Whew! After reading these 2 pages of posts I'm exusted.
A little history. I started Air Combat sims last year is CFS2 which I liked but hated all the cheating online with all the moded planes. I got a copy of CFS3 (from a friend with every intention of paying for it) and absolutly HATED it.
So I said, let me try AH. I dl's AH in May and started practicing. Wasn't paying attention so when I thought I was ready to go online I see that I need AHII to play online.
Installed AHII, had to update my video driver. Now works fine.
I'm in my 2 weeks and have played in the MA for the last 4 days. Here are my observations. (remember my AH was all offline practice)
1. I really like the new flight models. I thought the rudder in AH was weak. I almost never had to use the rudder unless I wanted to swing my nose side to side. The new model is more close to my CFS2 experience. I realise I have pedals and some may not. I still need to tweek my stick some more. Trimming is still a skill I need work on. I tried combat trim but it seems to get in the way more than help. It is helpfull for a quick trim-up but on full time just tend to irratate me more than anything.
2. Gunnery seems fine to me. It seemed to me that the guns in AH were a bit to strong, especially the 50cals. Again, not much experience to go by.
3. Balance? Seems the times I was in the MA there were far more friendlies than nmy. That could be attributed to my not knowing how to find a good fight. One thing I didn't want to do was dive in on a 8 on 3 and look like a kill stealer. When I did get into an engagement I died pretty quickly, which is to be expected being new and all.
4. Fun? Yeah, I had fun. Haven't killed anything yet but my rear end is full of bullet holes. Yeah, I had lots of fun.

Anyways, this is a bit of a scary thread for a new guy coming into the game. I always seem to come into things when they are in a downward spiral. I hope this isn't the case because I really like this game and so far am happy with AHII. I really tried to do my homework before going online so I wouldn't appear as such a dweeb though I do need more practice in AHII.
So far I'm pretty sure I'm going to stick it out and subscribe. In fact I'm positive I will.

So if some folks are leaving because of the changes, I think others like me will come in who don't have the prejudices that flying AH I might have instilled in them.
Now I just need some folks to fly with so I don't feel like such a lone wolf out there.
ClifRa