Its not odd, there's literally thousands of historical paint schemes to choose from. In AH there will be a limit of 15 paint schemes per plane. These should be high quality and historical. I personally don't want to see a bunch of goof ball skins or lesser quality non-historical skins fill one of those 15 slots. Pyro didn’t say the skin had to be exactly 100% historical but he did say the skin has to be something that they would have released themselves.
Now there are problems with some of the templates, this is known. The g6 being my favorite plane in AH I was disappointed that the tulip nose is "fixed" permanently. It’s not entirely clear that flaws in the templates will disqualify a skin. However, an artist who strives for perfection these flaws are a “major issue”.