Author Topic: Gun crazy Swiss  (Read 6850 times)

Offline MrRiplEy[H]

  • Persona Non Grata
  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 11633
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #15 on: June 10, 2007, 12:23:57 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by lazs2
ferndale..  that pic was taken during the shootfest?   160,000 people participating and you never seen a gun?   you asked if they owned em?

The info is incorrect?   they don't have full auto rifles and carbines at home?

That beetle guy used to post dumb stuff like that.. pictures of his travels in a planet warming jet..  resteraunt guides.. that sort of thing.

lazs


They have them AT home in locked containers. The gun is most likely government property and for military use only. They're not gun nutters -> nobody carries in normal life. Just like down here.
Definiteness of purpose is the starting point of all achievement. –W. Clement Stone

Offline AKIron

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 12072
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #16 on: June 10, 2007, 12:44:02 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by MrRiplEy[H]
They have them AT home in locked containers. The gun is most likely government property and for military use only. They're not gun nutters -> nobody carries in normal life. Just like down here.


Not so on the military use only government property thing according to this article, it sounds like they practice with them regularly and even keep them when their service is done if desired (conversion from full auto to semi required.)

http://www.nationalreview.com/kopel/kopel103001.shtml
Here we put salt on Margaritas, not sidewalks.

Offline AKIron

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 12072
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #17 on: June 10, 2007, 02:16:59 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by Ferndale
I read AKIron's article. ^ Yes Switzerland does have a low crime rate, but I don't think it's because of an armed populace. There are other factors which have a bearing. Here are some that spring to mind.
  • No poverty. Sure, not everyone is of equal wealth, but no-one lives below the poverty line.
  • Ethnic mixing - probably much less than in some other countries. No racial/ethnic tensions.
  • Low unemployment
  • No social underclass
  • High rate of adult literacy
I also did not see hordes of kids arsing about on the streets in the evenings - now that I could ascribe to the compulsory military service!
 The picture was taken in the middle of last month, before the "shootfest". I was in the area bounded by Basel, Zurich, Sankt Gallen and Schaffhausen - the far north of the country near the German and Austrian borders. I was outdoors most of the time, and never heard a single gunshot. [/B]


Won't argue that the factors you cite contribute to low crime rates and yet the Swiss remain very heavily armed by European standards. I guess you might attribute that to them seeing themselves an island in a sea wherein crime (European wars) may visit their door at any hour.
Here we put salt on Margaritas, not sidewalks.

Offline tedrbr

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1813
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #18 on: June 10, 2007, 02:54:07 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by AKIron
Won't argue that the factors you cite contribute to low crime rates and yet the Swiss remain very heavily armed by European standards. I guess you might attribute that to them seeing themselves an island in a sea wherein crime (European wars) may visit their door at any hour.


In years past perhaps, but I figure the Swiss retaining their large armed militia and compulsory service has more to do with their social and national identity these days than any threat, real or percieved.  It part of what makes them Swiss (along with their international banking), similar to how America relates to it's "Wild West" period.

Offline AKIron

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 12072
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #19 on: June 10, 2007, 04:24:34 PM »
I have no doubt that there are those in Switzerland who would like to see the Swiss disarmed. Some because they believe (foolishly imo) a civilized society doesn't need firearms and some for reasons more sinister. However, one can only speculate about their prevailing national attitude towards guns.

A disarmed society is ripe for the pickin' both from within and without. Those who believe the days are long past  of harvesters like Hitler are burying their heads in the sand.
Here we put salt on Margaritas, not sidewalks.

Offline AKIron

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 12072
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #20 on: June 10, 2007, 04:33:57 PM »
I gotta ask something. Who here believes that a society which bans private gun ownership, discourages childhood military/war play, tolerates but ridicules their own weak military, will have the resolve to stand up and fight when needed? I think you're out of touch with reality.
Here we put salt on Margaritas, not sidewalks.

