Author Topic: Current radar settings  (Read 1585 times)

Offline AKIron

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 15394
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #60 on: Yesterday at 08:19:36 AM »
My second point being don't try to translate spotting an enemy in a simulation to real life without understanding there is a big difference.
Here we put salt on Margaritas, not sidewalks.

Offline LilMak

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1651
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #61 on: Yesterday at 08:54:51 AM »
Nope, the problem isn't that simple at all.

MoL
It is, in fact, that simple. Simply draw in how far an AH pilot can identify friend from foe in the MA to 6k. What it’s been from day one. I don’t care about what happens in DCS or Grand Theft Auto.

It’s one thing to see a dot on the horizon. It’s something completely different to positively identify that dot and plot it on the clipboard for everyone to see. Part of institution of these adjustments was to pull back how much real time information is given while balancing out the ability to find combat.

A couple nights ago I looked right, didn’t see anything, and then there was a bomber icon on my clipboard. The icon was about five or six miles out. I flew to it, didn’t see anything, and figured out it was a goon sitting on the ground. The problem with the “seen contacts” being extended so far is that the slant vertical visibility I have from my cockpit. It basically covers everything from the ground to infinity and there is no window where any NOE or high aircraft can sneak past me and, by clipboard extension, anyone else on my team. Had the “seen contacts” been drawn into 3.4 miles, I never would’ve been able to find that poor goon. Had I flown over it at a 3.4 mile range, there’s a chance that he might’ve been hidden by my cowling and/or wings. Now, if the goal is simply to paint everything on the clipboard at 20 second intervals, just do it. No need to make it a “seen contact.” As of right now, every piece of manned equipment has the ability to paint “seen contacts” on the clipboard at 3/4 the coverage of a radar ring. Given the typical distance between bases in the MA, it’s effectively providing zero avenues for approaching enemy airspace without being “seen” regardless of altitude.

If we’re not going to bring it in from 7.5 miles, then I think there needs to be delay added to how long I look at a patch of sky before it gets reported. So, if I just happen to look over my shoulder for a second, I don’t paint everything on the clipboard for 20 square miles. But that makes everything more complicated.

The simplest solution is just to draw “seen contacts” to icon range. It’s easy to understand and still provides the ability to find combat without overly hampering the strategy of non-fighter aircraft. Do that and I’m happy with the radar compromise and will let my arguments rest.
« Last Edit: Yesterday at 09:03:08 AM by LilMak »
"When caught by the enemy in large force the best policy is to fight like hell until you can decide what to do next."
~Hub Zemke
P-47 pilot 56th Fighter Group.

Offline atlau

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1263
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #62 on: Yesterday at 10:29:03 AM »
I don't know if reducing SA has been beneficial. It seems to further favor high speed high alt fighters blowing thru. It would be interesting to compare kill and aircraft stats to previous tours.

Offline Animl-AW

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 7718
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #63 on: Yesterday at 12:28:45 PM »
This catering to one player is way out of hand

More is never enough. Solve this problem there will be a new one the next day

Enough already
Get over it
AH Tech Hangar
Windows Gaming Tweaks

Offline Mol

  • Zinc Member
  • *
  • Posts: 28
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #64 on: Yesterday at 12:46:49 PM »
If we’re not going to bring it in from 7.5 miles, then I think there needs to be delay added

Just checked the arena settings after todays update.

It looks as though the SeenPlaneRange is currently set at 5.1 miles with a 20 second delay.

Things change faster than I can keep up LOL

MoL
Man of Leisure (MoL)

Offline Eagler

  • Radioactive Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 20484
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #65 on: Yesterday at 12:55:39 PM »
Just checked the arena settings after todays update.

It looks as though the SeenPlaneRange is currently set at 5.1 miles with a 20 second delay.

Things change faster than I can keep up LOL

MoL

Sounds like an interesting setting..

