Maybe it's not for you or the folks you hang out with... otherwise you would all be in the SEA during events.
The Old style Ava and the SEA events are two different things. The old style was just furbal dogfights and the times I was in there was toward the lower altitudes.(which IMO is what defines a dueling arena). THE SEA wednesdays, on the otherhand, has objectives whether it be a fight, escort, bomb, jabo, and the LCA regularly flies there with numbers. The difference? The LCA didnt fly the AvA arena because it did not provide an objective (forward sweep, cap, escort, bomb, jabo). Dogfighting should be about knocking out all planes, not reupping low and get fast to a fight, rinse repeat. It also should be about pushing down the enemy, get a cap, so the other forces can get in. Historical context in entirety 24/7.
Want AvA historical situations and just dogfight? Fine, then propose that the objective is to reduce the enemy's airplane availability at an airbase. If a base has 20 aircraft, and one gets shot down, there's 19 left. The airfield with 0 airplanes changes sides, and the dogfight continues. All until the war is won by the enemy who has moved the battlefront the most. Now that would be a purpose of dogfighting in a historical arena match-up.
The new AvA setup now provides an objective and some have started to enjoy this arena (fighter engagement, escort, bomb, jabo).