Would be cool to have a duelling cue from the lobby where you can pick your opponents or have a random matchup. I don't want the ladder/ranking/score type aspect of it.
I think that is just for ego stroking and probably discourages people with "lesser" skills from participating. Baldeagle's bracket already shows who the better sticks are.
Just having a fun fight win or lose should be reward enough.
I wouldn't associate the typical MA ranking aspect to a dueling ladder. There is no way to manipulate it. The topdogs will have to be very good sticks to be higher on the ladder. Competition should drive people to improve their flying, the mouthy types with ego's wouldn't dare step into the ladder with the badass sticks!
some "lesser" sticks should get paired with equals. Without the ladder system in place you will have no way of knowing the level the person your fighting is at. Hence noobies getting beat down or bullied by morally weak players.
I'll even go as far to say that if you can show me a top fighter pilot without an ego, i'll agree to having no ladder system.