Offline Viking

  • Personal Non Grata
  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2867
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #21 on: June 10, 2007, 05:51:50 PM »
I gotta ask something. Which European society has banned private gun ownership? Who is out of touch with reality?

Offline AKIron

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 12072
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #22 on: June 10, 2007, 06:05:21 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by Viking
I gotta ask something. Which European society has banned private gun ownership? Who is out of touch with reality?



European societies aren't the only ones that may have to defend themselves against enemies foreign and domestic but since you asked, both England and Germany immediately come to mind as being so restrictive on gun ownership as to have effectively banned them. Of course others (non European) like Australia and Japan aren't even pretending to allow this liberty.
Here we put salt on Margaritas, not sidewalks.

Offline Gh0stFT

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1736
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #23 on: June 10, 2007, 06:16:28 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by AKIron
I have no doubt that there are those in Switzerland who would like to see the Swiss disarmed. Some because they believe (foolishly imo) a civilized society doesn't need firearms and some for reasons more sinister.


It all depends on history & culture of a country. There is not one rule what works for
all countrys. What works in switzerland may not work in germany or
elswhere.

I live 100m close to the swiss border on teh german side,
i can tell you, swiss people are different in so many things! ;)
The statement below is true.
The statement above is false.

Offline Viking

  • Personal Non Grata
  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2867
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #24 on: June 10, 2007, 06:45:30 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by AKIron
European societies aren't the only ones that may have to defend themselves against enemies foreign and domestic but since you asked, both England and Germany immediately come to mind as being so restrictive on gun ownership as to have effectively banned them. Of course others (non European) like Australia and Japan aren't even pretending to allow this liberty.


Yes the Australians aren't allowed to have guns:






In Japan also:



- Yoko Minamoto, Japan's premier female sports rifleman.

Owning shotguns and hunting rifles is legal in Japan.


I won't even comment on England and Germany, your claim is just too … out of touch with reality.

Offline Viking

  • Personal Non Grata
  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2867
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #25 on: June 10, 2007, 06:57:15 PM »
Japanese gun regulations explained by a Japanese gun owner:


"There are many people who believe that Japanese shooters at Olympics
are policemen or soldiers of Self-Defense Force.   Some other people believe
that Japanese citizen cannot own guns and people who enjoy shooting have to
rent guns at shooting range, and some other people believes that legal
gun owners must keep guns in lockers assigned for them at shooting ranges.
So, I decided to write short introductory article about gun ownership in Japan.

In Japan, the kind of guns owned by civilian are as follows.

   Air Rifle
   Hand Rifle
   Rifle
   Air Pistol (limited to 500 people for sports shooting only)
   Pistol (limited to 50 people for sport shooting only)
   Shot gun

The purpose to own guns is limited to two, i.e., hunting or sports shooting.
It means we cannot own guns for defense purpose.
The procedure to own the gun is as follows.
Of course, people who use guns in their work (policemen, soldiers, etc.)
don't have to follow the following step for guns used in the job.
The terminology about 'air gun', 'air rifle' follow Japanese custom.


   Participation in a lecture at nearby police station
  ------------------------------------------------------

   This is a requisite condition for anyone who tries to own gun.
   You go to the police station which is responsible for your address area, and
   apply for the lecture on gun regulation for beginners.   In case of Tokyo,
   entire districts are divided into four blocks, and the actual place to have
   the lecture is one police station in the block.
   The lecture for beginner is held once in a month, I think.

   The lecture starts at 9:00 in Saturday morning, and written examination
   follows after lunch.   To 20 questions, you have to give at least 14
   correct answers.   When I had this lecture, two or three people did not
   pass among 32 or 33 attendance.   This performance was high because usually
   80 % of attendants pass the examination.   After passing the examination,
   a certificate is given and its copy must be submitted whenever you do some
   application afterwards.   The certificate is valid three years.   It means,
   after the valid date of the certification, you have to attend a lecture
   for gun owners to get the new certificate.   This time, no examination is
   done.


