MT, there is a clear disconnect on this. You know it. You don't want to admit it, obviously.
There's no "gotcha" here. There's a problem here.
If the Gitmo Gang are entitled to habeas corpus and if as you said earlier the SC is saying the German POWs should have been entitled to habeas corpus in our courts... that idea is simply, totally, beyond all reason unworkable.
So in the next declared war, where ever or when ever, we capture hundreds of thousands of enemy soldiers like we did in WW2 and they all get their day in US court? You think THAT is in our Constitution? Really?