I think the best example if settings not goin over as well us when I redesigned the damage model in AW. No one tasked me to do it, I just found a weak point and went after it.
AW was nit originally surface strikes, 3D was not that advanced in the beginning. It was a Hit Bubble, and to get different results was a randomizer for end results. Ss long as you hit that invisible bubble you got some damage or kill.
It took me weeks and endless testing to change that to a much more realistic model. The Full Realism guys who I’ll refer to as simmers, and AW staff loved it and decided we had to use it. So to further test the reaction of the masses we put in in both Relaxed Realism who I refer to as gamers and in FR arenas. It was a little harder to get kills, because now you got proper damage over just straight kills. I got “thata boy” “ awesome”
It went over real well in FR, it was a must have to them. RR loved it too, for about a week or less. And then RR rebelled, because they had to be more precise to get a kill. Then they revolted. We took it out of RR and just left it in FR and/or scenarios.
Point being, a great change got rejected by the bigger RR crowd. They didn’t love more reality, go figure.
Point being, it all looked good on paper. Sometimes what they said they wanted wasn’t what they wanted after tasting it. All that barking was for nawt by the RR/Gamer tribes.
While I think these are great ideas that COULD have positive results, I’m also onboard with HT in try adapting first. There are infinite ways to play this sim, only a few are tapped into. Once you make a setting change, no matter how much they ask for it, it has possibilities of not turning out as planned. If that happens the biosphere gets ill. After several failed settings, one will tend to stay in the safe zone. After the population loss several years ago, you’re not quick to make changes. Try to adapt first, prove adapting failed.
There are a few here who can backup my story.
I don’t know everything, I don’t have all the answers, I’m not going to change the world, just speaking strictly from my own experiences.