I went through the same decision problem some time ago when my Thrustmaster stuff just couldn't be patched up any more.
I really wanted CH stuff, but they still don't have a good USB stick and throttle out yet. So I tried the Saitek x36 USB combination throttle and stick to use till CH came out with some good stuff.
What a surprise. I love this Saitek x36 and USB is the only way to go. I quickly junked my old rudder pedals and got a set of CH Pro USB Pedals. You'll love this combination. So far it's rock solid and easy to set up. Much better control.
Now I'm no longer waiting for CH to come out with something. I don't plan to change from this excellent Saitek stick.
You can download my Saitek x36 profile from the downloads page to get you started if you choose this excellent stick.
Ranger Bob