Everytime a build comes up there gets to be jabs at people because of their choice of parts (particularly CPU), so let's settle it best we can. It's pretty well understood Intel outperforms AMD in the performance area. I've heard that ATI is beating Nvidia in the current generation of GPUs, and since this is a forum for AHII we'll use that as a comparison (unless someone specifically states another game they want to play).
Leaving the fanboi-ism out of anything in here it would be nice to compare AMD vs Intel and NVidia vs ATI. I use $ for $ since I don't know of anyone (personally) that buys a GPU for way more than it can do (like 3grand for a 580).
For comparisons in both areas assume 1680x1050 in AHII. Aside from the difference in what's being compared the systems are of equal performance for this test. Same RAM, CPU/GPU (where applicable), PSU, HDD, and so on.In the $ for $ performance area who wins? -CPUs
I personally feel AMD wins (personal opinion, so looking for real stats) but I know more calculates into it than the CPU, chipset is a big problem but we'll assume the chipsets are good-as-it-gets for this.
Using everyday tasks and AHII as a comparison who would perform better in the $100, $200, $300 areas (no comparing a $101 CPU to a $199, keep it fair)?
Would the difference in AMD vs Intel be noticeable to an average user?
And as a guide, why does AMD or Intel perform better?
In the $ for $ performance area who wins? -GPUs
I have heard ATI is currently kicking NVidia because Fermi was rushed, is it still true?
Who performs better in the $200, $300, $400 marks (same restriction as CPU)?
Which maker runs cooler, less power, quieter (a must for some) in the respective prices?
What settings would likely be obtainable to those GPUs to sustain ~60FR (if possible since I know we don't have 1 of every card here)?
As a little side thing, what would be the minimum price to run AHII maxed at ~60FR? 500? 600? 900? 1500?
I run everything maxed (except shadows at 2-4K) at ~60FR for ~$635 so I'm curious how much more it would take to max it that little bit more. It would also help to get a baseline of what to expect if someone wants to run the game maxed.
~$635 includes running:
Case- Aerocool M40 $80
Motherboard- Biostar A785GE $55
CPU- AMD Phenom II X2 555 $90
RAM- Transcend DDR2-800Mhz 2x1GB $45
GPU- EVGA GTX 260 $185
PSU- OCZ StealthX 700Watt $85
HDD- 320GB WD $65 (was bought at Officemax so I cut the price for average prices in NE)
DVD- ASUS DVD RW $30With all the knowledgeable people in here I'm sure we can get a decent non-argument based response to help other people who are considering building a system.
![salute :salute](http://bbs.hitechcreations.com/smf/Smileys/default/salute.gif)