Eagler
Intel Core i7-13700KF | GIGABYTE Z790 AORUS Elite AX | 64GB G.Skill DDR5 | 16GB GIGABYTE RTX 4070 Ti Super | 850 watt ps | Pimax Crystal Super | Warthog stick | TM1600 throttle | VKB Mk.V Rudder

Offline Lazerr

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 5340
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #66 on: Yesterday at 05:50:39 PM »
Sounds like an interesting setting..

Eagler

I think 5 is perfect for this, maybe even 4. 

If you set it to icon range, you basically have the same dar as before, minus having to be looking in that direction.

Haven't tried to kill a radar tower yet.. if its a still the same setting prior to these changes, its too soft.

Offline Badboy

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1258
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #67 on: Yesterday at 06:29:20 PM »
I don't know if reducing SA has been beneficial. It seems to further favor high speed high alt fighters blowing thru. It would be interesting to compare kill and aircraft stats to previous tours.

A good point, it got me thinking.

There's another aspect to this discussion that I think deserves consideration, and that's the influence of gameplay on the visibility settings we prefer.

Aces High is a unique combination of air combat simulation and strategic warfare. Players can pursue very different objectives, and those objectives sometimes create conflicting preferences about how the game should work.

For example, fighter pilots generally want to find enemy aircraft and engage them. For them, good visibility and information about enemy activity help create opportunities for combat.

On the other hand, players flying bombers, ground attack aircraft or operating vehicles may have very different priorities. They can achieve high scores and rankings by destroying ground targets, factories, radar installations and other strategic objectives. For many of those missions, the ideal outcome is to reach the target undetected, destroy it or capture it without ever encountering an enemy player.

In real warfare that's obviously desirable. Accomplishing your objectives without suffering losses is a success. But whether that's equally desirable in a multiplayer combat game is another question.

I've recently seen the MA with around 20 players online, all apparently pursuing their own objectives with almost no combat occurring between them. Everyone may be achieving something, contributing to the war effort, but with very little or no direct interaction between the players.

That raises an important question about what makes Aces High enjoyable and keeps players coming back.

The strategic element is valuable, but I would argue that it works best when it creates opportunities for combat. Bombing raids provide opportunities for interception, ground attacks generate defensive responses, and battles for territory bring opposing forces together. In my view, the strategic game and the combat simulation should complement each other.

The difficulty arises when the most effective way of achieving objectives is also to avoid contact with other players. The scoring and ranking systems can reward activities that produce little or no direct combat. That's not necessarily wrong, but it can create incentives that conflict with the interests of players who primarily come online to fight.

I suspect this conflict of interests influences our preferences about visibility. Players who want to find combat are likely to favour better detection, while those who want to complete missions without interception may prefer greater opportunities for concealment. Neither preference is inherently bad or even unreasonable, and I'm not suggesting that anyone advocating shorter detection ranges necessarily has that motive.

There's also the question of realism. Concealment, surprise and reconnaissance are all important aspects of warfare. Aircraft operating at low altitude against a terrain background should sometimes be difficult to detect, and terrain masking should provide real opportunities for avoiding observation.

But equally, military forces employ observers, reconnaissance and communications specifically to locate and report enemy activity. More observers generally provide better coverage, and pilots can communicate sightings directly through voice or text, irrespective of what appears on the clipboard. Restricting automatic reports doesn't eliminate those advantages.

Ultimately, I think we're dealing with a gameplay balance problem rather than simply a question of visual acuity.

Particularly with the relatively small player population we have today, finding opponents and generating encounters is important. If we make enemy activity more difficult to locate, we risk creating even more situations where players are online with fewer opportunities to encounter one another.

In real warfare, most military personnel spent only a small proportion of their time actually fighting. Reproducing that level of inactivity might be historically realistic, but it wouldn't necessarily make for enjoyable gameplay. There's an important distinction between making combat itself realistic and reproducing the historically low frequency of combat.

I believe that more opportunities for meaningful player interaction generally make Aces High more enjoyable, encouraging existing players to stay and new players to subscribe. More players then create more opportunities for interaction, producing a virtuous cycle that benefits everyone.

Unfortunately, the reverse is also possible. Fewer encounters can make the game less enjoyable, causing players to leave, which further reduces opportunities for interaction. That becomes a vicious cycle of declining player numbers and activity.

