I agree with Westy on having news updates from Pyro as opposed to him having to deal with issues like this. But I also respectfully disagree that this is a minor issue. It's something that was bound to come up, and certainly will again.
People do not like to be "shut-up" or even told to. Put yourself in any other social gathering at almost any level and imagine someone forcing you to "shut-up" when it's not warranted. What are you most likely to do?
There is apparently a need for moderators, although I don't know for the world why with the .squelch command. I must also say that I think with the official statement that there is a "grey area", there's gonna be more ruffled feathers than many would think, especially now that most know the moderators exist. Not at all trying to cause trouble here, but think about it. Imagine your local police enforcing "grey" laws. (Ok sorry, I watch "Cops" too but you get my drift)
I watched ch#1 carefully last night with this moderator issue in mind and I'll tell you, I saw PLENTY of "reasons" IN MY OWN OPINION (very conservative) that warranted a quick mute in comparison to what happened the other night. Hell there's been a few times I should have been muted, as with most! But it's no big deal till it happens to YOU.
Having moderators without specific guidlines to follow is asking for trouble. Players not having specific guidlines to follow WITH the presence of moderators is even worse. I still firmly refuse to believe bias can be avoided and I truly think bias played a huge role in Wulf's mute.
Lastly, if this has to be, then why not shut both off at the onset of "hostilities", it's an easy concept really. I use the .squelch command as soon as someone really starts to get on my nerves, because I know if I don't, being the hothead I am, I'm gonna bite back. If I didn't, I'd be muted about 1/2 the time.
Just 2 cents
SwampRat