   Air rifle, hand rifle, and shot gun
  -------------------------------------

   Once you get the certificate of the gun regulation lecture, there are two
   different paths depending on what you want to own.   Note that you cannot
   apply for usual rifles nor pistols at this stage.   To own them, you need
   further qualification.

   A. Air rifle or hand rifle.

      People who are not familiar with gun confuses air rifle from
      'air soft gun' (or simply 'air gun') which uses plastic bullet and
      whose barrel does not have rifling.
      In fact, recently it was reported on TV that some members of AUM camped
      near by Mt. Fuji and did some military training using 'air rifle' of
      AK 47.   This report was not correct.   What they used must be air soft
      gun shaped like AK 47 or model gun of AK 47.

      Hand rifle is unique to Japan.   It is actually air pistol, but long
      sleeve covers the barrel, and long stock is attached to the grip.
      In Japan, ownership of pistol (air or not) is restricted because of
      their small size which enables covered transportation.   Therefore,
      hand rifle was introduced for people who plan to own air hand gun
      eventually.

      If you want to own air rifle or hand rifle, you can go to a gun shop
      with certificate to show to clerks, determine which gun to buy, ask
      clerks to write a paper which describe the detail of the gun, and name of
      the shop.   When you buy a gun not from a shop but from a current owner,
      the same paper is needed.

      You must be at least 18 years old, or, you need to be over 14
      years old and have recommendatory letter from an organization which
      governs all official sports organizations.

   B. Shot gun.

      Prior to go to gun shop, you have to take practical shooting course,
      followed by examination.    To apply for it, you have to submit a lot
      of papers to the police, and it takes a few months until you get the
      approval because you and your family who live together are examined.

      After the approval, you have the course at a shooting range and pass
      it (it is quite easy).   Then, you go to a gun shop, determine the gun
      to buy, and ask clerks to write the paper.

      You need to be at least 20 years old.

   After applying for any gun, usually it takes about one month until you get
   permission.   When you get notification from the police about permission,
   you go to the police station to receive license booklet, take it to the
   gun shop and receive the gun.   Then within two weeks, you have to go to
   the police station again with the gun to have it inspected and stumped on
   the license.


   SB - Small Bore rifle (0.22 caliber, rim-fire)
  ------------------------------------------------

   Since using of 0.22 caliber rifle (both rim-fire and center-fire) for
   hunting is prohibited in Japan (probably small animals suitable as targets
   of 0.22 caliber live not far from where people live), the only permitted
   purpose to own it is for rifle shooting sports.   The step to own Small Bore
   (rim-fire) rifle is as follows.

   A. Become a member of a branch of National Rifle Association of
      Japan, then become a member of N.R.A.J. itself.
      I my case, I became a member of Setagaya (one district in Tokyo) area
      at first, which means automatic membership of Tokyo branch of N.R.A.J,
      then had to wait one year until I was allowed become a member of N.R.A.J
      it self.   But this term differs with branches.
      If you want to just enjoy air rifle, and have no interest in participating
      in national wide shooting meet, to stay just as Tokyo branch's member
      saves membership fee.

   B. Participate in a few hour's lecture by N.R.A.J., and get certification.

   C. Participate in at least two shooting meet per year before you apply for
      SB.

   D. Get certification of skill of shooting.
      In case of shooting in Standing position, the score of criteria is
      300 for S60, and 200 for S40.   It is quite easy.

   E. By satisfying above A,B,C,D, then you can apply for SB to N.R.A.J.
      What you get if you pass the examination is recommendatory letter that
      you are suitable for shooter of N.R.A.J., and have potential to become
      a shooter for higher level competitions like Olympic.

   F. Submit above letter as well as many other papers to the police station.
      Like the case of shot gun, it takes a new months until the police
      issues a permission to take shooting course in practice.

