarly labeled desktop counterparts, and knowing that the GPU is the most critical part in modern games I'd vote for the 4070 model. The 4070 version is also about a quarter of an inch thicker which hopefully means better cooling. And if you play AH on the monitor the 16:10 ratio gives you 120 pixels more visibility up and down, making following vertical maneuvers that tiny bit easier.
That said, although both rank quite high the critical reviews should be taken seriously. At least you should keep a keen eye on similar symptoms as long as the computer is still under warranty. Then again, the lemons could be made on Mondays.