I've also used both the TM Flight Hotas X and the T16000M and despite trying to be light handed the twist on both made less funny noises right from the start. Most likely that was due to the excitement in a fight causing me to cross the limits. Back in the day I was told about WW2 pilots trying AH and their stick handling could be compared to a jeweler's work. Hand on heart, how many of you almost never hit the extents of the moving range of any axis?
That said, there's a guy in our squad who to my knowledge has been happy with his 16000 for years without issues, no other controllers. It's not that he doesn't know about anything better, once he told that already before AH he had all bells and whistles and also a pilot's license but for occasional gaming in various places like a holiday cottage or a con he likes to travel light with only the stick and laptop, lending an external monitor at the location for convenience. Truly light handed, he is.