Puffy ack is like the IRS. Everyone hates it, but no one ever gets around to blowing it up.
The ack is fine as it is - it is way too easy to sink the cv group now as it is and it always ruins a good furball going, drives me nuts seeing a guy come in with a box of buffs and dive bomb it - they should die from ack as soon as they point the nose down
my 2 cents
NwBie
Um, no, sorry. First, what about all the people trying to furball with an enemy CV around? Puffy ack ain't like auto-ck, wirblewinds or even a manned 5 incher. If you are within 2 miles of the carrier, it can get you and it is absolutely random with no "rules"you can follow to avoid it (read: Don't try to follow planes into the autoack).
Second, it doesn't seem to hit lanc-stukas, a guy in a 5 incher usually has to do that, it seems to hit high, fast, fighters miles away who may not even know they are anywhere near a carrier. Third and finally, by its very tendency to begin puffing around high planes at very long ranges, it probably has needlessly given away the position of CVs too early many a time.