Originally posted by Maverick:
Miko,
.... As long, of course, he / she is a good politician. That factor mitigates ALL the killing in their own and other countries as well.
Mav
Mav, read your post again and then read mine again.
It is not a good style to put words in other people mouth they never said and then argue with them.
You said that Saddam Hussein was an idiot and I stated that he is very smart.
Neither term has anything to do with moral values of a person. There are many well-meaning idiots and there are quite a few evil geniuses. Of course you may be confused by the TV where all "evil geniuses" are actually idiots but that is not the case in real life.
"Smart" or "genius" means that a person has high congitive ability (ability to process information). "Idiot" means that a person has low cognitive ability.
Besides that there are such valuable human capabilities as dearing, decisivness, bravery, charisma, wisdom, education, realistic perseption of reality. Each of those may be posessed by evil as well as good persons.
According to what I know of S. Hussein and A. Hitler careers they are/were very capable persons. I am sure that their I.Q. are very high.
The fact that they engaged in murders genocide only indicates that they were evil people, not that they were stupid.
Of course if you read A. Hitler's memoirs you may get an impression that he thought he was acting in the best interests of humanity and civilization, as he saw them. So he may arguably be called misguded rather then evil. The real idiots in this story are people who confuse evil genius with stupidity. You would think I mean you but actually I am talking about some of my ancestors who could read "Mein Kamph" for twelve years before Hitler even started genocide and underestimated him and did not get out in time. And politicians who allowed WWII to happen for exactly the same reasons.
When we get to the moral judgements, I think that my statement
"Thinking that just because someone is an enemy or evil he is automatically stupid is a big mistake." clearly indicates that I consider Hussein evil and our enemy.
Nowhere did I indicate that S. Hussein was a "good" politician or that any of his actions were "wonderfull additions to the world" (as we perceive it). I just said he was a brilliant politician.
Life would have been much nicer if all the evil guys were stupid and all the good guys were smart. That is mostly true when it comes to violent crime in US - a smart person is much less likely to commit one, but not in international politics.
miko
[This message has been edited by miko2d (edited 01-11-2001).]