   G. Take a practical shooting course at a shooting range, and get a
      certification.

   H. Apply for a gun to buy.


   LB - Large Bore rifles (center-fire)
  --------------------------------------

   There are two purposes you can use LB, one is sports shooting under
   control of N.R.A.J., and the other is hunting.

   A. For rifle shooting as sports, the requisite to apply for it are
      as follows.

      a. It is over one year since you have owned a SB.

      b. You have already participated in 2 shooting meet per year with SB.

      You apply for recommendatory letter to N.R.A.J., and follow the similar
      steps (without practice course in a shooting range) as SB.
      It looks only bolt action rifles can be allowed.

   B. For hunting purpose, you must have continuous 10 years' history to
      have own shot gun or SB.   You simply apply for a gun to the police
      station.


   Air pistol
  ------------

   The requisite condition to apply for air pistol is almost the same
   as SB except that certification of more skill in shooting is
   required (in case of AR S60, score of over 510).

   Since the number of owners of air pistol is limited up to 500,
   you usually wait one year or more (it means you wait someone
   fails to update the license) until you get recommendatory letter.

   After getting recommendatory letter from N.R.A.J, follow the same
   procedure as other kinds of guns to apply for the license.


   Pistol
  --------

   To apply for pistol, you need quite excellent skill of air pistol
   (in case of AP60, score of over 555) to apply for pistol.

   This time, the number of people is limited to 50, but because of
   so hard criteria, I heard two years ago that only 30 people owned it.


   Permission for ammunition
  ---------------------------

   Anybody can buy bullets for air rifle, hand rifle, and air pistol without
   restraint.   For ammunition which contains powder, you have to get
   another paper from the police.
   On the permission paper, based on which kind of guns you have, the kind
   of ammunition gun shops can sell to the owner of guns are listed as well
   as total maximum amount.   This paper is valid for one year, and, if my
   memory is correct, the maximum number of ammunition the police allow to
   a paper is 4,000.
   Because of the law, the maximum number of ammunition you can keep
   at home is limited to 800, and you must keep them in a specially designed
   locker which is different from gun locker."

Offline Viking

  • Personal Non Grata
  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2867
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #26 on: June 10, 2007, 06:57:55 PM »
"Updating the license
  ----------------------

   The license of gun is a booklet like passport.
   Your name, photograph, address, birth date, license booklet No. and its
   issue date, etc. are in the first page.
   Then pages for up to 12 guns follow (so, if you own more than 12 guns,
   you have several license booklets).
   In the last page, there is a holder to insert the permission paper to buy
   ammunition.

   The license for each gun is valid three years (more correctly, until
   the third birthday after you get the license).
   It means, if you have three guns which you owned in three continuous years,
   you have to update the license of different gun every year.   If you have
   three guns owned in the same year or owned in interval of multiple of three
   years, you can update them in the same year.   Here, 'year' means not
   calendar year, but a interval between two birthdays of the owner, i.e.,
   if you buy two guns, one a day before the birthday and the other one day
   after the birth day, their licenses are updated in the different years.
 
   To keep the license, following things must be cleared.

   A. Requisite to update license.

      There's no condition to update the license of air rifle, hand rifle,
      and shot gun.   But if you have not used them in the past three years,
      license can not be updated.

      To update the license of SB and LB, you have to show stump you got
      at rifle shooting meets.   Though one of conditions that N.R.A.J.
      issues recommendatory letter for SB and LB is that owner should
      participates at least two formal shooting meets per year for EACH gun,
      in realty, it is not checked by the police strictly.

      To update license of air-pistol or pistol, it is strictly examined
      whether you participated in enough number of shooting meets, and score
      at them were enough to qualify the ownership.

   B. Annual gun inspection.

      Usually in spring, there's a day of annual gun inspection (the date
      differs with police stations).   You bring not only all guns but also
      a paper to report the number of times you used gun (for practice,
      shooting meet, hunting) as well as the number of bullets you consumed.

