Originally posted by Rude
I think the only distinction between your point of view and mine is this.....you fear the loss of your civil rights....I'm willing to give some up knowing they can be recovered when and if the day comes when it would be appropriate.
I cannot think of one circumstance where yours truly would be of interest to a goverment bent on securing our country or an instance where I would be involved in any activity which would bring them down to my neck of the woods to put me in the pokey and deny me anything related to my constituional rights as an American citizen.
I can't recall the exact quote, but isn't it something like "The price of liberty is eternal vigilance"?
From my point of view, the overall concern is that the price to be paid in terms of limitations on civil rights may, in the end, be too high. Frankly, once rights are eroded they are generally never reinstated....that's just the way government works.
I don't buy into the argument that one has nothing to be afraid of in terms of these limitations if one isn't doing anything wrong. These things are too easily abused.
I'm all for sealed search warrants, keeping certain information classified from the public at large, even "secret trials" which are conducted in accordance with recognized procedures and safeguards. But at some point, those limitations and special rules cross the line and undermine the very principles upon which the United States was founded and which it has defended and promoted for the last 200+ years.
There is a famous tale told by a priest (I think) who survived the Holocaust. When someone asked him why he didn't object when the Gestapo rounded up the Jews, he replied that it was not his problem because he wasn't Jewish. When the Gypsies were rounded up, same answer. And same answer for everyone else who was shipped off to the death camps. And then he mentions that when the Gestapo showed up to arrest him, there was no one left to speak up. It may be the stuff of legend, but it does a good job of showing why some people object so much to these issues.
In most cases, they are not "liberals" or "Bush haters" or "terrorists" or "terrorist sympathizers" or "communists" or "traitors", nor do they wish to see America attacked and lives lost....they are Americans.