Of course, stealth and strategic operations are important parts of the game, and combat shouldn't be unavoidable. But we need to be careful that changes intended to improve realism or protect particular styles of play don't inadvertently reduce the interaction that makes multiplayer gaming attractive.

The objective should be realistic combat, not necessarily a realistic scarcity of combat.

For me, the priority should be a system that preserves realistic opportunities for concealment while encouraging encounters, interceptions, defensive responses and combat.

After all, the central attraction of a multiplayer air combat game is surely the opportunity to engage other human players. If we make it increasingly easy for everyone to avoid one another, we risk undermining the very thing that makes multiplayer combat different from flying offline.

We all have strong views about what's realistic and what we'd personally prefer, but are those preferences necessarily what's best for the game as a whole?

Badboy
The Damned (est. 1988)
  • AH Training Corps - Retired
  • Air Warrior Trainer - Retired

Offline hitech

  • Administrator
  • Administrator
  • *****
  • Posts: 12687
      • http://www.hitechcreations.com
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #68 on: Yesterday at 08:44:08 PM »
bad boys right up which is rather good condensed to my words. Aceshigh is a game that's meant to be fun and fair ,war is meant to be neither.

HiTech

Offline hazmatt

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2609
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #69 on: Yesterday at 08:52:28 PM »
I haven't played other games.   Do they light up the "seen" enemy contact on a map that all other players can see?

Depends on game. Some don't have icons at all. Some you have to mark on the map. Some do light up an enemy contact for the team but not in the way that AH3 does. Even on the ones that do light up for the team it is still possible to terrain mask and to come up from below or behind somebody or to close in at such a high speed that you're on top of them before you are detected.

Offline Rubicon

  • Zinc Member
  • *
  • Posts: 43
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #70 on: Yesterday at 08:57:09 PM »
I have enjoyed the changes and look forward to seeing what the latest iteration brings.

I play only for fighter combat.  I have no idea how bombing works and even my jabo bombing skills are incredibly bad, I am here to shoot at other planes.  My poor colour vision means the ground game is unplayable for me, I simply cannot distinguish between a tank and a bush  :)

I have enjoyed the less complete information given by the clipboard.  I have been bounced a few times and bounced a few.  It adds more excitement IMO.
In game name = Fess

Offline Dadtallica

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2670
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #71 on: Yesterday at 09:34:37 PM »
Also liking the new changes after much complaining lol.

Casting my vote for smaller dots…
My Videos @NightspanNavigatorProductions

Back in 2022 after a loooooong break from 2010. Old name Ratpack, same for the BBS. Old squads, Excaliburs, 172nd Rabid Dawgs.

Offline Eagler

  • Radioactive Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 20484
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #72 on: Today at 06:41:54 AM »
Variable enemy icon range setting...set by the player..changeable b4 each sortie..

Where the shorter the range setting the higher the kill points for each victory..

Just throwing it out..

Eagler
Intel Core i7-13700KF | GIGABYTE Z790 AORUS Elite AX | 64GB G.Skill DDR5 | 16GB GIGABYTE RTX 4070 Ti Super | 850 watt ps | Pimax Crystal Super | Warthog stick | TM1600 throttle | VKB Mk.V Rudder

Online thndregg

  • Platinum Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 4151
Re: Current radar settings
« Reply #73 on: Today at 07:49:14 AM »
Just observation from last night's sortie - myself, PorkyPig, Anvil8, and York in sets of B17's on our way into and out of Rookland strat..

Dar functionality served well enough to keep me looking around. We had contacts at our 30K alt. One P51 did get the sneak in on our 12 as we were dealing with attacks from other vectors and took a bomber out during the first of several shootouts.

I think it works. There's just the right amount of suspense and anticipation of an attack to make it challenging and keep my interest and SA up. I like it.  :cool:
Skeleton Crew is **Selectively Recruiting** B29 Bomber Crews. Contact: thndrEGG-CO or MATAHARI-XO in game via PM.