   C. Certification of a lecture which is valid at the time of update.

      To update of the license, valid certificate of gun regulation lecture is
      necessary.   It means you have to attend the lecture every three years.

     
   Others
  --------

   A. There are many kinds of papers which you submit to the police at
      various opportunities.   The following is a list of them (not all of
      them are needed every time).

      o Application for ownership
      o Application for license update
      o Application to buy ammunition
      o Paper to return expired paper to buy ammunition
      o Signed paper that gun shop or ex-owner agrees to sell a gun to you,
        which contains detailed description of the gun
      o List of your family who live with you
      o Abstract of your family register
      o Past 10 years' record of your address, job, crime, and guns
        you ever own
      o Doctor's certification that you are not a user of drugs, and
        satisfies some other physical conditions.
      o Certification of gun lecture (for beginners, or for owners)
      o Certification of practice course at a shooting range

   B. If you have some crime history, using knife or guns, you cannot
      apply for gun ownership for some amount of years.
      Also, if you live with dangerous people, like member of Yakuza,
      it may happen application is rejected.

   C. In Japan, most policemen are transferred every several years to avoid
      their adhesion with residents.   In case of a policeman who is
      in charge of handling gun ownership, he is transferred every two years.

   D. Because only one policeman works for gun ownership in each police
      station, I experienced several times that he was absent for criminal
      investigation.   What I do when I have some business about gun ownership
      is to call him in the morning to check his convenient time, then
      go to the police station.   So, it is often necessary to take
      annual leave of a day or half just to submit papers.
      I hope some reformation about this inconvenience.

   E. The most popular accident caused by legal gun owner is to shoot the
      colleague mistakenly at hunting.
      In total, 10 to 20 accidents on legally owned guns happen every year.
      N.R.A.J is proud of its record of no accident at shooting meets.

   F. The number of owners of shot gun and air rifle are, if my memory is
      correct, around 35,000 respectively, whereas owners of rifles are 1/10
      of them.

   G. Guns must be kept in your house in a specially designed locker.
      One exception is pistol (not air pistol) which must be kept in a locker
      of the nearby police station.

      You must keep key of the locker in a secret place (your family should not
      know it), and even if policemen comes to your home for inspection,
      only owner should show guns.
      He can reject to show guns if policemen come without prior notification.
      It is to avoid an incident that guns are stolen by 'false police'.

   H. To do hunting, you need another license for it.
      Issuing of hunting license is under control of Governor of each
      prefecture.
      The first course for beginners is followed by written examination
      follows like that for gun ownership.   License is valid for 3 years.

   I. When you apply for a gun, you specify its purpose (target shooting, or
      hunting).   You cannot use a gun for hunting if its purpose in the
      gun's license is "target shooting"."

Offline AKIron

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 12072
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #27 on: June 10, 2007, 06:59:12 PM »
Private gun ownership is not legal in Japan except as noted here: http://yarchive.net/gun/politics/japan_gun.html

How can i take you seriously if you're going to claim the Japanese are allowed to own guns?

Australia is almost as bad and Australians are not allowed by law to defend themselves with any type of firearm.

England and Germany are almost as bad and I bet if I took the time I could some other European countries that are as restrictive.

Sheep to the slaughter.
Here we put salt on Margaritas, not sidewalks.

Offline Viking

  • Personal Non Grata
  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2867
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #28 on: June 10, 2007, 07:05:04 PM »
Are not shotguns and rifles guns?

Offline AKIron

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 12072
Gun crazy Swiss
« Reply #29 on: June 10, 2007, 07:09:29 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by Viking
Are not shotguns and rifles guns?


Look at the restrictions on them and the effort required to obtain. I haven't looked up stats on ownership in either Japan or Australia but I'd bet they are both extremely low due to the effective ban.
Here we put salt on Margaritas, not sidewalks.