Hitech,
It's your business. You do whatever you think will least affect your bottom line.
If it was me, and it was my business, I wouldn't have an O' Club, to be honest. When you walk into a CVS, do you bring in your life size made in China Trump Cardboard cutout? Normal people will answer "No, I go there for XYZ, not political points". The same should apply here. You come to this BBS in order to talk about planes and tanks and the applicability of the head on pass in whatever ride the other guy HO'd you with.... not to affirm your own political biases with other degenerates. The same should apply to your product here.
Screw the BS that can and will affect the number of dollar bills rolling in your bank account. The O'Club can and will hit your bottom line, as it currently sits with suspended rules. It is obvious that people can't be adults 24/7. You don't need to play babysitter or placate a viewpoint to a customer. Just shut the crap down, say deal with it and work on the actual game that actually pays you. This O'club does not pay your bills, and is only a headache. So I'd get rid of it, or make the banhammer real big.
Of course you could have a different opinion, and say that traffic on your site means everything..... I'd disagree, but that's up to you. As it stands, I've stopped coming here as much due to the insanity; basically I check this once a week now. And yes, it has affected how I view other players I see on the actual game....which I suspect, isn't unusual.