Sorry if I am repeating someone earlier, I am too lazy today to read all 3 pages.
Perfect situation charts such as you are talking about are not a great deal of help. Rarely in combat will you be in an apples to apples situation where plane X being 4 mph faster than plane y really comes into play. Relative energy is the important factor. While you are looking at your chart you are not seeing what he is doing that is affectin ghis energy relative to yours.
Having a working knowladge of the various planes is important yes but specifics that tight wont be worth the trouble to chart out in detail. You need to know that a P38 for example can zoom climb better than damned near anything out there so if on the merge he has dove 2k feet below you, dont think that just because you are fast as well you can just pull straight up and rope him. He will point his gawky looking monstrosity straight up and give you a .50cal enema before you can say WTF just Happened.
Knowing this little tidbit for example while flying you see him start his dive at about 3k out and you take an approiate action. Or you can be looking at your chart for the P38 column, look back up and say...."WTF did he go?" (answer being under the huge nose of your Dora and probably just pulling up for a nice belly shot through the floorboard of the soon to be distengrated Fokewulf.)
I understand what you are trying to accomplish bud. And I really do understand it. I am just trying to impress upon you that SA and reading energy has far more bearing on surving/winning than dry statistics.
Good Luck!