Originally posted by Animal:
Miko,
Correct me if I'm wrong, but you believe it would have been better if the space race had never taken place?
Depends on your point of view. It was great and almost bloodless (for americans) way to bankrupt communists - more humane then bombing each other.
But the technology would have advanced no matter what and every passing year the same feat would have been much cheaper - same as the Columbus expedition.
Remember - they did not even have decent computers then and the flight was actually controlled by analog computers because digital ones were too slow.
Few years later many of the experiments could have been modelled on the computer instead of flying into space... Or sending computers into space to perform automated experiments. Of course those times certain computing principles were considered anti-communist in russia with severe concequences to their proponents - same as genetics or botanics...
For pure technological/scientific outcome the same money could have brought bigger return.
Columbus was financed by private funds of spanish kings, US program was financed by US congress democratically elected. US ended WWII richer and more powerfull then it was before it.
Russian space program was financed by the communist clique while their countrymen lived in squalor and died from hunger and sickness.
Don't get me wrong - we would have been in space no matter what - that is inevitable with technological progress.
Those days I can go to the store and by myself a decent airplane for my four month salary, no big deal, or a yacht that would have better chance to make it across the ocean then Columbus ships did. If US had a program to perform a non-stop round-the world aircraft flight in 1910, it would have cost billions and many lives. When such flight actually happened, barely anyone noticed.
Americans had connertial use of satellites for many years. Russian can launch other people's satellites into orbit but cannot make decent ones.
The results of progress is what people can use, not a feather in the hat of a power-mad politician.
miko