On the Axis side, IMO the 190-D9 catches it best, then the A model 190s, then the Ta-152. The 152 doesn't dive like the others, but as with anything that can dive it's a matter of being in the right place at the right time to catch it and the guns are nice if you can get a shot on him.
P51 or any jug will do the job. F4Us aren't terrible at it, but not as good as the P51 or P47s.
Personally my first choice would be a D9, then an M jug, then the P51, then any of the others. Depending on your personal preferences, any of those 3 could be interchanged IMO.
Wiley.