Mr. Toad,
your utopian view of Britain without private cars is interesting! And make no mistake, I shall toy with the ideas you have suggested.
However, it won't work in practice. I limited impact version of the carless utopia was tried by the current government - twice. Both times it failed.
In 2000, the fuel tax accelerator (a tax by which the cost of road fuel was increased by 6% above the rate of inflation) triggered the fuel tax revolt. (read about it
here) In this revolt, drivers basically said they'd had enough. And Tony Blair was forced to listen - something he normally only does every once every 4 years. The accelerator tax was abandoned!
The following year, Labour again tried to establish its vision of motoring Utopia - pretty much like the scenario you described yourself! Did you know that in 2001, not one single inch of new road was built in Britain - the smallest amount of new road building since 1880, and the invention of tarmacadam?
And the result? Mayhem. Traffic jams, outraged motorists. You see we NEED mobility. I might be working in Maidenhead one year, and Croydon the next. I could not relocate on the basis of a 6 month contract. Commuting was the only way to go. I suppose I could have walked the 60 miles to my Croydon office, but I think it might have been closed by the time I got there.
However - guns - sure we needed guns in the days of highwaymen, some of whom targeted areas not so far from where I am now. Gentlemen travelling on the long distance coaches were advised to carry their sidearms!
But last time I drove down the A4, I didn't see any guys on horseback with a silk scarf covering their faces, brandishing a flintlock.
By 1911, when firearms legislation was first considered, only the criminal classes needed guns for their chosen occupation. For this reason, legislation to remove firearms from circulation "sailed through parliament". Remember, said legislation was passed by a
democratically elected government, which was
reelected two years later. Even the opposition party did not try to reverse this legislation when finally elected in 1924.
We had our gun years, but recognised when they was over. The US, however, still harks back to the days of guys wearing raccoons on their heads and standing on the threshold of their property with a rifle.
