Yah, Pluck, upon reflection I feel this is going to be the problem with AvA.
In just about any matchup, one side has turners and one side has B&Z planes. Thus the style of fighting is pretty much dictated by the plane set in use.
As we see here, the LW's advantage is in B&Z; it's natural that they're going to use that advantage. The Allied advantage is in turnfighting. They are going to attempt to capitalize on that.
Same in the Pac, mostly. the IJN/A turns, the US mostly B&Z's.
These are generalizations but it's mostly true.
Properly fought though, a B&Z plane dictates the fight. As long as it stays fast and executes properly, they're mostly untouchable unless and until someone comes in above them.
So, while I enjoyed playing last night, I fear the limitations produced by B&Z may be a problem.
While it's probably anathema to the devotees, it might be better to enable a full RPS on both sides. I think it would make for better fights.
Just my .02, based on the idea that I think B&Z side vs Turner Side will get old pretty quick. I could be wrong.