Ya a turkey gun and a home defense gun are at opposite ends of the spectrum.
shamus
No, they are not at different ends of the spectrum. The difference between the two is the choke tubes. Nothing more. Yeah, a person can get all tacti-coolio with all the BS gadgets, or he could buy himself a decent Remington, Browning, Mossberg, or other such legit non fad gun (a.k.a. Benelli), and have plenty of cash left over for a camo wrap, extra choke tubes, and some different kinds of ammo. A home defense shotgun does not have to have an extended mag tube, an 18in barrel, a pistol grip, or other such stuff.
I have a close friend who uses a Browning A500 for pheasant, duck, goose, turkey and deer hunting. The only thing he changes is the choke tubes, installs sights on his 24in barrel for slug use, and he adds the camo wrap for turkey. He stores it in his bedroom and is probably about #2 on his list of "go to" guns when things go bump in the night (#1 being a pistol).
I vote for a Remington 870. A very tried and true design with loads of experience and company support behind it. Also, there are MANY accessories out there available to fine tune it to anything you want or need and then some.