Ink, do you have the standard Saitek pedals or the combat pedals?
Oh, and to answer the op's question the Thrustmaster T16000 stick seems to get good marks at a reasonable price. (around $50)
I used a CH Fighterstick for many years, and I had no problems with it. They can be found new for around $100.
I now use a Warthog, and it's a nice stick, but very expensive. They can be found for around $430.