Sheesh CAP .. guess it all depends on who yer dealin with. Apple Valley Airport out in the High Desert, I'd call 'em the day before and have a 172 whenever I wanted it, with or without instructor depending on what I wanted to do.
Never was part of a 'club' .. -shrug- .. just called the guys I was learnin to fly with 
-GE aka Frank
well...in all honesty.....that arose because they only have 2 cessnas left. when i first joined the club, they had 4 172's, a 152(all of which i was checked out in), 6 warriors, and a couple twins. they've cut down to 1 172, and the 152, but still have all the pipers.
i won't transition to the pipers for now, as a lot of the ntsb reports i read are low time pilota that transitioned to pipers.....and i only have 207 hours. i know it seems kinda silly and anal, but it's my way of not becoming an ntsb report. besides....i honestly like the way cessnas fly.
i willl someday own my own airplane....that's why i bought this shop. i didn't buy it to get rich. i bought it so i could have stuff i want. my own airplane if the first thing on that list.
