Yes she picked the good looking guy.
Assuming that she was really there to meet a guy that she would have a serious relationship with, I could not believe how stupid she was.
The trader had made millions at a time in life when many don't even own a car. He was modest and never once mentioned his job or wealth when all the guys on the show were trying to impress her with thiers.
He won her attention through his personality so she knew he was a genuine nice guy before she found out.
All the other guy had going for him was his looks. He had a hard time communicating with her and their dates were awkward.
Yet she picked the model type.
It just goes to show how superficial some good looking women are. I don't think you could have written a more complete human than Adam in the show. He seemed slow but obviously by his accomplishments he was not at all.
The nice thing about the show is that she had to choose. I am sure in real life she would have strung Adam along while seriously pursuing the model guy.