Of course the situation described is possible, even plausible. What fools you is, some of the newest sticks in the game will fly P-51's as jabo rides trying to learn to fly fighters, and some of the most experienced sticks in the game will fly them just to surprise you. Plus there are guys who have been almost exclusively flying the Pony for years. Some of the best fights I've been in have been Pony vs Pony. This AH2 FM allows it to do some incredible reversals, and getting into a rolling scissors in such a fight is a measure of "how low can you go" in alt, speed, flaps, etc. There are definitely planes more forgiving than the Pony, but few better all around performers.
it is not all about turning circles and stereotypes.
ManeTMP showed me the way when he slaughtered my spit5 in a P47d40 back almost 18 months ago now.
all he did was made himself look juicy, then attacked when i was certain of victory.
You fight him often, you will learn thats almost a signature move for him. ManeTMP is like a master fisherman, and he knows his bait. He also knows how to hook you and reel you in. He may not be the best stick in the game, but he's damn good. That and he flies a P-47 like most people fly a Spit.
