Originally posted by lazs2
phoo.. catalytic converters may or may not have become standard equipment unless mandated.
Come on. You know they wouldn't. There is zero reason to include them, and they are an added cost.
Originally posted by lazs2
Now they are saying that the converters may be causing problems of their own. computer controled ignition and fuel injection would have happened no matter what and they are the biggest reason cars run cleaner.
I certainly agree that computers have been a huge help and would have happened anyway. But you still need a cat (or other smog devices). Even with a perfect computer that has zero CO and HC, you are still gonna get NOx. And again, it is absolutely certain that no one would want these devices if they weren't regulated in.
Originally posted by lazs2
I am an individualist... like a less wimpy libertarian... The govenment needs to exist to protect the individuals rights. Before it regulates anything to protect people it needs to be damn sure there is a problem and a solution that does not destroy individuals right to life liberty and the pursuit of happiness.
I agree, but that last part is the kicker, isn't it. There are times when one person's freedom has to be restrained a little to allow for another person's life, liberty, and happiness. For example we need a law against murder. I think you would agree that we shouldn't allow the freedom to kill anyone whenever we want to, despite the fact that this is unquestionably an abrogation of individual freedom. The point is that this is not some stark philosophical difference between right and left. It is a difference of opinion as to what kind of governement regulation we should have and where it should be appled. We all have our opinions and none of them are holier than the other. You would advocate government interference in some cases too.
Originally posted by lazs2
The early smog laws were bad regulation... they simply were laws with no ability to comply at the time unless everyone was willing to drive 4 cyl cars.. our modern V8's put out less smog than 70's jap crapboxes...
Yeah, I agree. Like when they mandated lower compression, thus increasing knocking because of reduced squish and requiring timing to be pushed back further, and thereby causing even worse gas mileage despite the lower power output. What a crappy time that was. Look, I'm not gonna defend that ****. The governement is obviously not always right and often makes stupid decisions. All I'm saying is that there are a few situations where we want the government to step in to solve a prisoner's dilemma that we as a society have deemed worthy of solution. They need to be thought about carefully before we get the govt involved, but we can't just stick our fingers in our ears and pretend they don't exist.
Actually the US postal service is a good example of this, in a way. But this post is long enough.