Looking at the discussion thread about the choices, I can figure out the last 4(with the odds that these will make it to the final four). They will be; G-55 (2:1), A-26 (5:2), P-39 (3:2), B-25 (5:1).
First round will see eliminated the 410, 111, Brewster( Sorry Finns, I wanted this one too, HAAKKA PAALE!!! ), Pe-2 or Tu-2(they don't tell you wich. That ambiguity will hurt this choice, and added to this it is a bomber. Bombers have usually got the short end of the stick when it comes to "Fighter" Sims.).
Next round will eliminate the Yak-3, and the Japanese "Mystery" Fighter(again the abiguity of wich they will model will eliminate it from contention, besides there are a couple of "dogs" in that choice.[Ki-44, and Ki-45])
Next up on the chopping block the B-25. (Sorry guys, a light perk bomber is going to win out here.)
Beyond that, my guess would have the A-26, out the next round. Bombers are low man on the totem pole in this community, and fighters will generaly get more votes than bombers. The only reson it will get this high in the vote is because of the large American voting block.
My prediction for the Final selection P-39. Edging out the G-55s firepower with the dominating American voting block/home court advantage.